All poems

近现代 近现代 · 诗 Poem

我用残损的手掌

With My Wounded Palm

戴望舒

Dai Wangshu

抗战War of Resistance 爱国Patriotic 土地The earth 名篇Masterpiece

我用残损的手掌,摸索这广大的土地:这一角已变成灰烬,那一角只是血和泥;
这一片湖该是我的家乡,春天,堤上繁花如锦障,嫩柳枝折断有奇异的芬芳。

With my wounded palm I grope over this vast land:
this corner has become ash, that corner is nothing but blood and mud;
this stretch of lake should be my home — spring, and along the bank flowers like brocade screens, and torn willow twigs with a strange fragrance.
Listen

Meaning

Written in a Hong Kong prison cell in July 1942, the poem takes one physical act — a wounded hand, the hand of a man who was tortured, moving across a map of China — and makes it the whole poem. Where the hand touches, the country answers: a corner is ash, another is blood and mud, and one stretch of water is recognized, with a catch in the throat, as the speaker's hometown. The meaning is that a damaged body still loves the damaged land, and that the same ground holds both the ruined present and the remembered spring. The tenderness of the ending is not a contradiction of the suffering; it is the reason the suffering matters.

我用残损的手掌,摸索这广大的土地:这一角已经变成灰烬,那一角只是血和泥;这一片湖该是我的家乡,春天,堤上繁花如锦障,嫩柳枝折断有奇异的芬芳。

Appreciation

[Plain Paraphrase] The opening sentence is a single long metaphor. Instead of saying 'I think of my country', the poet puts a hand on the map and lets the hand travel: one corner, then another, then a lake. What the hand finds is the poem: ash, blood and mud, and then a sudden remembered spring. [Structure] The movement is exactly the movement of a hand. It starts at the whole ('this vast land') and breaks into pieces ('this corner', 'that corner', 'this stretch of lake'); each piece is a separate touch, separated from the last by a semicolon, which is why that mark matters more than any rhyme. The poem stops mid-gesture, at the scent of a broken willow twig, rather than concluding. [Imagery] The poem's first sense is touch, not sight — 'grope' sets the register, and every image that follows is something a hand would feel: ash is dry, mud is wet and heavy, a broken twig gives off scent. The colour scheme has two poles, grey and dark against bright: ash, blood, mud against 'flowers like brocade screens'. That contrast is the poem's whole argument. The word 'should' in 'this stretch of lake should be my home' is the emotional centre; it is a hedge, and through the hedge the reader hears the split between what memory holds and what the map now shows.

【白话串讲】 戴望舒写《我用残损的手掌》:“我用残损的手掌,摸索这广大的土地”——“这一角已变成灰烬,那一角只是血和泥”——“这一片湖该是我的家乡”——“只有那辽远的一角依然完整”——他写抗战中的中国。 【意象与手法】 以「手掌摸索地图」为统摄全诗的隐喻,触觉意象贯穿始终;沦陷区之痛与家乡之美强烈对照;语言沉痛而温润,象征与写实交织 【情感与主旨】 戴望舒于狱中写祖国之痛与家乡之美,表达对沦陷土地的悲悯、对侵略者的控诉,以及残损之躯仍深爱这片土地的赤子深情 【名句点睛】 常考「我用残损的手掌,摸索这广大的土地」的象征手法——残损的手掌既是狱中受刑的身体,也是饱受摧残而不屈的民族精神的化身

Background

Dai Wangshu (1905–1950) was born in Hangzhou and made his name with 'The Lane of Rain', which earned him the title 'the poet of the rain-lane'. He studied in France, absorbed the French symbolists, and wrote in a soft, melancholy manner. After the war with Japan broke out he turned to public and national verse; in 1938 he went to Hong Kong to edit the literary page of a newspaper andcampaign for resistance. When Hong Kong fell in December 1941 he was arrested for his anti-Japanese writing, and he spent months in prison, beaten and seriously ill, writing poems in which the injury of his hands is literal. This poem from July 1942 is the most famous of them; it was collected in 'The Years of Calamity'. At that time much of North, East and Central China had already fallen, so the map the poet's hand traverses was, for his readers, a live newspaper.

