宋 Song · 词 Ci lyric
千秋岁
Qianqiu Sui
数声𫛸鴂。
又报芳菲歇。
惜春更把残红折。
雨轻风色暴,梅子青时节。
永丰柳,无人尽日飞花雪。
莫把幺弦拨。
怨极弦能说。
天不老,情难绝。
心似双丝网,中有千千结。
夜过也,东窗未白凝残月。
Again they announce the fading of fragrance.
Loving spring, I pluck the last red blossoms.
The rain is gentle but the wind turns fierce—the season when plums are green.
At Yongfeng, the willows—all day with no one, catkins drift like snow.
Do not pluck the thinnest string.
When grief is uttermost, the string can speak.
Heaven does not age, and love cannot be severed.
My heart is like a net of doubled silk, within it a thousand thousand knots.
The night has passed; the eastern window not yet bright, a waning moon hangs frozen.
Meaning
Through late-spring night imagery the poet laments the passing of spring and the difficulty of retaining beauty, and with 'my heart is like a net of doubled silk, within it a thousand thousand knots' expresses love's lingering, stubborn bond. The poem cherishes fleeting time and deep feeling with delicate, restrained emotion and profound thought.
这心就如同用双股丝线织成的罗网,其中绾结了千千万万的绳结,解也解不开,割也割不断。一夜就这样过去了,东窗尚未透出亮色,天边仍凝结着一弯残月。不要再去拨动那细急哀怨的幺弦了。
Appreciation
The lyric opens with the cuckoo's cry in the tradition of Li Sao allegory; 'loving spring, I pluck the last red blossoms' writes love of spring with irrational, touching folly. The lower stanza turns to the thinnest string and the silk net to figure love, tightening layer by layer, closing on the frozen waning moon—motion and stillness mirrored, endless aftertaste.
【白话串讲】 张先写千秋岁:“数声𫛸鴂。又报芳菲歇”——杜鹃啼,春将尽。“惜春更把残红折”——“天不老,情难绝。心似双丝网,中有千千结”——“夜过也,东窗未白凝残月”——“心似双丝网,中有千千结”成了千古名句。 【意象与手法】 全词以鸟声起兴,借鹈鴂悲鸣预告芳菲将歇,暗合《离骚》比兴传统。「惜春更把残红折」以亲手折花写怜春之痴,无理而妙。下片转以幺弦、双丝网等意象喻情,层层逼紧,结以「凝残月」之景收束,动静相映,余味无穷。 【情感与主旨】 词人借暮春夜半之景,写春光易逝、芳华难驻之叹,更以「心似双丝网,中有千千结」道出情思之缠绵坚执,抒发了对美好时光与深挚情感的无限珍惜与执着,情致婉约而思力深厚。 【名句点睛】 「心似双丝网,中有千千结」以丝谐思,双丝织网、千结难解,将抽象之情具象为触手可及的罗网,新颖贴切,遂成咏爱情坚贞的千古名句。
Background
Zhang Xian, styled Ziye, of Wucheng, was a renowned lyricist of the early Northern Song; a jinshi of the Tiansheng era, he rose to Director of the Ministry of Works, famous for the nickname 'Zhang of the Three Shadows.' Qianqiu Sui ('A Few Cries of the Cuckoo') is among his representative works; though not precisely dated, from its lines 'the season when plums are green' and 'the night has passed, the eastern window not yet bright, a waning moon hangs frozen' it is a late-spring, midnight meditation. Zhang Xian's official career was smooth; he associated with Yan Shu, Ouyang Xiu, and Song Qi, and his lyrics mostly write love between men and women and lamenting spring and parting. Beginning with the cuckoo's mournful cry, it secretly uses Qu Yuan's Li Sao line 'I fear the cuckoo's first cry makes all the hundred herbs lose their fragrance,' lodging the sigh that spring passes and beauty cannot stay; the lower stanza turns to love, and 'my heart is like a net of doubled silk, within it a thousand thousand knots' uses the doubled-silk net for love's entangling, becoming a famous line for the ages. The Qian Ding Ci Pu records Qianqiu Sui as a double-mode seventy-one-character form; this lyric follows it. Its imagery of 'fading fragrance' and 'catkins like snow' belongs with the spring poems of Yan Shu and Mei Yaochen, yet shows thought within lingering depth—its excellence.
