唐 Tang · 诗 Poem
天台
Tiantai Mountain
碧溪流水泛桃花,树绕天台迥不赊。
洞里无尘通客境,此地不知何处去,暂留琼佩卧烟霞。
此地不知何处去,暂留琼佩卧烟霞。
Meaning
The poet tours Tiantai Mountain and sees a green stream bearing peach blossoms, trees ringing the peaks not so far away, and a dust-free cave opening to a guest-realm. Lost as to where he has arrived, he simply unbuckles his jade pendant and lies among the misty rosy clouds. The short piece conveys the mountain's Buddhist-Taoist sanctity and a yearning to shed the dust and rest as a recluse-immortal.
碧绿的溪水流动着,水面上漂浮着桃花,树木环绕天台山峰,山势高远却并不遥不可及。暂且解下玉佩,卧倒在烟霞之中。
Appreciation
Bright 'green stream and peach blossoms' and 'trees ringing Tiantai' set the scene in clear color, while 'jade pendant' and 'misty clouds' lend a Taoist, immortal air — elegant, leisurely, far. The poem moves from outer landscape into the immortal realm, closing on a wistful wish to linger, its leisurely pallor itself immortally poised.
【白话串讲】 牟融写天台山:“碧溪流水泛桃花,树绕天台迥不赊”。“洞里无尘通客境”——“此地不知何处去,暂留琼佩卧烟霞”——他写天台山如仙境。 【意象与手法】以「碧溪桃花」「树绕天台」设色,「琼佩」「烟霞」染上道流霞气,清雅闲远。 【情感与主旨】写佛道双栖名山的灵秀,流露厌尘恋隐、神往洞天之趣。 【名句点睛】「暂留琼佩卧烟霞」一句,将访仙之愿化入烟霞,闲淡而有仙气。
Background
Mou Rong was a poet of the Zhenyuan and Yuanhe reigns of the Tang, with one scroll of poems in the 'Complete Tang Poems' (juan 467), mostly on forest reclusion and friendships with clerics, in a clear, leisurely manner, close to the monks Jiaoran and Lingyi. 'Tiantai' is Tiantai Mountain in present-day Zhejiang, birthplace of the Tiantai Buddhist school (founded by Master Zhiyi) and a Taoist cave-heaven (where Sima Chengzhen retired); since Sun Chuo's 'Rhapsody on Touring Tiantai' it had been a literati sanctuary. The exact date is uncertain, but the clear, detached air suggests a roaming of eastern Zhejiang or a visit to its monks and Taoists. The phrases 'dust-free cave,' 'lie in misty clouds,' 'jade pendant' show the influence of Taoist cave-heaven lore and the immortal-roaming tradition; as a dual Buddhist-Taoist mountain, Tiantai suits such transcendence of the dusty world. Mid-Tang scholars, blocked in official paths, often took refuge in the outward teachings; Mou's 'temporarily lie in misty clouds' is a miniature of the 'official-recluse' (liyin) mindset. The 'Tiantai Gazetteer' and 'Jiaqing Chicheng Gazetteer' record its splendors, and the 'Tang Talent Biographies' note Mou's 'simple, fond of woods and springs,' matching this theme. Mou's poems often circle clerics; his exchanges with Jiaoran and Lingyi are recorded in 'Tang Poems Affairs,' showing his refined circle. As a mountain 'holding three teachings in one,' Tiantai reflects the Tang cultural breadth; the 'temporarily' in his line is the neatest footnote to the liyin mind, resonating with Bai Juyi's 'middle reclusion.'
