五代 Five Dynasties · 诗 Poem
小重山·春到长门春草青
Little Double Height: Spring Comes to the Long Gate
春到长门春草青,玉阶华露滴,月胧明。
东风吹断紫箫声,宫漏促,帘外晓啼莺。
愁极梦难成,红妆流宿泪,不胜情。
手挼裙带绕阶行,思君切,罗幌暗尘生。
The east wind breaks off the purple-flute song; the palace clepsydra urges; beyond the curtain a dawn oriole cries.
Grief at its height, the dream will not form; her red makeup streams with overnight tears, past bearing.
She twists her skirt-sash and paces the steps; her longing for you is acute; on the silk blinds dusk dust gathers.
Meaning
A palace lady's spring insomnia, pacing her empty rooms in longing for the emperor.
春天来到长门宫,阶前春草一片青翠;玉石阶上凝聚着华美的露珠滴落,月色朦胧而明亮。东风把紫箫的吹奏声吹断,宫中漏声急促,帘外传来拂晓啼莺。手揉着裙带在阶前绕行,思念君王情切,罗帐上已暗暗积满灰尘。
Appreciation
Spring greens the Long Gate but brings no visitor; the flute fails, the oriole cries, and the lady paces with her sash, her only company the dust on the blind. The poem is insomnia set to music.
【白话串讲】 薛昭蕴写小重山:“春到长门春草青,玉阶华露滴,月胧明”。“东风吹断紫箫声,宫漏促”——“愁极梦难成,红妆流宿泪,不胜情”——“手挼裙带绕阶行,思君切”——她写深宫怨妇的思念。 【意象与手法】以「长门」「春草」「宫漏啼莺」铺丽景写哀,「手挼裙带」写痴立,以景锁愁。 【情感与主旨】写深宫女子思君之切、长夜不眠的孤寂,花间宫怨以丽写哀的典型。 【名句点睛】「手挼裙带绕阶行」六字写尽辗转无寐,娇慵中见断肠。
Background
Xue Zhaoyun (fl. 9th c.) was one of the few women ci poets of the Five Dynasties. The 'Long Gate' is the palace of the discarded consort.
薛昭蕴,晚唐五代前蜀词人,于《花间集》中位列温庭筠、韦庄之后,其词多写闺情宫怨,风格秾丽婉约。《小重山·春到长门春草青》以「长门」这一经典宫怨符号领起,写失宠宫人春夜之孤寂。词中「春到长门春草青」暗用汉武帝陈皇后贬居长门宫、司马相如作《长门赋》之典,点明主人公的失宠身份;以下「玉阶华露滴,月胧明」「东风吹断紫箫声」「宫漏促,帘外晓啼莺」铺写春夜宫苑之景,下片「愁极梦难成」「手挼裙带绕阶行」则写思君之切、长夜不眠。全词约作于前蜀宫廷唱词盛行之时,是花间宫怨词中「以丽景写哀情」的典型,亦见薛昭蕴于闺怨一体中的婉妙笔致。薛昭蕴此词以长门为引,写失宠宫怨,在《花间集》中自成一凄婉面目。其虽为五代宫廷唱词,而所写孤寂之长夜,实已超越具体宫闱,具普遍性的人生失落之感。花间词多写闺情,薛氏此首以春景之丽反衬怨情之哀,章法典型而情致深婉。读此词,宜与温庭筠、韦庄同类之作并观,方见花间宫怨一体中薛昭蕴特有的清丽与含蓄,亦知五代宫廷词如何将政治失意化为艳情之美。
Art
Each line layers sight and sound - green grass, dripping dew, the broken flute, the crying oriole - into a portrait of sleepless, ornamented grief.
此词善以春宵丽景层层反衬宫怨之哀,景愈美而情愈孤。上片三转:起句「春到长门春草青」以青草满院长门写春来之景,温庭筠「草色入帘青」可参;「玉阶华露滴,月胧明」以露滴、月胧写春夜之静美;「东风吹断紫箫声,宫漏促,帘外晓啼莺」则于静中插入箫声、漏声、莺声,以声写寂,且「晓啼莺」暗点长夜将尽、人犹未眠。下片由景及人:「愁极梦难成」点题,「红妆流宿泪」写泪,「手挼裙带绕阶行」以动作写焦灼,「思君切,罗幌暗尘生」收以尘封之幌,见幽闭之久。全词景—声—人—情四层递进,疏密有致,是花间小令「设色秾丽而脉理清晰」的范例。上片写春宵丽景而以声衬寂,下片写思君之切而以态见哀,景情相生而脉理清晰。其于「春到长门春草青」以乐景起,「手挼裙带绕阶行」以痴态结,起结之间,由外而内、由景而人,章法暗合「先境后情」之序。花间小令最易流于堆垛,此词却能设色秾丽而脉络不乱,正见薛昭蕴于令曲结构之讲究,亦见五代宫廷词虽主艳情,而未尝废章法,非率尔应歌者可到。
Allusions
The Long Gate is the Han palace where the discarded Empress Chen lived; the purple flute and palace clepsydra mark the confines of court. The silk blind is the lady's seclusion.