戴望舒(1905—1950),原名戴朝采,浙江杭州人,中国现代诗人,因《雨巷》得名「雨巷诗人」,是三十年代象征派诗歌的代表。他早年留学法国,受法国象征派影响,诗风细腻忧郁;抗战爆发后投身救亡,1938年赴香港主编《星岛日报》副刊,宣传抗日。1941年12月太平洋战争爆发,日军占领香港,戴望舒因从事抗日宣传被捕入狱,在狱中遭受严刑拷打,身染重疾,几濒于死。此诗即写于狱中(1942年7月),「残损的手掌」是狱中受刑致伤的手掌的实录——诗人以这只伤痕累累的手掌抚摸地图上的祖国,写下了这首诗。当时中华大地大半沦陷:东北、华北、华东相继失守,山河破碎,人民在血与火中呻吟;戴望舒本人身陷囹圄,个人的伤残与民族的苦难在此诗中叠合为一。此诗后收入诗集《灾难的岁月》,是戴望舒由象征主义转向现实关怀的代表作,也是抗战诗歌中最深沉的篇章之一。此诗写于铁窗之内,而诗中无一丝哀乞之态,唯有对土地执着的抚摸与眷恋,故能于血泪之中见出赤子之心。

Art

The poem's central device is a metaphor that runs the whole length of the text: the hand becomes the country's boundary, and the country becomes a body part. Because the metaphor is maintained rather than announced, nothing in the poem needs to say 'China' twice — the reader learns the identification from the touch itself. The second device is its economy of nouns: ash, blood, mud, lake, bank, flowers, willow. There is not one adjective of praise and not one epithet of abuse; the horror of the middle lines works precisely because it is a catalogue of plain things. The third device is the shift of register between the first two lines, which are public and violent, and the last, which is private and domestic — and the shift is signalled only by the word 'spring'. Finally, the closing image smuggles pain back in through an innocent detail: a broken twig still smells, just as this wounded palm still loves.

此诗为自由体新诗,其艺术核心在于一个统摄全篇的隐喻——「手掌摸索土地」:诗人不写「思念祖国」的抽象抒情,而把全部情感落实为一只残损的手掌在祖国地图上的摸索,触觉由此成为全诗的第一感官。结构上,全诗以「摸索」为线索展开:先是「这一角已变成灰烬,那一角只是血和泥」的沦陷之痛,再是「这一片湖该是我的家乡」的回忆之美,由现实到记忆、由痛到爱,对照中推进情感。表现手法上,象征与写实交融:手掌既是被摧残的身体(写实),也是民族受难而不屈的化身(象征);灰烬、血和泥既是沦陷区景象的写实,也是国破的象征;家乡湖堤的繁花锦障、嫩柳芬芳则是美好记忆的写实,也是理想祖国的象征。人称上以「我」的独白贯穿,但「我」的伤残与「土地」的破碎互为镜像,个人抒情升华为民族抒情。语言上沉痛而不哀靡:「摸索」「灰烬」「血和泥」沉重有力,「繁花如锦障」「奇异的芬芳」温润明亮,一暗一明的色调构成全诗的两极。

Allusions

The poem uses no classical allusion, but it hangs on older traditions. The gesture of a hand on the land continues the Chinese dwelling-place sentiment that runs from the 'Odes' to Qu Yuan; the difference is that Dai Wangshu makes the hand a blind one — it 'gropes' rather than looks, which turns a romantic homecoming into a difficult version of it. The ruined corner answers the line of national-ruin poems by Lu You and Wen Tianxia, 'the remnant people's tears are spent in the dust of the Hu', and the ash is the modern form of 'the country broken like a wind-blown willow fluff'. The lake, the bank, the flowering willow descend from the whole southern-towns tradition of Jiangnan memory — the lines of Wei Zhuang about spring water greener than heaven. And the groping is a blind man's act, quietly in line with the Qu Yuan formula 'the road is long and hard, and I will seek above and below'. What the poem does is translate these inherited images into a modern, hurt body.