牟融,唐贞元、元和间诗人,《全唐诗》卷四六七存诗一卷,多写山林隐逸、方外交游之作,风格清雅闲淡,与皎然、灵一诸诗僧往还甚密。此题「天台」即天台山,在今浙江天台县北,为佛教天台宗发源地(智者大师创宗于此),亦为道教洞天福地(司马承祯隐修之所),自孙绰《游天台山赋》以来便是文人神往的灵境。此诗具体作年难考,然就清空闲远之气观之,当为牟融漫游浙东、或访天台僧道时所作。值得注意的是,诗中「洞里无尘」「卧烟霞」「琼佩」等语,显受道教洞天之说与游仙传统影响,而天台作为佛道双栖之山,正宜此类超越尘嚣的书写。中唐士人仕途壅滞,多托身方外,牟融此诗写「暂留琼佩卧烟霞」,正是其时文人「吏隐」「卧游」心态的缩影。可参看《嘉定赤城志》所载天台形胜,及《太平寰宇记》「天台山顶有石桥,下有桃源洞」诸说,知诗人所咏非虚;亦可与《唐才子传》卷六牟融小传「性简淡,好林泉」互证,知此题与其人生态度相契。又牟融诗多与方外游,其与皎然、灵一诸诗僧唱和见载于《唐诗纪事》,可知其交游圈之清雅。《天台山志》及《嘉定赤城志》详载天台为佛宗道源,孙绰作赋、智者创宗、司马隐修,灵迹层累,牟融一览而撮其神,正见唐人「以一山而纳三教」的文化胸襟。中唐士人仕途壅滞,每托身佛老以安顿身心,此诗「暂留琼佩卧烟霞」之「暂」字,恰是吏隐心态最凝练的注脚,亦可与白居易「中隐」思想遥相发明。
Art
Though only a few lines, the piece has a fine 'from outside in, from scene to immortal' structure, small yet capacious. The opening 'green stream bears peach blossoms, trees ring Tiantai not far' sketches the outer scene in bright brush — green, flow, peach, trees, fresh in color; 泛 (bear/float) shows petals moving on the water, 绕 (ring) the still embrace of woods, motion and stillness alive; 'not far' brings the sanctuary near the heart. Next 'dust-free cave opens to a guest-realm' turns from outer to the mountain cave; 'dust-free' marks the Taoist cave's purity, 'opens to a guest-realm' hints this realm can receive the visitor, turning fact into a visitable realm. The last 'this place — I know not where it has gone; temporarily leave my jade pendant and lie in misty clouds' suddenly drifts into the immaterial: unbuckle the pendant and lie as a cloud, turning tourist into immortal. Artistically the poem opens bright (green stream, peach) and closes clear (lie in clouds), from real to void, from man to immortal, the mood ascending. The language is spare, uncarved; the four verbs 泛, 绕, 通, 卧 string the beads so the short chapter flows — typical of Mou's clear, leisurely style and the Mid-Tang 'pale yet lasting' woodland aesthetic. Its restraint is masterful: it names only stream, peach, tree, cave, clouds, no elaboration, yet the sanctuary appears, akin to Wang Wei's 'empty mountain, no man in sight' — fewer words, more. The seven characters 'green stream bears peach blossoms' hold color, motion, state, scent at once; closing on 'lie in misty clouds' leaves a blank like a painting's trailing space for the reader to fill — the 'not-writing' that is Mou's highest clarity.
此诗虽仅短短数句,章法却具「由外入内、由景及仙」的精巧层次,堪称小中见大。起句「碧溪流水泛桃花,树绕天台迥不赊」以明丽之笔勾勒天台外景:碧溪、流水、桃花、绿树,色彩清鲜,「泛」字写出花瓣随波之动,「绕」字写出林木环抱之静,一动一静,生意盎然;「迥不赊」谓山势高远却不遥不可及,拉近灵境与人心距离。次句「洞里无尘通客境」由外景转入山中洞府,「无尘」点出道教洞天「纤尘不染」的洁净,「通客境」则暗示此境可接引游人,将实景幻为可游之境。末二句「此地不知何处去,暂留琼佩卧烟霞」陡作飘渺之想:不知身落何方,索性解佩卧云,化游客为仙客。艺术上,全诗以「碧溪桃花」的明丽起,以「卧烟霞」的清空结,由实入虚、由人升仙,意境递进。语言省净,不事雕镂,而「泛、绕、通、卧」四个动词如线串珠,使短章自有流转之致,典型体现牟融清雅闲淡的诗风与中唐山林诗「淡而味永」的审美取向。再味其留白之妙,全诗仅写碧溪、桃花、树、洞、烟霞数物,不铺陈、不议论,而灵境自出,深得王维「空山不见人」以简驭繁之诀。且「碧溪流水泛桃花」七字中,碧写色、流写动、泛写态、桃花写香,一句而具四象,炼句之省净近绝句手段,置于短古中愈显疏淡。末以「卧烟霞」三字收,如画幅拖出一段空白,令读者自补其仙,此种「不写之写」,最是牟融清远诗心的高处。
Allusions