张先字子野,乌程人,北宋前期词坛名家,天圣八年进士,历官至尚书都官郎中,以「张三影」之号著称于世。《千秋岁·数声𫛸鴂》是其代表作之一,不见于史传明确系年,据词中「梅子青时节」「夜过也,东窗未白凝残月」诸语,当为暮春夜半感怀之作。张先一生仕途平稳,多与晏殊、欧阳修、宋祁等交游,词亦多写男女情思与伤春惜别,唐圭璋《全宋词》据《张子野词》著录此调。词以「𫛸鴂」悲鸣起笔,暗用屈原《离骚》「恐鹈鴂之先鸣兮,使夫百草为之不芳」句意,寄寓春光易逝、芳华难驻之叹;下片转入情语,「心似双丝网,中有千千结」以双丝之网喻情思之缠绵,遂成千古名句。案《钦定词谱》卷十六载《千秋岁》双调七十一字,前段八句五仄韵,后段八句五仄韵,此词即依此格。词中所写「芳菲歇」「飞花雪」等意象,与晏殊、梅尧臣诸人咏春之作同属一时风气,而于绵邈深情中见思致,是其过人处。词牌《千秋岁》本为唐教坊曲,宋人用以咏叹节序与情事,张先此作与秦观「水边沙外,城郭春寒退」同调之作并称双璧,然观词所重首在言情,韵脚密而情意更密。后人论词每谓「小令宜清,慢词宜壮」,而子野以双调小令之体写绵长不尽之情,一气旋折而章法不乱,尤见其工力之深,故历来选宋词者鲜有不录此篇。
Art
In structure the upper stanza writes scene and spring-lament, the lower speaks love and parting, orderly yet with feeling flowing. The opening 'a few cries of the cuckoo' breaks the air with bird-song, secretly carrying the Li Sao allegorical tradition; once the bird cries, the fading of fragrance is already foreseen—sound painting scene, scene painting feeling, a double method. 'Loving spring, I pluck the last red blossoms'—the verb 'pluck' is especially striking: the spring-lover, unable to bear the fallen red, plucks it himself, showing deepest pity in an irrational act, folly yet wonderful. 'The rain is gentle but the wind turns fierce' sets 'gentle' against 'fierce,' writing late spring's sudden change, plums just green yet wind wild and rain urgent, preparing the later spring-lament. The turn 'do not pluck the thinnest string; when grief is uttermost, the string can speak' moves from scene to feeling, writing sorrow through music—the string unplucked yet grief already full, tightening layer by layer. 'Heaven does not age, and love cannot be severed' uses heaven as comparison, reversing 'if heaven had feelings heaven too would age,' swearing from the reverse, love's stubbornness fully shown. The close 'my heart is like a net of doubled silk, within it a thousand thousand knots' puns 'silk' on 'thought' (si), doubled silk a net, a thousand knots unsolvable, a fresh and apt metaphor, the classic image of love's constancy in Song ci. 'The night has passed; the eastern window not yet bright, a waning moon hangs frozen' closes with scene, a sleepless night yet the east not bright, the waning moon frozen in the sky—exactly the unfinished sorrow, mirroring the lower stanza's direct feeling,含蓄 with aftertaste. The whole lyric joins cunning and deep feeling, delicate yet not without clarity—Zhang Xian's representative work of 'skillful phrasing yet writing the true.'