此诗不用典故,而以意象与象征承载文化意蕴,其深层可上溯中国文学的土地书写传统。其一是「手掌抚摸土地」的意象:承中国「乡土」情结——从《诗经》「昔我往矣,杨柳依依」的故园之思,到屈原「长太息以掩涕兮,哀民生之多艰」的忧国之情,戴望舒以手掌代目、代足,「摸索」而非「遥望」,把对祖国的爱化为最直接的身体接触,正合中国人「故土如母」的文化心理;其二是「这一角已变成灰烬」的沦陷书写:承南宋陆游「遗民泪尽胡尘里」、文天祥「山河破碎风飘絮」的国破之痛,灰烬与血泥正是「破碎山河」的现代转译;其三是「这一片湖该是我的家乡」:湖、堤、繁花、嫩柳构成江南的典型意象,暗承韦庄「春水碧于天,画船听雨眠」的江南记忆与历代游子望乡的母题,「该是」二字以虚拟语气写记忆与现实的断裂,更见沉痛;其四是「摸索」的盲人式姿态:暗喻国难中摸索前路的民族处境,与《楚辞》「路漫漫其修远兮,吾将上下而求索」的求索精神一脉相通。全诗以现代诗艺写古老的情感母题,故能于抗战诗中别具深厚。

Commentary

'With My Wounded Palm' is a classic of the war poetry of resistance and the turning point of Dai Wangshu's career. Critics have long read the poem as the moment when the 'rain-lane' poet of private reverie became a poet of national mourning; it is placed alongside Ai Qing's 'I Love This Land' and Tian Jian's 'To the Fighters' as one of the peaks of the period. The strength of the image is widely noted: the wound of the body is the wound of the nation, and the groping hand is the love of a son who cannot see. After 1942 the poem travelled through every anthology and textbook, and 'the wounded palm' became one of the most quoted images of the literature of the war. Its tone — anguish without despair — is what has kept it readable: it does not plead, and it does not boast; it only keeps touching until it finds something still sweet.

《我用残损的手掌》是抗战诗歌的经典之作,也是戴望舒诗歌生涯的转折点与巅峰。文学史上,戴望舒以《雨巷》成名,诗风唯美忧郁;此诗标志着他由个人内心的低吟转向民族苦难的歌唱,其语言仍保有象征主义的精致,而情感已注入时代的血泪——研究者普遍认为此诗是「雨巷诗人」蜕变为「土地诗人」的关键文本,与艾青《我爱这土地》、田间《给战斗者》共同构成抗战诗歌的三大高峰。思想上,「残损的手掌」这一意象具有强大的象征能量:身体之残即民族之伤,手掌之摸索即赤子之爱,戴望舒以个体的伤残写出了整个民族的受难与不屈,被论者称为「以身体书写民族」的典范。传播上,此诗自1942年问世后广为传诵,入选多种教材与选本,「残损的手掌」成为抗日战争文学中最著名的意象之一;1999年中央电视台《诗歌散文》节目曾配乐朗诵,影响及于当代。此诗以沉痛而不绝望的基调,证明诗歌在最黑暗的年代依然保有照亮人心的力量。

