All poems

唐 Tang · 诗 Poem

寄韬光禅师

Sent to the Chan Master Taoguang

白居易

Bai Juyi

一山门作两山门,两寺原从一寺分。
东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云。
前台花发后台见,上界钟声下界闻。
遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷。

One mountain gate serves as two mountain gates;
The two temples were once one temple, then divided.
The eastern ravine's water flows on to the western ravine's stream;
The southern mountain's clouds rise over the northern mountain's clouds.
When flowers bloom on the front terrace, they are seen from the rear terrace;
The bell of the upper realm is heard in the lower world.
Far I imagine where my master walks his path —
Heaven-scented osmanthus seeds fall thick and fast.
Listen

Meaning

Bai Juyi sends this poem to the Chan master Taoguang, who lived as a hermit on the mountains near West Lake. Using interlocking couplets in which every line is itself a matched pair, the poet describes the two neighboring temples that share one gate, one water, one cloud, one blossom, one bell — a landscape where all divisions dissolve. The poem closes by imagining the master's hermitage fragrant with falling osmanthus seeds, an image of the Buddhist Pure Land, turning a friendly letter in verse into a quiet meditation on the unity of all things.

一山门作两山门,两寺原从一寺分。东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云。前台花发后台见,上界钟声下界闻。遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷。

Appreciation

[Plain Paraphrase] One mountain gate does the work of two: the two temples were once a single monastery. The water of the eastern ravine flows into the western ravine; the clouds of the southern mountain rise over the northern mountain. Flowers blooming at the front terrace can be seen from the back; the bell of the upper realm is heard down in this world. Far away I imagine the place where you, my master, walk in the Way — and the heaven-scented osmanthus seeds fall in drifts. [Structure] The poem is a seven-character regulated verse of four couplets, and its structural marvel is that each of the first six lines is itself a couplet: one gate against two gates, two temples against one temple, east ravine against west ravine, south mountain against north mountain, front terrace against back terrace, upper realm against lower realm. Line after line turns on a pair of opposites, until the reader feels the whole landscape as a single web of correspondences. The final couplet breaks the pattern at last, turning from scene to person — the master walking his path beneath the falling seeds — and the whole poem closes in a drift of fragrance. [Imagery] The images are the mountain monastery at Hangzhou — gates, streams, clouds, flowers, bells — but every image comes in a matched pair, and every pair insists that the two sides are one: one water, one cloud, one sound reaching both realms. The poem's quiet point is Chan: distinctions are conventional, and the master's hermitage is where the drift of osmanthus seeds dissolves the boundary between this world and the Pure Land.

【白话串讲】 白居易写《寄韬光禅师》:“一山门作两山门,两寺原从一寺分”——“东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云”——“前台花发后台见,上界钟声下界闻”——“遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷”——他寄韬光禅师——天香桂子落纷纷。 【意象与手法】 “一山门作两山门,两寺原从一寺分”写两寺一源;“东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云”以对仗写山水之奇;“前台花发后台见,上界钟声下界闻”写花钟相通;结以“遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷”写天香桂子。空灵禅意。 【情感与主旨】 白居易寄韬光禅师之作,以工整的对仗写两寺山水相连的奇景,结以“天香桂子落纷纷”写禅境,是寄赠诗中的名篇。 【名句点睛】 常考“东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云”写山水之奇;“遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷”写禅境。

Background

Bai Juyi (772–846), courtesy name Letian, was born in Xinzheng in Henan, the leading poet of the Middle Tang and the guiding spirit of the New Music Bureau movement. In 822 he was appointed prefect of Hangzhou, and it was in these years, among the temple mountains of West Lake, that he formed close ties with Chan monks; the master Taoguang of this poem was a Zen hermit who dwelt on the ridge above Lingyin Temple. The poem is a friendly letter in verse to a monk, describing the wondrous geography of the twin temples — one gate serving two monasteries, one stream shared by two ravines — which was a real feature of the monastery grounds above the lake. Late in life Bai Juyi called himself a layman of the fragrant mountain and turned increasingly to Chan; this poem's landscape of dissolving boundaries is the record of that state of mind.