「长门」典出汉武帝陈皇后失宠后居长门宫,司马相如为作《长门赋》以悟主,后世遂以「长门」为失宠宫怨的代称(如李白《长门怨》)。此词以「春到长门」开篇,即定失宠幽闭之旨。「紫箫」暗用萧史弄玉吹箫乘凤之典(《列仙传》),本为夫妻和谐之象,此处「吹断」则反写箫声零落、欢会难期。「宫漏」为宫中计时之器,漏声「促」写夜短心长。「罗幌」即罗帐,班婕妤《怨歌行》「弃捐箧笥中,恩情中道绝」之被弃意可参。数典皆宫怨传统意象,经薛昭蕴融裁,自然贴合失宠宫人之境,可见花间词「裁古入艳」之法。上述长门、紫箫、宫漏、罗幌诸典,皆宫怨传统中久经熔铸之故实。薛昭蕴信手用之,各安其所:以长门写失宠,以紫箫写欢断,以宫漏写夜长,以罗幌写久闭,无一闲笔。花间词用典每尚隐秀,此词于秾丽中暗藏典实,使艳情具历史厚度。学者读之,不妨循典以求意,自见失宠宫怨如何在千年书写中凝聚为一套稳定的意象符号,而薛词正此传统中清婉的一环。
Commentary
A fine example of the 'palace grievance' in early ci; the restraint of the imagery heightens the desolation.
薛昭蕴词见录于赵崇祚《花间集》,为花间派重要一家。近人论花间词,每以温庭筠为密丽之祖、韦庄为清疏之别,而薛昭蕴介于二者之间,以「婉丽而不失清浅」见长(参李冰若《花间集评注》对薛词之评骘)。此词「手挼裙带绕阶行」之痴态,与温庭筠「懒起画蛾眉」之慵、韦庄「不忍觑花间」之直,同写闺怨而各极其态。其「春到长门春草青」显受李白《长门怨》「秋草秋萤飞」及温词影响,可见花间宫怨一脉的承传。今人读之,当于玉阶月胧、帘外莺啼的秾丽中,体贴失宠宫人长夜不眠的孤寂,亦可见五代宫廷词将政治失意化为艳情的特殊视角。薛昭蕴词见录于《花间集》,为花间重要一家,近人论花间宫怨每及之。此词「手挼裙带绕阶行」之痴态,与温庭筠之慵、韦庄之直同写闺怨而各极其态。汤显祖辈虽未专评薛词,而后世选家多许其婉丽。今人读之,当于玉阶月胧、帘外莺啼的秾丽中,体贴失宠宫人长夜不眠之孤寂,亦可见五代宫廷词将政治失意化为艳情的特殊视角,其文献与审美价值俱未可轻。
Prosody
Line by line
春到长门春草青,玉阶华露滴,月胧明。
Spring comes to the Long Gate, the grass is green; on the jade steps bright dew drips, the moon dim and clear.
春天来到长门宫,阶前春草一片青翠;玉石阶上凝聚着华美的露珠滴落,月色朦胧而明亮。
Spring has come to the Changmen palace; the spring grass is green. Rich dew drips on the jade steps; the moon shines dim and clear.
起句三叠景语,由大及细,由色及声光。「春到长门春草青」以「长门」点题、「春草青」设色,暗用陈皇后典故,于明媚中藏失宠之悲——春草年年青,而君恩不再;「玉阶华露滴」以露滴写静夜之幽,玉阶本为君所临幸之地,今唯露滴空阶;「月胧明」以月色朦胧收束,胧明之间,孤影自见。三句无一字写怨,而长门、空阶、胧月已自道尽幽闭之哀,是「以乐景写哀」的高境,亦见花间词「不著怨字而怨自深」的设色本领。
The opening layers three scenes, from broad to fine, from color to sound and light. 'Spring has come to the Changmen palace; the spring grass is green' uses 'Changmen' for the theme and 'spring grass green' for color, secretly using the allusion to Empress Chen—beneath the brightness lies the grief of disfavor: the spring grass greens every year, yet the royal favor returns no more. 'Rich dew drips on the jade steps' uses dripping dew to write the stillness of the night, the jade steps by nature the place the monarch visited, now only dew dripping on the empty stair. 'The moon shines dim and clear' closes in the misty moonlight, between dim and clear the lone figure seen of itself. Three lines not one word of resentment, yet the Changmen, the empty steps, and the misty moon already tell the grief of seclusion, the high realm of 'grief through joyous scenery,' and the Huajian skill of 'resentment without the word resentment.'
东风吹断紫箫声,宫漏促,帘外晓啼莺。
The east wind breaks off the purple-flute song; the palace clepsydra urges; beyond the curtain a dawn oriole cries.
东风把紫箫的吹奏声吹断,宫中漏声急促,帘外传来拂晓啼莺。
The east wind breaks off the purple flute's sound; the palace water clock hurries; beyond the curtain the dawn oriole calls.