此词结构上片写景惜春,下片言情怨别,章法井然而情意流转。起拍「数声𫛸鴂」径以鸟声破空,暗含《离骚》比兴传统,啼鸟之声一出,芳菲之歇已在预料之中,是为以声写景、以景写情的双管手法。「惜春更把残红折」一「折」字尤为精警,惜春者不忍见残红委地,乃亲手折取,于无情动作中见至深怜惜,无理而妙。「雨轻风色暴」二句以「轻」「暴」对举,写暮春天气之骤变,梅子方青而风狂雨急,为后文惜春张本。过片「莫把幺弦拨,怨极弦能说」,由景入情,转以乐声写愁,弦声未拨而怨已满,层层逼紧。「天不老,情难绝」以天作比,翻用「天若有情天亦老」之语,从反面立誓,情之坚执尽见。结拍「心似双丝网,中有千千结」,以「丝」谐「思」,双丝成网,千结难解,取喻新奇而贴切,成为宋词中咏爱情坚贞的典范意象。「夜过也,东窗未白凝残月」以景结情,一夜无眠而东方未白,残月凝空,正见愁思之未尽,与下片直抒情语互为映发,含蓄有余味。全词巧思与深情并至,纤丽而不失清刚,是张先「措词纤巧」而又能以巧写真的代表作。尤须指出,全词以「歇、折、节、雪、说、绝、结、月」八字入声短韵一气贯注,句句押韵而句句转折,音节与情思同其迫促,收处「凝残月」以平收之景宕开,遂觉愁思不尽,此等声情相济之处,正词家所谓「以韵传情」的至高境界。
Allusions
The 'cuckoo' (tijué) is also called zigui or cuckoo. Li Sao says 'I fear the cuckoo's first cry makes all the hundred herbs lose their fragrance'; Wang Yi's commentary notes it cries at the spring equinox so the hundred herbs fade. Zhang Xian uses it for exactly 'first cry then fragrance fades,' the eye of the whole poem's spring-lament. 'At Yongfeng, the willows—all day with no one, catkins drift like snow' uses Bai Juyi's Willow Branch lyric: 'a tree in spring wind, a thousand ten-thousand branches, tender as gold, soft as silk; in the western corner of Yongfeng garden, all day with no one, to whom does it belong'—the Tang emperor Xuanzong, hearing it, had two willows planted in the palace, spreading Bai's poem. Zhang Xian's 'all day with no one' transforms Bai's 'all day with no one,' using the Yongfeng willow to write love's homelessness. The 'thinnest string' (yaoxian) is the finest string of the pipa, its sound thin, urgent, and mournful, a Song ci convention for sorrow. 'Heaven does not age' reverses Li He's 'if heaven had feelings heaven too would age,' using it conversely for love's unseverability. 'My heart is like a net of doubled silk' puns 'silk' on 'thought'—the Han yuefu 'Ancient Quatrain' already opened this pun; Zhang Xian advances it into the doubled-net-thousand-knots metaphor, a unique creation for the ages. 'Loving spring, I pluck the last red blossoms' secretly echoes 'fading fragrance'—plucking the red yet fragrance fades, pitying spring yet spring leaves, a causal flow beyond the words. 'The rain is gentle but the wind turns fierce' hints at love's storms through weather's sudden change.
「𫛸鴂」即鹈鴂,一名子规、杜鹃。《离骚》云:「恐鹈鴂之先鸣兮,使夫百草为之不芳。」王逸《楚辞章句》注鹈鴂一名买鴂,春分鸣则众芳生,秋分鸣则众芳歇。张先以之入词,正是取「先鸣则芳歇」之意,为全篇惜春之眼。「永丰柳,无人尽日飞花雪」用白居易《杨柳枝词》「一树春风千万枝,嫩于金色软于丝。永丰西角荒园里,尽日无人属阿谁」之典。据孟棨《本事诗》载,此诗出后,唐宣宗问永丰坊何处有杨柳,遂命取两枝植于禁中,白诗因之广传。张先写「无人尽日」,正化用白诗「尽日无人」之句,托永丰柳以写情之无着。「幺弦」指琵琶最细之弦,其音细急而哀,宋词习用以写愁怨。「天不老」句翻用李贺《金铜仙人辞汉歌》「天若有情天亦老」,反其意而用之,以言情之难绝。「心似双丝网」则以「丝」谐「思」,汉乐府《古绝句》「理丝入残机,何悟不成匹」已开以丝谐思之先例,张先更进一层,织为双网千结之喻,遂为千古独创。又「惜春更把残红折」之「折」,暗与「芳菲歇」之「歇」呼应,折红而芳歇,怜春而春去,字面之外有因果流转之妙。「雨轻风色暴」则以天时骤变暗喻情海风波,宋人评词多谓此词或有寄托,虽未必确指,然其意象之富赡实为宋初词中罕见,凡此皆可见子野读书之博与取用之精。
Commentary