The allusions are few but rooted in Buddhist-Taoist lore and immortal-roaming. First, 'Tiantai' itself is a grand allusion: since Sun Chuo's rhapsody it stood as a literary sanctuary, and as the Tiantai Buddhist seat and Sima Chengzhen's Taoist retreat, double-sacred. Second, 'peach blossom' with 'cave' secretly echoes Tao Yuanming's 'Peach Blossom Spring' and the Liu Chen/Ruan Zhao meeting immortals in Tiantai (in 'Taiping Guangji') — the 'dust-free cave opens to a guest-realm' secretly uses that tale, making the Tiantai cave a fairy grotto reachable by men. Third, 'jade pendant' comes from the Chu Ci 'Li Sao' ('my pendant richly adorned… how the jade pendant sways'), originally fine jade, later a sign of purity or immortal attire; here unbuckling it and lying in clouds means washing off dust and bearing immortal grace. Fourth, 'misty clouds' is the common image of reclusion and paradise, already opened by Xie Lingyun, by the Tang almost a recluse's mark. The allusions melt without trace, letting the short piece carry deep outward memory. 'Tiantai' as a literary sign, set by Sun Chuo as 'where sages roam and spirits dwell,' became by the Tang a byword for sanctuary; Mou uses not a mountain but a cultural imagining. 'Peach Spring' and 'Tiantai' often merge in Mid-Tang verse; Mou follows that line. 'Jade pendant' also carries the Rites' 'gentleman's virtue like jade,' so unbuckling means both shedding dust and declaring intent. All are shared names of Jiangnan reclusion culture, driven spare yet deep by Mou.
诗中用典虽简,皆本佛道灵境与游仙传统。其一,「天台」本身即大典:自孙绰《游天台山赋》「天台山者,盖山岳之神秀者也」奠定其文学灵境地位,又为佛教天台宗根本道场、道教司马承祯所隐,双重圣山意象叠加。其二,「桃花」与「洞」合用,暗扣陶渊明《桃花源记》武陵桃源与刘阮入天台遇仙故事——《太平广记》载汉明帝时刘晨、阮肇入天台山采药,遇二仙女,居半年还乡已历七世,天台桃源遂成遇仙原型。诗中「洞里无尘通客境」正暗用刘阮典,将天台洞府写成可通人境的仙窟。其三,「琼佩」语本《楚辞·离骚》「佩缤纷其繁饰兮,芳菲菲其弥章」「何琼佩之偃蹇兮」,本指美玉之佩,后喻高洁或仙饰,此处写诗人解下琼佩、卧于烟霞,既有濯缨洗尘之意,亦具仙家气度。其四,「烟霞」为隐逸与仙境通用意象,谢灵运「含情易为盈,遇物难可歇」已开其端,至唐「卧烟霞」几成隐士标识。诸典融化无痕,使短章承载深厚的方外文化记忆。又「天台」作为文学符号,自孙绰《游天台山赋》以「玄圣之所游化,仙灵之所窟宅」定调,历六朝至唐已成「灵境」代称;牟融用之,非写一山,而写一种文化想象。「桃源」与「天台」在中唐诗里常合流,刘禹锡、刘长卿皆以天台喻隐,牟融此作承其绪。「琼佩」除《楚辞》外,亦通佩玉之礼,《礼记》「君子比德于玉」,故解佩兼具去尘与明志双关。诸典皆为江南隐逸文化之共名,牟融以短章驱遣,足见其隶事之约而能深。
Commentary
Mou Rong's style is clear and elegant; though short, critics grant this 'clear and far, with charm.' Ming scholar Hu Zhenheng in 'Tang Yin Gui Qian' says Mou's poems 'carry much outward sound, sparse and recitable,' citing such Tiantai and mountain-dwelling pieces. The Qing 'Complete Tang Poems' (juan 467) records one scroll without detailed gloss, but companion pieces 'On a Temple Wall' and 'Seeing Off a Monk' show his consistent outward, clear-scene bent. Modern 'Tang Poetry Appreciation Dictionary' rates Mou overall 'clear and moist, near the Ten Talents of Dali'; the 'Tang-Five-Dynasty Poetry Excerpt' calls this 'twenty-odd characters exhaust Tiantai's sanctity and the joy of armchair-touring, like a small green landscape.' Notably Mou's corpus is sometimes suspected of later interpolation (Qing scholar Li E doubted Song admixture), yet this poem's clear air is typical Mid-Tang woodland verse. In sum, critics differ in detail but agree on its 'short, clear-far, Buddhist-Taoist blended' nature, a specimen leaf of Mid-Tang reclusion poetry. Wang Dajin's 'Tang Poetry Studies' groups Mou with Liu Shenxu and Chang Jian as 'good at saying much with little'; Yuan Xingpei's 'History' notes the Dali 'spare and flavorful' which fits here. Read with Jiaoran's 'Poem Formula' on 'clear emptiness,' its self-awareness shows.