《寄韬光禅师》为唐代诗人白居易所作诗。白居易(772—846),字乐天,号香山居士,又号醉吟先生,祖籍太原,生于河南新郑,中唐诗人,新乐府运动倡导者。此诗写寄赠禅意,为寄韬光禅师之作。诗中「一山门作两山门,两寺原从一寺分」写一山门作两山门,两寺原从一寺分;「东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云」写东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云;「前台花发后台见,上界钟声下界闻」写前台花发后台见,上界钟声下界闻;「遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷」写遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷。白居易此诗以寄赠禅意、天香桂子落纷纷写其禅意之情,空灵禅意,是白居易诗中的名篇。此篇《寄韬光禅师》在历代选本中多被收录,其艺术价值与流传之广,正可见此诗在同类题材中的重要地位。诗人以匠心独运之笔写寻常之情事,遂使此作历千载而犹有生气,为后人所称赏不绝。

Art

The poem's supreme device is the interlocking couplet — couplets within couplets. Each line pairs its own opposites: one gate that is two gates, two temples that were one temple, the east ravine's water flowing to the west, the southern mountain's clouds over the northern, front-terrace flowers seen from the back, the upper realm's bell heard below. The repetition is not mere wordplay: each pair quietly argues that the division is in the naming, not in the thing — one gate, one temple, one stream, one cloud, one bloom, one bell. This is the Chan doctrine of non-duality staged as topography. The language is transparent and the rhythm perfectly even, a seven-character regulated verse of complete correctness, so that the philosophical point arrives cushioned in music. The closing couplet is a masterpiece of restraint: 'far I imagine where my master walks his path' is deliberately quiet — no road, no date — and then 'heaven-scented osmanthus seeds fall thick and fast' lets the scene fall away into pure fragrance, the gentlest possible suggestion that the master already dwells in a land where nothing needs to be divided.

此诗艺术上以「空灵禅意、以水写情」见长。全诗共八句四联,由一山门作两山门而东涧水流西涧水而前台花发后台见。起「一山门作两山门,两寺原从一寺分」写一山门作两山门:一山门作两山门,两寺原从一寺分;「东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云」写东涧水流西涧水:东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云;「前台花发后台见,上界钟声下界闻」写前台花发后台见:前台花发后台见,上界钟声下界闻;结「遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷」写天香桂子落纷纷:遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷。全诗以水写情,由一山门作两山门而天香桂子落纷纷,空灵禅意,是白居易诗中的名篇。通篇以少总多之法出之,章法严谨而用意深曲,意象凝练而情韵悠长,读之愈久,愈觉其构思之精与笔力之健,堪称同类诗作中不可多得之佳篇,足见诗人炉火纯青的艺术功力。通篇以少总多之法出之,章法严谨而用意深曲,意象凝练而情韵悠长,读之愈久,愈觉其构思之精与笔力之健,堪称同类诗作中不可多得之佳篇,足见诗人炉火纯青的艺术功力。

Allusions

The poem's one explicit classical resonance is in its closing image. 'Heaven-scented osmanthus seeds' blends two traditions: the moon-palace cassia of myth, whose fragrance is called heavenly, and the famous cassia of the Tianzhu Temple beneath West Lake, whose seeds were said to fall from the moon — Bai Juyi's own line about seeking cassia seeds in the mountain temple by moonlight made the falling seed a signature image of the Hangzhou mountains. In Buddhist usage the falling of the seeds also carries the association of the Pure Land, where flowers rain down as a sign of the awakened mind. Applied to the master Taoguang, the image quietly compares his hermitage to that Pure Land: where he walks in the Way, the air itself drifts with the seeds of enlightenment. 'Upper realm' and 'lower world' are the Buddhist distinction between the heavens above and the world of men — one more of the poem's dissolving pairs, since the bell of the upper realm is heard in the lower world, and the boundary is crossed by sound.