On Zhang Xian's nickname 'Zhang of the Three Shadows,' the Song Gu Jin Shi Hua records a guest calling him 'Zhang of the Three Zhong' (heart's affair, eye's tears, mind's person); Zhang said 'why not call me Zhang of the Three Shadows'—for 'clouds break, moon comes, flowers play with shadows,' 'gentle, loath to rise, the blind weighs down flower shadows,' 'willow path with no one, falling catkins fly without shadow,' his life's proud lines. This concerns the 'shadow' lines yet shows his verbal craft. Li Tiaoyuan's Yu Cun Ci Hua says the name came from the popular 'shadow' lines, 'clouds break, moon comes, flowers play with shadows' especially a masterpiece. For this lyric, 'my heart is like a net of doubled silk, within it a thousand thousand knots' has been cited by many ci talks; Shen Xiong's Gu Jin Ci Hua calls Zhang Xian 'skillful in phrasing,' exactly provable here. Zhang Xian's lyrics inherit the warmth of Yan Shu and Ouyang Xiu above and open the grace of Qin Guan and Liu Yong below, a bridging figure in Northern Song ci. Li Qingzhao's Ci Lun jibes that Zhang Xian and others 'though sometimes with wonderful lines, are fragmentary, hardly masters'—yet 'sometimes with wonderful lines' can be turned on this lyric; 'my heart is like a net of doubled silk' and 'the eastern window not yet bright, a waning moon hangs frozen' are proofs of those wonderful lines, so even harsh critique does not dim its famous lines. Across ages it is often anthologized with 'Tian Xian Zi' and 'Qing Men Yin,' all for their verbal craft and deep feeling; critics' emphasis varies, but 'skilled in love, long in phrasing' remains constant.
关于张先「张三影」之号,宋人《古今诗话》载:客谓子野为「张三中」,即「心中事、眼中泪、意中人」也。子野曰:「何不目之为张三影?」客不晓,子野曰:「云破月来花弄影」「娇柔懒起,帘押卷花影」「柳径无人,堕絮飞无影」,此余平生所得意也。事见胡仔《苕溪渔隐丛话》前集卷三十七所引。此虽专论「影」字句,亦足见其炼字之工。李调元《雨村词话》卷一论张先词,谓「张三影」之目实由「影」字句脍炙人口而来,「云破月来花弄影」尤称杰构。就本词而言,「心似双丝网,中有千千结」二句,历代词话多所称引,清人沈雄《古今词话》评张先「措词纤巧」,正可于此得证。张先词上承晏欧之温润,下启秦柳之婉丽,于北宋词坛有承前启后之功。《词林纪事》卷四引《过庭录》谓子野「以歌词得名」,虽属泛论,亦见其词名之盛。综合诸家所评,此词之佳在能以巧思写深情,以纤丽之笔传执著之念。至于李清照《词论》,则讥张先诸人「虽时时有妙语,而破碎何足名家」,可见宋人对子野词亦有微辞,然「时时有妙语」一语正可移评此词,「心似双丝网」「东窗未白凝残月」等句即其妙语之验,是知苛评亦无损其名句之流传。又此词历代多与《天仙子》《青门引》并选,皆取其炼字之工与情致之深,批评家对子野词的认识虽有侧重,而「工于言情、长于炼字」之评则始终如一。
Prosody
Line by line
心似双丝网,中有千千结。
My heart is like a net of doubled silk, within it a thousand thousand knots.
这心就如同用双股丝线织成的罗网,其中绾结了千千万万的绳结,解也解不开,割也割不断。
The heart is like a net woven of double silk, knotted within by a thousand thousand knots.
这是全词最为脍炙人口的名句。以双丝网设喻,双丝交织既见情之缠绵密致,千千结又写愁之郁结难解,形象新颖而寄意深挚。妙在「丝」与「思」谐音双关,织网之丝亦即相思之丝,情思如罗网密布,纵有千般挣扎亦无从脱身,遂把相思之情写得入骨三分。句法上「双」对「千千」,「网」对「结」,数字与物象叠用,音节铿锵而余韵绵长,故能超越一时一境,成为后世咏爱情坚贞的经典比喻。
This is the ci's best-known line. Comparing the heart to a net of double silk, the interwoven double strands show love's clinging density, while a thousand thousand knots write grief's tangled, undecidable core; the image is fresh and the feeling deep. The beauty is the pun of silk and longing, homophones: the silk of the net is the silk of longing, and thought spreads like a dense net, so that a thousand struggles cannot break free - love written to the bone. In syntax, double pairs with thousand thousand, net pairs with knot, numbers and images layered, the rhythm sonorous and the aftertaste long; thus it outlives its time and place to become the classic metaphor for steadfast love.