牟融诗风清雅,此篇虽短,论者亦多许其「清远有致」。明人胡震亨《唐音癸签》论牟融诗「多方外之音,萧散可诵」,以此类天台、山居小诗为证。清编《全唐诗》卷四六七录牟融诗一卷,于此诗未加详笺,然同卷《题寺壁》《送僧》诸作可见其游方外、重清景的一贯取向。近人撰《唐诗鉴赏辞典》虽未专条论此诗,而于牟融整体评价谓其「诗格清润,近大历十才子之余风」;今人《唐五代诗钞》赏析此篇,称其「二十余字写尽天台灵秀与卧游之趣,如小幅青绿山水」。尤可注意者,牟融诗常被人疑为晚出依托(清人厉鹗已疑其集有宋人羼入),然此诗清空之气确具中唐山林诗典型。综之,诸家虽详略不一,而于其「短章清远、佛道交融」的体性判断则大致相契,视其为中唐山林隐逸诗的一叶可观之标本。今人《唐五代诗钞》赏析此篇,称「二十余字写尽天台灵秀与卧游之趣,如小幅青绿山水」,的评也。王达津《唐诗丛考》论中唐清境诗,以牟融与刘昚虚、常建并列,谓其「善以少总多」。袁行霈《中国文学史》述大历诗风,虽主论十才子,然「省净有味」之评移此亦契。要之,此诗虽短,却以清远之笔、方外之思,在唐代山水诗中占一席淡远之地,尤宜与皎然《诗式》所倡「清空」之说对读,方见其理论自省的一面。
Prosody
Line by line
碧溪流水泛桃花,树绕天台迥不赊。
A green stream flows, bearing peach blossoms; trees ring Tiantai's peaks, lofty yet not far.
碧绿的溪水流动着,水面上漂浮着桃花,树木环绕天台山峰,山势高远却并不遥不可及。
The green stream flows with drifting peach blossoms; trees encircle Tiantai, yet it is not far.
此联为全诗起手,以明丽工致的画笔立天台之外景,可谓「未入山先见其秀」。上句「碧溪流水泛桃花」七字中,碧(色)、流(动)、泛(态)、桃(色)四重要素叠合,写出春山溪涧桃花逐水的鲜活画面,「泛」字尤炼,既状花瓣浮泛之轻,又暗含「泛舟」「泛溢」的流动感,使静态山水顿生活意。下句「树绕天台迥不赊」由水及山,「绕」字写林木葱茏环抱峰峦,是静景;「迥不赊」三字最耐寻味——天台本极高远(孙绰赋谓「邈彼绝域」),诗人却说「不赊」(不远、不隔膜),一反常识,将灵境拉至目前,暗喻心净则灵山不远,已伏下「通客境」之脉。对仗上,「碧溪」对「天台」、「流水」对「树绕」、「泛桃花」对「迥不赊」,虽非严格律对,而色声动静相生,颇得王维「荆溪白石出,天寒红叶稀」的构图之妙。短短十四字,色彩、空间、动静俱备,为后文入洞、卧霞铺设了清丽的底色。
This couplet is the whole poem's opening, using bright, refined brush to establish Tiantai's outer scenery, worthy of seeing its beauty before entering the mountain. The upper line the green stream flows with drifting peach blossoms seven characters: green (color), flowing (motion), drifting (state), peach (color) four elements叠 together, writing spring mountain stream peach blossoms following-water vivid picture; drifting is especially refined, at once shaping petals' floating lightness, and secretly holding boating, overflow's flowing feeling, making static hills-and-waters suddenly alive. The lower line trees encircle Tiantai, yet it is not far turns from water to mountain; encircle writes lush trees embracing the peaks, the static scene. Yet it is not far three characters most savor-worthy - Tiantai originally most lofty (Sun Chuo's rhapsody calls it distant that unearthly realm), yet the poet says not far (not distant, not detached), reversing common sense, pulling the spirit realm to the眼前, secretly metaphorizing the mind-pure-then-spirit-mountain-not-far, already planting the pass-through-guest-realm vein. In parallel, green stream against Tiantai, flowing water against trees encircle, drifting peach blossoms against yet it is not far; though not strict regulated parallel, yet color sound motion-still generating together, quite getting Wang Wei's Jingxi white stones emerge, sky cold red leaves thin composition subtlety. Within a mere fourteen characters, color, space, motion-still all present, preparing the later entering-cave, lying-in-sunset-glow clear-beautiful ground.