Prosody

Form Free verse in modern Chinese; no fixed metre, rhythm comes from the inner movement of feeling自由体新诗,长句抒情,无固定格律,以情感的内在节奏为韵律
Rhyme There is no rhyme. The music is made by the length of the sentences: the first two clauses are short and heavy, as if the hand were falling on paper, while the closing clause lengthens and softens, so that the sound slows down exactly as the emotion does.全诗不押韵,节奏由句式的伸缩与标点的调度构成:「我用残损的手掌,摸索这广大的土地:」以两个对称的短句开篇,沉重而凝滞;「这一角已变成灰烬,那一角只是血和泥;」以「这一角/那一角」的对称排比推进,如手掌的两次触摸;「春天,堤上繁花如锦障,嫩柳枝折断有奇异的芬芳」则转为舒缓流丽的长句,声调由沉痛转温润。
Tone pattern The voice is a first-person monologue, and it is held low throughout. 'This corner has become ash' is clipped and hard; 'this stretch of lake should be my home' slackens and turns tender; the frequent commas make the whole reading drag, which reproduces the slowness of a hand feeling its way over a map.语气以第一人称的内心独白贯穿,沉痛而不哀靡:「这一角已变成灰烬」短促沉重,如泣如诉;「那一角只是血和泥」以「只是」的轻读收束,愈轻愈痛;「春天,堤上繁花如锦障」以「春天」二字单独成顿,如一声叹息后转入回忆,语调骤然明亮温存。标点的运用极讲究:冒号拉开土地的全景,分号衔接痛与痛、痛与美,逗号的频繁使用造成缓慢凝滞的摸索节奏。
Reading note The sound of the poem is the sound of touching. It opens with two butted clauses — 'with my wounded palm / I grope over this vast land' — each falling like a palm on paper. The lines of ruin are short and struck, separated only by semicolons, so that the reader hears two consecutive touches without a pause for breath: that is the rhythm of the groping. Then 'spring' arrives alone, as if after a sob, and the final sentence unfolds at length, slowing until it stops on a scent. Punctuation here is the real metronome: the colon opens the landscape, the semicolons join pain to pain and pain to beauty, and the commas reproduce the drag of the hand. Colloquial words — 'this corner', 'should be' — keep the whole thing close to speech, so that the poem reads like a murmur rather than a declamation. This is the free verse at its best: inner rhythm where there is no outer measure.《我用残损的手掌》的声律之美,在于以自由诗的节奏精确对应「摸索」的触觉与情感的起伏。全诗无韵,而韵律自存,其韵律由三方面构成:其一是句式的伸缩——开篇「我用残损的手掌,摸索这广大的土地:」两句对称而沉重,节奏如掌落纸上;写沦陷的「这一角已变成灰烬,那一角只是血和泥;」以对称排比推进,两句之间只有一个分号的停顿,如两次连续的触摸,急促而沉痛;写家乡的「春天,堤上繁花如锦障,嫩柳枝折断有奇异的芬芳」则以长句舒卷,节奏骤然放缓放柔,如目光在记忆里流连。其二是标点的调度——全诗以冒号拉开「土地」的全景,以分号衔接痛与痛、痛与美的转场,以逗号制造缓慢凝滞的摸索节奏,标点成为节奏的隐形指挥。其三是口语化的语气——「这一角」「那一角」「该是」等口语词汇使抒情带上传告与独白的亲切,沉痛而不隔膜。全诗由「摸索」的沉重起,经「灰烬血泥」的沉痛,转「繁花芬芳」的温润,声情随手掌的移动而起伏,恰如一首以触觉写成的无韵之歌,是自由诗「以内在节奏为韵律」的典范,也证明戴望舒即使转入现实主题,其语言仍保有象征派诗人的精致。

Line by line

我用残损的手掌,摸索这广大的土地:

With my wounded palm I grope over this vast land: the whole poem's metaphor is set in nine characters — a damaged hand, a blind touch, and a country open like a book.

我用残损的手掌,摸索着这广大的土地:

With my shattered palm I grope over this vast land:

开篇两句是统摄全诗的隐喻核心,一出手即奠定整首诗的基调与视角。「我用残损的手掌」七个字交代了抒情主体最鲜明的特征:手掌是残损的——狱中受刑的伤口,是身体的痛楚,也是民族受难的标记;「摸索这广大的土地」写动作:不写「抚摸」「接触」,而写「摸索」,一字之差境界迥异——「摸索」是伤残者以触觉辨识世界的姿态,带着小心翼翼、带着痛,也带着盲人般的专注与深情,彷佛要把祖国的每一寸山河都摸进心里。冒号的使用尤见匠心:一个冒号拉开「土地」的全景,以下「这一角」「那一角」「这一片湖」皆由此引出,手掌的移动轨迹即全诗的结构线索。「我」与「土地」、「残损」与「广大」形成双重对照:手越残损,土地越广大;身越伤痛,爱越深沉。两句即完成个人与民族、身体与土地的叠合,是抗战诗歌中罕见的以触觉立骨的起笔。

The palm. With my shattered palm I grope over this vast land. The shattered palm groping the vast land is the opening. To have groped with the shattered palm would be a groping; the with-my-shattered-palm-i-grope-over-this-vast-land is the groping.