诗中「一山门作两山门两寺原从一寺分」「东涧水流西涧水南山云起北山云」「前台花发后台见上界钟声下界闻」「遥想吾师行道处天香桂子落纷纷」等语,皆含典故故实。「一山门作两山门两寺原从一寺分」写一山门作两山门两寺原从一寺分;「东涧水流西涧水南山云起北山云」写东涧水流西涧水南山云起北山云;「前台花发后台见上界钟声下界闻」写前台花发后台见上界钟声下界闻;「遥想吾师行道处天香桂子落纷纷」用天香桂子之典(天香桂子写佛寺),写遥想吾师行道处天香桂子落纷纷。诗人以天香桂子之典入诗,不着痕迹,而把寄赠禅意之情写得真切可感,是善于熔铸典故的体现。此等用典之法,熔铸古今而不着痕迹,既不炫博以示学,亦不拘泥于旧解,正见诗人学养之深与运思之巧。读者于此等处尤当细心玩味,方能领会其言外之旨与味外之味。

Commentary

This poem has been prized since the Tang as a model of regulated verse written with a Chan flavor. Commentators note its unique structure — couplets nested within couplets — as one of the most ingenious uses of parallelism in the seven-character regulated verse: each line is self-contained, each pair interlocking, so the whole poem feels like a single landscape seen from many angles at once. Later anthologists rank its closing couplet among the finest Chan-inflected endings in Tang poetry: the master is never directly described, yet the drifting osmanthus seeds leave him everywhere and nowhere, exactly the taste of a Zen awakening. In the history of poems sent to monks it stands with the Wangchuan collection for purity of atmosphere, and it is often set against Wang Wei's 'Deer Enclosure' in discussions of how Tang poetry absorbed Buddhist emptiness into landscape. The poem's reputation rests on the paradox at its heart: perfect formal symmetry in the service of a vision in which all distinctions vanish.

这首《寄韬光禅师》,是白居易写寄赠禅意之作,写一山门作两山门、东涧水流西涧水、上界钟声下界闻、天香桂子落纷纷之情,空灵禅意。起「一山门作两山门,两寺原从一寺分」——一山门作两山门,两寺原从一寺分。写一山门作两山门:一山门作两山门、两寺原从一寺分——两山门、一寺分;「东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云」——东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云。写东涧水流西涧水:东涧水流西涧水、南山云起北山云——西涧水、北山云;「前台花发后台见,上界钟声下界闻」——前台花发后台见,上界钟声下界闻。写前台花发后台见:前台花发后台见、上界钟声下界闻——后台见、下界闻;结「遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷」——遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷。写天香桂子落纷纷:遥想吾师行道处、天香桂子落纷纷——行道处、落纷纷。这「遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷」,是全诗之结:以天香桂子落纷纷写其禅意。全诗空灵禅意,以水写情,正是白居易诗中的名篇。

Prosody

Form Poem (seven-character regulated verse, qilü)诗(七言律诗)
Rhyme A seven-character regulated verse of eight lines and four couplets. The rhymes are the level-tone words 'divided' (fen), 'cloud' (yun), 'heard' (wen), and 'thick and fast' (fen) — all of the en/un rhyme group — rhyming on lines 2, 4, 6, and 8, as the form requires.此诗为七言律诗,共八句四联。押韵:「分」「云」「闻」「纷」押文部韵。首联起、颔联承、颈联转、尾联合,平仄相间,正与写寄赠禅意的空灵禅意相称,也见其以七律写禅意的工稳。
Tone pattern The tonal patterns of the middle couplets are strictly matched: 'east ravine water flows west ravine stream' answers 'south mountain clouds rise north mountain clouds,' and 'front terrace flowers bloom back terrace seen' answers 'upper realm bell sounds lower world heard' — level and oblique tones interchanging line by line, the perfect evenness of the regulated form. The first couplet opens level and explanatory, the middle couplets turn flowing and circular, the last couplet slows and lengthens — the rhythm traces the movement from geography to reverie.句式上,「一山门作两山门,两寺原从一寺分」写一山门作两山门,音节空灵;「东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云」写东涧水流西涧水,音节回环;「前台花发后台见,上界钟声下界闻」写前台花发后台见,音节流转;结「遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷」写天香桂子落纷纷,音节悠长。全诗音节随情起伏,由空灵而回环、由流转而悠长,正合七律「工稳」之妙,读来如寄赠禅意、天香桂子落纷纷之音,空灵而动人。
Reading note The poem's formal perfection is inseparable from its Chan mood. The regulated verse demands the strictest symmetry, and Bai Juyi turns that demand into the poem's meaning: couplets within couplets, opposites that match — the form itself performs the non-duality the poem describes. The rhymes are soft and level, never breaking the surface calm, like a bell's tone spreading and settling; the repeated end-words hang the poem in a single key of quiet. The middle couplets flow in an echoing loop — east, west; south, north — the sound itself circling back like the water and the clouds; the closing couplet then stretches out, the pace releasing like the seeds themselves drifting down. Form and feeling coincide: the strictest symmetry in the service of a vision where all divisions dissolve — the paradox at the heart of the poem's art.此诗为七言律诗,是白居易写寄赠禅意之作,也是其诗中的名篇。全诗的艺术特色在于「空灵禅意、以水写情」:「一山门作两山门,两寺原从一寺分」写一山门作两山门、「东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云」写东涧水流西涧水、「前台花发后台见,上界钟声下界闻」写前台花发后台见、「遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷」写天香桂子落纷纷。全诗空灵禅意,以水写情。尤为精妙者,是「东涧水流西涧水」写尽西涧水;而「天香桂子落纷纷」用天香桂子之典,正是白居易诗「空灵禅意」的典范,为历代选本所常收。《寄韬光禅师》一诗之所以读来声情并茂,正在于诗人以声韵配合情思、以节奏烘托意境,音节之长短、平仄之起伏,皆与诗意相为表里,此亦可见中国古典诗歌声律之美与匠心之工。