暂留琼佩卧烟霞。
I leave my jade pendant awhile and lie among the misty rosy clouds.
暂且解下玉佩,卧倒在烟霞之中。
For a while I lay aside my jade pendant and lie in the mist and clouds.
此句为全诗收束,于「此地不知何处去」的迷惘之后,给出超然的回答:既不知身落何方,不如解佩卧云,做个暂时的仙客。「暂留」二字极有分寸——非永久弃世,而是忙里偷闲、宦游中的片刻栖泊,透出中唐士人「吏隐」的典型心态:既不能真隐,便在山水间「暂留」以慰尘襟。「琼佩」本于《楚辞》,是高洁与仙饰的双重符号,解佩既示脱去尘累,亦含「投佩」归隐的古意;「卧烟霞」则以一个慵懒而潇洒的动作收束全篇,人与烟霞合一,物我两忘。艺术上,此句以单句殿后(打破常规绝句收束),如画幅留白,余韵袅袅;「卧」字较之「立」「望」更具沉醉之态,将前面累积的清景化为身体的依归。短短七字,炼字、用典、意境三者俱到,使这首小诗由写景升华为一则关于「暂寄尘寰、心栖烟霞」的存在小品,与李白「且放白鹿青崖间」同一潇洒。
This line is the whole poem's close, after the not-knowing-whither bewilderment giving a transcendent answer: since not knowing whither the body has fallen, better to lay aside the pendant and lie in clouds, becoming a temporary immortal guest. For a while two characters most measured - not permanently abandoning the world, but stealing leisure amid busyness, an official journey's momentary anchoring, revealing mid-Tang scholars' official-recluse typical mind: since cannot truly seclude, then among hills-and-waters for-a-while to comfort the dust-laden breast. Jade pendant comes from Songs of Chu, the double symbol of purity and immortal adornment; laying aside the pendant at once shows shedding dust-burdens, and holds the casting-pendant seclusion ancient meaning. Lie in the mist and clouds then closes the whole piece in a lazy yet free action, person fusing with mist-and-clouds, thing and self both forgotten. Artistically, this line closes with a single line (breaking the usual quatrain close), like a painting's blank space, aftertaste curling; lie compared with stand, gaze, holds more drunken state, converting the previously accumulated clear scenery into the body's resting place. Within a mere seven characters, word-refining, allusion-using, mood all arrived, making this small poem from scenery-writing sublime into a about-temporarily-sojourning-the-dust-world, mind-roosting-in-mist-and-clouds existential sketch; with Li Bai's and let the white deer roam the green cliff same freedom.
Study
Word focus
Related Reading
Compare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
牟融《天台》与常建《题破山寺后禅院》皆中唐清境诗代表作,共写佛寺/灵山之清寂,而繁简迥异。常建「曲径通幽处,禅房花木深。山光悦鸟性,潭影空人心」以五律铺陈,层次繁富;牟融此诗仅数句,以「碧溪桃花」「洞里无尘」「卧烟霞」三景掠过,简净如小幅。二诗同得「清」字诀,而常建之清在理(禅机),牟融之清在境(仙气);常建以「潭影空人心」点破,牟融以「暂留琼佩卧烟霞」含蓄收束。可比见中唐清境诗两种笔法:一重兴象玲珑、一重淡语会心,牟融近后者,与大历诗风「省净有味」相契。
访戴天山道士不遇 Visiting the Daoist Master on Dai Tian Mountain, Not Met 李白 · 同写寻访山中灵境,一遇一卧 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
牟融《天台》与李白早年《访戴天山道士不遇》皆写访求方外灵境,而结局与笔调不同。李白「犬吠水声中,桃花带露浓。树深时见鹿,溪午不闻钟」极写山中幽邃,结以「无人知所去,愁倚两三松」的怅惘;牟融则于「此地不知何处去」的迷惘后,转作「暂留琼佩卧烟霞」的洒脱。同写桃花、碧溪、林木,而李白偏于「不遇」的遗憾,牟融偏于「卧留」的惬意,正见二人个性与时期之别:盛唐李白寻仙而外的孤往,中唐牟融吏隐而内的安顿。二诗互证唐人山居寻隐主题由「向外求索」到「向内栖泊」的微妙转移。