这一角已变成灰烬,那一角只是血和泥;

This corner has become ash, that corner is nothing but blood and mud: the first rest-stop of the groping hand, and the plainest, heaviest lines in the poem.

这一角已经变成灰烬,那一角只剩下血和泥;

This corner has turned to ash, that corner is only blood and mud;

此句写沦陷与战火中的土地,是「摸索」的第一个落点,也是全诗最沉痛的写实。「这一角已变成灰烬」写被焚毁的土地:灰烬是燃烧后的余骸,一座城、一片田、一个家园化为灰烬,一个「已」字写尽既成事实的惨烈与无可挽回;「那一角只是血和泥」写被血浸透的土地:血与泥混合,是战场与屠场的景象,一个「只」字极言其惨——没有别的,只剩血和泥。两句以「这一角/那一角」对举,把「广大」的土地具体化为处处疮痍;以「灰烬/血和泥」并置,从焚烧与杀戮两个维度写尽沦陷之痛。句末的分号尤为讲究:它不是句号,意味着沉痛的抚摸还要继续,家乡的记忆还在后面——分号在声情上造成「欲哭而强忍」的停顿,为下文的转折蓄势。此句以最素朴的名词(灰烬、血、泥)写最惨烈的现实,不呐喊而自震撼,正是「白描的控诉」。

The ash. This corner has turned to ash, that corner is only blood and mud. The ash corner and the blood-and-mud corner are the grim first touch. To have turned to ash would be a turning; the this-corner-has-turned-to-ash-that-corner-is-only-blood-and-mud is the turning.

这一片湖该是我的家乡,春天,堤上繁花如锦障,嫩柳枝折断有奇异的芬芳。

This stretch of lake should be my home — spring, and along the bank flowers like brocade screens, and torn willow twigs with a strange fragrance: the turn of the poem, from ruin back to a remembered tenderness.

这一片湖应该是我的家乡,春天,堤上繁花像锦障一样铺展,嫩柳枝折断后发出奇异的芬芳。

This lake must be my home: in spring, blossoms on the dike spread like a brocade screen, broken willow shoots give off a strange fragrance.

此句是情感的转折点,由沦陷之痛转入家乡之美,是全诗最温润明亮的段落。「这一片湖该是我的家乡」中的「该」字是全句的眼:不是「是」而是「该是」——家乡本该如此美好,而现实已不容确认,一个「该」字写尽记忆与现实的断裂,希望与怅惘并生。「春天,堤上繁花如锦障」写记忆中的家乡:湖、堤、繁花构成江南水乡的典型画卷,「锦障」以锦绣帷帐喻繁花铺展,明亮华丽;「嫩柳枝折断有奇异的芬芳」则以一个极细微的感官细节写家乡的气息——柳枝折断,青涩的芬芳扑面,这个「折断」的细节尤妙:它既是记忆的实感,又暗合「残损」的意象,美中带着轻微的痛。两句以「繁花/嫩柳」的明丽对照前句「灰烬/血泥」的惨烈,把「该是」的家园之美与「已是」的破碎之痛并置,爱之愈深,痛之愈切。此段是抗战诗中罕见的以美写痛的笔法,家乡越美,失陷越痛。

The lake. This lake must be my home: in spring, blossoms on the dike spread like a brocade screen, broken willow shoots give off a strange fragrance. The this-lake-must-be-my-home and the brocade-screen blossoms and the fragrant broken willow are the memory. To have must-be-my-home'd the lake would be a must; the this-lake-must-be-my-home-in-spring-blossoms-on-the-dike-spread-like-a-brocade-screen-broken-willow-shoots-give-off-a-strange-fragrance is the must.