此句以三声叠写长夜将尽之寂。「东风吹断紫箫声」以风断箫写欢会难续、声不成调,紫箫本喻夫妻和鸣,一「断」字见恩断;「宫漏促」以漏声之急反衬人心之缓——夜短而愁长;「帘外晓啼莺」以破晓莺啼收束上片,点出人竟彻夜未眠,而晓色已至,春宵苦短、幽怨方长。三景皆声,以声写寂,是花间词「以闹写静」的妙法。由箫断而漏促而莺晓,时间悄然推移,而主人公之孤坐如故,章法极细而情致极婉。
This line layers three sounds to write the stillness of the dying long night. 'The east wind breaks off the purple flute's sound' uses the wind breaking the flute to write the difficulty of continuing the meeting, the tune broken—of old the purple flute signaled the harmony of husband and wife, and the single word 'breaks' writes the severed favor. 'The palace water clock hurries' sets the urgency of the clepsydra against the slowness of the heart—the night short, the grief long. 'Beyond the curtain the dawn oriole calls' closes the first stanza in the dawn oriole, pointing out that the woman has sat all night unsleeping, and the dawn is already come, the spring night brief while the secret grief is long. Three scenes all sound, writing stillness through sound, the Huajian method of 'writing stillness through noise.' From the broken flute to the hurried clock to the dawn oriole, time passes imperceptibly while the protagonist sits as before, the craft most fine and the feeling most tender.
手挼裙带绕阶行,思君切,罗幌暗尘生。
She twists her skirt-sash and paces the steps; her longing for you is acute; on the silk blinds dusk dust gathers.
手揉着裙带在阶前绕行,思念君王情切,罗帐上已暗暗积满灰尘。
My hands crumple the girdle as I walk the steps; my longing for you is keen; on the silk curtain, dust has silently gathered.
结片由景及人,写失宠者的焦灼与久闭。「手挼裙带绕阶行」以一「挼」(揉搓)字写无人之处的下意识动作,状思极无措之态,与上文「愁极梦难成」呼应;「思君切」三字直点题旨,质朴有力;「罗幌暗尘生」以帐上积尘写幽闭之久、恩幸之绝,尘生则人去,最是凄凉。全词至此由外景收归内室,由春宵之美收归罗幌之暗,丽景与孤尘对照,哀感倍增。是花间宫怨「以艳笔写枯寂」的范例,结得含蓄而力重。
The closing moves from scene to person, writing the disquiet and long seclusion of the neglected woman. 'My hands crumple the girdle as I walk the steps' uses the single word 'crumple' (rubbing) for the unconscious action where no one is near, picturing the helplessness of extreme longing, echoing the foregoing 'grief at its height, dreams hard to come.' 'My longing for you is keen' three characters directly point the theme, plain and forceful. 'On the silk curtain, dust has silently gathered' uses the dust on the curtain to write the length of seclusion and the end of favor—dust gathered means the person gone, the bleakest sight. The whole now closes from outer scene to inner chamber, from the beauty of the spring night to the darkness of the silk curtain, the bright scene set against the dusty desolation, grief doubled. It is the Huajian model of 'writing bleakness in gorgeous brush,' reserved in the close yet weighty.
Study
Word focus
Related Reading
Compare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
李白《长门怨》「天回北斗挂西楼,金屋无人萤火流。月光欲到长门殿,别作深宫一段愁」与此词同以「长门」写失宠宫怨,且皆借月色、深宫写孤寂。李诗为七言绝句,气象清迥,以「萤火流」「别作愁」写空寂;薛词为花间小令,设色秾丽,以「玉阶露」「罗幌尘」写幽闭。一唐诗之疏、一五代词之密,同写长门而体性迥异,恰见宫怨题材自唐入五代由「清」转「艳」的演变,亦见同一符号在不同文体中的不同声口。
菩萨蛮·小山重叠金明灭 菩萨蛮·小山重叠金明灭 温庭筠 · 同出花间,宫怨闺怨一脉 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
温庭筠《菩萨蛮》「小山重叠金明灭,鬓云欲度香腮雪……懒起画蛾眉,弄妆梳洗迟」与薛昭蕴此词同出《花间集》,同写女子孤寂情态,且皆以动作(温之「弄妆」、薛之「挼裙带」)传心理。温词秾密隐晦,意象叠绣;薛词婉丽稍清,脉络更显。二家并观,可见花间派内部「温韦薛」的风格光谱——薛昭蕴正介于温之密与韦之疏之间,其宫怨小令可视作温庭筠宫怨笔法的承与变。
小重山·春透水波明 小重山·春透水波明 李清照 · 同调写春怨,五代与两宋之异 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
李清照《小重山》「春透水波明,寒峭花枝瘦……梦回山枕隐花钿」亦以《小重山》写春闺之情,与薛昭蕴此词同调同性。李词为两宋之际的清照体,愁而能雅、怨而不淫;薛词为五代花间,丽而能婉。二词同以春景起、以闺情结,而一北宋南渡前之闲愁、一五代宫廷之失宠,时代与身份各异其哀。并观可见《小重山》一体自晚唐五代到两宋的承传,以及宫怨向闺怨泛化的题材流变。