Line by line

一山门作两山门,两寺原从一寺分。

One mountain gate serves as two mountain gates; the two temples were once one temple, then divided.

一山门作两山门,两寺原从一寺分。

One mountain gate became two mountain gates; two temples were originally divided from one temple.

起句写一山门作两山门,起笔即见其山门。「一山门作两山门」写一山门作两山门,「一山门作」写一山门作、「两山门」写两山门;「两寺原从一寺分」写两寺原从一寺分,「两寺原从」写两寺原从、「一寺分」写一寺分。一句写一山门作两山门两寺原从一寺分,以一山门作两山门写两山门、以两寺原从一寺分写一寺分,写尽一山门作两山门、两寺原从一寺分之情。以山起兴,空灵而禅意,是「以山起兴」的妙笔。

The opening line writes one mountain gate become two, the start. 'One mountain gate became two mountain gates' — the single gate of old now serves two temples; 'two temples were originally divided from one temple' — the two temples once split from the one. Rising through the mountain, airy and Zen-like, the start of the poem's quiet Buddhist scene.

东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云。

The eastern ravine's water flows on to the western ravine's stream; the southern mountain's clouds rise over the northern mountain's clouds.

东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云。

The east ravine's waters flow into the west ravine; the south mountain's clouds rise from the north mountain's clouds.

此句写东涧水流西涧水,是全诗写东涧之态的关键。「东涧水流西涧水」写东涧水流西涧水,「东涧水流」写东涧水流、「西涧水」写西涧水;「南山云起北山云」写南山云起北山云,「南山云起」写南山云起、「北山云」写北山云。一句写东涧水流西涧水南山云起北山云,以东涧水流西涧水写西涧水、以南山云起北山云写北山云,写尽东涧水流西涧水、南山云起北山云之情。以水写景,空灵而禅意,是「以水写景」的点睛之笔。

This line writes the east ravine's waters flowing into the west, the key image. 'The east ravine's waters flow into the west ravine' — the waters joining; 'the south mountain's clouds rise from the north mountain's clouds' — the clouds mingling. Through water it writes the scene, airy and Zen-like, the hidden oneness beneath the two temples.

前台花发后台见,上界钟声下界闻。

When flowers bloom on the front terrace, they are seen from the rear terrace; the bell of the upper realm is heard in the lower world.

前台花发后台见,上界钟声下界闻。

Flowers bloom before the front hall, seen from the back hall; the bell from the upper realm is heard below.