Study

Word focus

残损 In 'with my wounded palm', the word means maimed or damaged — it is stronger than 'injured' and harsher than 'broken'. It names the actual torture of the prison, and it also suggests slow depletion, so the hand is not only hurt once but worn down. As the key image-word of the poem it carries both the body and the nation at once. 「我用残损的手掌」之「残损」,是全诗的核心意象词,也是诗人对自身处境的凝练命名。「残损」不同于「伤残」「残缺」:「伤残」偏于伤痛的即时性,「残缺」偏于形状的不完整,而「残损」兼有二者——既写受伤致残的身体事实(狱中酷刑的实录),又含「受损」「损耗」的渐进意味,暗喻民族元气在战火中的消耗。更深处,「残损」与「手掌」的组合构成全诗的象征核心:手掌是创造与抚摸的器官,残损的手掌是被摧毁的创造力的象征,也是受难而不肯放下的爱的象征——手已残损,仍在摸索,正是「残躯犹抱山河」的赤子之姿。这个词还统摄了全诗的触觉基调:残损的手掌摸过灰烬、血泥、繁花、嫩柳,每一次接触都是疼痛与温存的混合。「残损」由此超越对身体的描写,成为民族受难状态的总体象征,与后文艾青的「嘶哑的喉咙」(《我爱这土地》)并列为抗战诗歌中最具代表性的「残缺意象」。
摸索 In 'I grope over this vast land', 'grope' is chosen against 'stroke' or 'touch'. To grope is to feel one's way in darkness, and this implies both the prison dark and the national night; it also implies search, as in the old formula 'I will seek above and below'. Because the verb governs the whole structure — every 'this corner' is a stop of the groping hand — it is the single word on which the poem turns. 「摸索这广大的土地」之「摸索」,是全诗动作的核心,也是诗人选择的第一感官动词。「摸索」不同于「抚摸」「触摸」:「抚摸」是温存的爱抚,「触摸」是短暂的接触,而「摸索」是在看不见或看不清的情况下以触觉探路——它暗示着诗人所处的黑暗(狱中)与国土的暗夜,也暗示着国难中摸索前进的民族处境。这个词的深意有四:其一,它是盲人式的姿态,以触代视,愈显专注与深情——看不见也要摸,摸到的每一寸都是山河;其二,它暗含「探求」之义,承屈原「上下而求索」的传统,把爱国的抒情升华为求索的姿态;其三,它与「残损」相配,残损的手掌摸索广大土地,愈是残损愈见摸索的艰难与固执;其四,它规定全诗以触觉为纲的结构——「这一角」「那一角」「这一片湖」都是手掌移动的轨迹。「摸索」一词,以最朴素的动词承载了全诗的动作、姿态与精神,是戴望舒炼词的典范。
锦障 In 'flowers like brocade screens', the word originally means a screen of embroidered silk, such as the wealthy used to set up along a road. Dai Wangshu uses it for the flowers along the bank, so a spring bloom is described in the vocabulary of luxury. The effect is to make the memory of home brilliant and slightly unreal, which is why the brightness hurts: the more beautiful the screen, the more terrible the ash in front of it. 「堤上繁花如锦障」之「锦障」,是此诗最华美的喻体,也是记忆中的家乡最明亮的色调。「锦障」本指锦绣的帷帐(古人游春时张设的锦帐),戴望舒以之喻堤上繁花:繁花连片铺展,如锦绣帷幕横陈堤岸,一个「锦」字写尽花色的绚丽丰美,「障」字则写出花阵的绵延遮蔽——繁花多到如帷幕般将堤岸整个罩住,正是江南春深的极致景象。此喻的妙处在于以富贵之物(锦)写自然之景(花),把记忆中的家乡写得富丽明媚,与现实的「灰烬」「血和泥」形成色彩与质地的双重反差:锦障之柔美对灰烬之焦枯,繁花之绚烂对血泥之惨烈。同时,「锦障」的华丽正见记忆的滤镜——正因为现实已碎,记忆才格外鲜亮;「该是」的家乡越美,「已是」的破碎越痛。一个「锦障」,为全诗最痛的部分垫上了最亮的底色,以美写痛、以亮写暗,正是此诗艺术深度的所在。

Related Reading

我爱这土地 I Love This Land 艾青 · 同为抗战时期「土地」主题的巅峰之作,一以手掌一以鸟喉写土地之爱 Both peak works of the war on the theme of the land; one through a bird's throat, one through a hand

Ai Qing sings the land with a hoarse throat — 'then I die, and even my feathers rot inside the land' — and Dai Wangshu feels it with a maimed palm. Both were written in the darkest years, both use a damaged organ as the image of loving a ruined country, and both end by leaving the love intact. The difference is in temperature: Ai Qing is open and burning, Dai Wangshu is contained and dark. Read together they show the two poles of the war poetry — the cry and the touch.