此句写前台花发后台见,是全诗写前台之态的关键。「前台花发后台见」写前台花发后台见,「前台花发」写前台花发、「后台见」写后台见;「上界钟声下界闻」写上界钟声下界闻,「上界钟声」写上界钟声、「下界闻」写下界闻。一句写前台花发后台见上界钟声下界闻,以前台花发后台见写后台见、以上界钟声下界闻写下界闻,写尽前台花发后台见、上界钟声下界闻之情。以钟写景,空灵而禅意,是「以钟写景」的点睛之笔。

This line writes flowers before the front hall seen from the back, the key image. 'Flowers bloom before the front hall, seen from the back hall' — the blossom shared between the two halls; 'the bell from the upper realm is heard below' — the temple bell carrying between the heights. Through the bell it writes the scene, airy and Zen-like, sound and sight crossing between the abodes.

遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷。

Far I imagine where my master walks his path: heaven-scented osmanthus seeds fall thick and fast.

遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷。

Far I think of the place where my master walks the Way; heavenly fragrance, cassia seeds falling in showers.

结句写天香桂子落纷纷,是全诗立意的落点。「遥想吾师行道处」写遥想吾师行道处,「遥想吾师」写遥想吾师、「行道处」写行道处;「天香桂子落纷纷」用天香桂子之典写天香桂子落纷纷,「天香桂子」写天香桂子、「落纷纷」写落纷纷。一句写遥想吾师行道处天香桂子落纷纷,以遥想吾师行道处写行道处、以天香桂子落纷纷写落纷纷,写尽遥想吾师行道处、天香桂子落纷纷之情。以桂写情,空灵而禅意,是全诗最动人处,也是「以桂写情」的点睛之笔。

The closing line writes heavenly fragrance and falling cassia, the poem's landing. 'Far I think of the place where my master walks the Way' — the distant thought of the master; 'heavenly fragrance, cassia seeds falling in showers' uses the allusion to the cassia of the moon, the scented seeds falling through the air. Through the cassia it writes the feeling, airy and Zen-like, the poem's most moving point: the poet far below, imagining the master's walking the Way amid falling celestial fragrance.

Study

Word focus

山门 'Mountain gate' — the gate of a Buddhist monastery, so called because temples were built in the mountains. Here it describes the unusual geography where one gate serves two temples; the word also carries the sense of the gate of the Buddhist teaching, preparing the poem's play on one and two. 「山门」写一山门作两山门,是写山门之态的关键。「一山门作两山门」着一「山门」,写山门——着一「山门」,写一山门作两山门,见其门之山。两字写尽山门之态,是「以词写门」的妙笔。「山门」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。
东涧 'Eastern ravine' — the mountain stream on the east side, paired in the poem with the western ravine of the same line. The east-west pair is one of the poem's nested couplets: one water, flowing between two names, the landscape's divisions quietly dissolved. 「东涧」写东涧水流西涧水,是写东涧之态的关键。「东涧水流西涧水」着一「东涧」,写东涧——着一「东涧」,写东涧水流西涧水,见其涧之东。两字写尽东涧之态,是「以词写涧」的点睛之词。「东涧」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。
钟声 'Sound of the bell' — the temple bell, the voice of the monastery across the valleys; in the poem it crosses from the upper realm, the world of the heavens, to the lower world of men, so that one sound bridges the two worlds — a sound-image of the Chan truth that divisions do not hold. 「钟声」写上界钟声下界闻,是写钟声之态的关键。「上界钟声下界闻」着一「钟声」,写钟声——着一「钟声」,写上界钟声下界闻,见其声之钟。两字写尽钟声之态,是「以词写钟」的点睛之词。「钟声」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。
桂子 'Osmanthus seeds' — the seeds of the sweet olive, which fall in autumn like a drift of small grains. 'Heaven-scented osmanthus seeds' fuses the cassia of the moon palace with the famous cassia of the Tianzhu Temple below West Lake; in Buddhist association the falling seeds are like the flowers that rain in the Pure Land — a sign of the master's awakened realm. 「桂子」写天香桂子落纷纷,是写桂子之态的关键。「天香桂子落纷纷」着一「桂子」,写桂子——着一「桂子」,写天香桂子落纷纷,见其子之桂。两字写尽桂子之态,是「以词写桂」的点睛之词。「桂子」一字之用而全篇生色,与诗中情韵相为表里,正见诗人炼字之精与匠心之独运。读者于此等处若细细体会,自能领会其于平淡之中见功力、于寻常处见神奇之妙。

Related Reading

水调歌头·明月几时有 Prelude to Water Melody (How Long Will the Full Moon Shine) 苏轼 · 同写禅意感怀、空灵旷达,一写我欲乘风归去、一写遥想吾师行道处天香桂子落纷纷,皆于禅意之中见空灵 Both are poems of philosophical elevation with a Chan-Daoist flavor: Su Shi's wish to ride the wind and return against Bai Juyi's imagining of the master walking his path — both rise beyond the scene to a realm of freedom.

Su Shi's famous Mid-Autumn lyric — I wish to ride the wind and return, yet I fear the jade towers and jade halls, the height being too cold — rises from the moon to the problem of transcendence and settles at last on the wish to share this beauty though a thousand miles apart. Bai Juyi's poem rises from temple geography to the master's invisible realm, settling in a drift of osmanthus seeds. Both begin in landscape and end in freedom from it: Su Shi through philosophical acceptance — men have sorrow and joy, parting and meeting, as the moon has its dark and clear — Bai Juyi through Chan non-duality, one gate, one water, one bell. Su Shi is open and philosophical; Bai Juyi quiet and allusive. Read together they show two faces of the Chinese imagination's escape from the world — the lyric of acceptance and the lyric of emptiness.

苏轼《水调歌头·明月几时有》「我欲乘风归去,又恐琼楼玉宇,高处不胜寒」,写禅意感怀、空灵旷达,是宋词长调的名篇;白居易《寄韬光禅师》则以「遥想吾师行道处,天香桂子落纷纷」「前台花发后台见」写落纷纷、后台见。两诗同写禅意感怀、空灵旷达:一写我欲乘风归去、以乘风写超然,一写遥想吾师行道处天香桂子落纷纷、以天香写禅意;一为苏轼之旷达、一为白居易之空灵,并读正可见诗写「禅意感怀」的两种笔法,皆于禅意之中见空灵。

八声甘州·对潇潇暮雨洒江天 Eight Beats of Ganzhou Song (Facing the Dusk Rain Spilling over the Sky) 柳永 · 同写涧中凝望、空灵清丽,一写对潇潇暮雨洒江天、一写东涧水流西涧水南山云起北山云,皆于涧中之中见凝望 Both gaze into mountain waters with ethereal clarity: Liu Yong's dusk rain washing the clear autumn against Bai Juyi's eastern ravine water and southern mountain clouds — both write the landscape of ravine and mountain in pure, ringing tones.

Liu Yong's lyric opens with one of the most famous landscape vistas in Chinese poetry — facing the dusk rain spilling over the sky, a washing of clear autumn — gradually narrowing from the fading chrysanthemums and withering willows at the tower-rail to the wanderer's question of where to look when he turns back. Bai Juyi's poem also writes water and cloud, mountain and gate, but his vision broadens instead of narrowing: ravine answers ravine, mountain answers mountain, until the whole landscape is one web and the gaze turns to the master beyond the world. Liu Yong's landscape is the mirror of the traveler's sorrow; Bai Juyi's landscape is the demonstration of Chan emptiness. One is lyrical longing, the other quiet illumination. Both are masters of the clean, ringing line, and together they show the two directions of Chinese landscape writing — the pouring-out of feeling and the dissolving of it.

柳永《八声甘州·对潇潇暮雨洒江天》「对潇潇暮雨洒江天,一番洗清秋」,写涧中凝望、空灵清丽,是宋词写羁旅的名篇;白居易《寄韬光禅师》则以「东涧水流西涧水,南山云起北山云」「一山门作两山门」写西涧水、两山门。两诗同写涧中凝望、空灵清丽:一写对潇潇暮雨洒江天、以暮雨写清秋,一写东涧水流西涧水南山云起北山云、以山门写禅意;一为柳永之清丽、一为白居易之空灵,并读正可见诗写「涧中凝望」的两种笔法,皆于涧中之中见凝望。