艾青《我爱这土地》与戴望舒《我用残损的手掌》并称抗战诗坛的「土地双璧」:一者以「嘶哑的喉咙」歌唱土地,一者以「残损的手掌」摸索土地,都以受难的肢体写深沉的爱国。两诗都写于国难最重之时(1938/1942),都以「残损」「嘶哑」的残缺意象写民族受难,都以「为什么我的眼里常含泪水」「该是我的家乡」的深情句收束。差异在于:艾青以鸟喻人,情感直露悲壮(「然后我死了,连羽毛也腐烂在土地里面」);戴望舒以手掌喻身,情感内敛沉痛(灰烬、血泥、芬芳的细腻触觉)。艾青的歌是嘶哑的呐喊,戴望舒的摸是无言的触碰。两诗并读,可见抗战诗歌抒情的两极:一者如火,一者如水,而「对这土地爱得深沉」是共同的底色。

死水 The Dead Water 闻一多 · 同为写国难与沉沦的象征名篇,一写腐水一写残掌,皆以意象写尽民族的痛 Both use images of the nation's ruin; one a stinking ditch, one ash and blood

Wen Yiduo's 'The Dead Water' of 1926 sees a whole society in a stagnant ditch and calls for its ugliness to be used as a fertilizer — the satire is against himself and his time. Dai Wangshu's poem of 1942 stands in front of the same ruin but refuses the ironies: the hand only reaches out and recognises a lake. The two read as the two faces of modern Chinese poetry's response to a broken country — Wen Yiduo's cold indictment and Dai Wangshu's hot tenderness — and the difference in their dates marks the difference between denouncing a situation and living inside it.

闻一多《死水》作于1926年,「这是一沟绝望的死水,清风吹不起半点漪沦」,以臭水沟象征军阀混战下的中国社会;戴望舒《我用残损的手掌》作于1942年狱中,以残损的手掌摸索破碎的山河。两诗都以「丑」与「痛」的意象写民族的沉沦,都以冷峻的笔触不加粉饰:死水之臭、灰烬血泥之惨,皆以直面惨淡的勇气入诗。差异在于:闻一多以反讽写绝望中的愤怒(「不如让它丑恶来开垦」),戴望舒以触摸写痛楚中的深情(「摸索这广大的土地」);《死水》的象征是封闭自足的(一沟死水即整个社会),《残损的手掌》的象征是敞开的(手掌划过不同的土地)。两诗并读,可见中国现代诗写国难的两副面孔:闻一多的批判之冷与戴望舒的眷恋之深,一者使人警醒,一者使人落泪。

乡愁 Nostalgia (Xiangchou) 余光中 · 同为以身体动作写故国之思的现代名篇,一为摸索一为投递,一北一南隔代呼应 Related reading

Compare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.

余光中《乡愁》「小时候,乡愁是一枚小小的邮票……而现在,乡愁是一湾浅浅的海峡」,以邮票、船票、坟墓、海峡四个意象写乡愁的深化,与《我用残损的手掌》同属以具体物象承载故国之思的现代诗名篇。两诗的深层相通处在于:都把抽象的家国之思落实为可触可感的身体经验——戴望舒以手掌「摸索」土地,余光中以「我在这头,母亲在那头」的空间阻隔写乡愁;都以「残缺」为情感底色——手掌残损、海峡阻隔。差异在于:戴望舒写的是国土破碎之痛(大陆,1942),情感沉痛悲壮;余光中写的是两岸隔绝之思(台湾,1972),情感温柔怅惘;一为「山河在手」的执念,一为「一湾海峡」的遥望。两诗相隔三十年,一北一南,恰可见「土地之爱」这一母题在现代汉语诗中的延续与变奏。