夜过也,东窗未白凝残月。
The night has passed; the eastern window not yet bright, a waning moon hangs frozen.
一夜就这样过去了,东窗尚未透出亮色,天边仍凝结着一弯残月。
The night is over; the east window is not yet bright, and a last moon is fixed on the sky.
结句以景结情,写彻夜无眠之人独对残月之态。「凝」字下得极稳,残月似凝固于天边,亦似凝住一夜未散的愁思,把时间与情感同时冻结,含蓄而沉郁。全词至此戛然而止,而「凝残月」三字又回头照应「情难绝」之誓语,愁未尽而情不绝,余味无穷。此等以景收束之法,与晏殊「无可奈何花落去」的结句异曲同工,皆以小景托大情。月与人俱凝,愁与夜俱深,短短十四字胜过千言直说,正是「不着一字,尽得风流」的含蓄境界,读者于此低回久之,自能想见一夜无眠者的身影。
The closing ends feeling in scenery, writing the sleepless figure alone facing the last moon. The word fixed is placed with great steadiness: the waning moon seems congealed on the horizon, as if it also congealed the grief that has not dispersed through the night, freezing time and feeling at once, restrained and grave. The ci stops here, and the three words fixed on the last moon answer the vow above that feeling cannot end - grief not spent, feeling unbroken, the aftertaste endless. This way of closing in scenery, akin to Yan Shu's blossoms fall beyond all help, holds a large feeling in a small scene. Moon and person alike congealed, grief and night alike deepened; fourteen short words surpass a thousand plain words - the restrained realm of not writing one word yet achieving all, and readers who linger long can picture the sleepless figure.
莫把幺弦拨。
Do not pluck the thinnest string.
不要再去拨动那细急哀怨的幺弦了。
Do not pluck the thin, sad string.
五字单句成拍,是词中陡转之笔。「幺弦」音细而急,最易勾起断肠之怨,诗人却先作「莫拨」之劝,其惧愁之情溢于言表,情之深者不言愁而愁自见。下一句「怨极弦能说」复以「能说」反扣「莫拨」,一层是怕愁,一层是知怨之已极、非弦声所能尽吐,语愈转愈深,正见用笔之盘纡。此等欲说还休的写法,与李清照「多少事、欲说还休」同一机杼。前人评词有「语淡情浓」之说,此五字单句正是其例:字面平淡无奇,而弦外之怨如泉涌泉咽,愈抑制愈汹涌,足见张先以小令写情的节制与力度。
A five-word single line, a sudden turn in the ci. The thin string sounds fine and urgent, most apt to stir the grief that breaks the heart; yet the poet first gives the admonition do not pluck it, and his fear of grief is plain between the lines - when feeling is deep, one does not name grief and grief appears of itself. The next line, even grievance the string can tell, turns can tell back against do not pluck: one layer the fear of grief, the next the knowledge that grievance has reached the point no string can utter, the meaning deepening as it turns, showing the winding brush. This way of wishing to speak and then stopping shares the method of Li Qingzhao's how many things, wishing to speak and stopping. Critics speak of plain words, intense feeling, and this five-word line is the example: the surface is ordinary, yet the grievance beyond the strings wells up like a spring, the more restrained the more swelling, proving Zhang Xian's restraint and power in the short song.
Study
Word focus
Related Reading
Compare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
晏殊同是北宋前期词人,与张先过从甚密。晏词「无可奈何花落去,似曾相识燕归来」写春归花落之叹,张词「又报芳菲歇」「惜春更把残红折」写芳菲将尽之惜,两词均以自然物候为触媒,抒岁月不居之怀。但晏殊出以闲雅圆融之笔,惆怅中含理性之安顿;张先则以「双丝网」「千千结」的执著形象传情,情感的密度与强度远过之,可见两人虽同属婉约一脉,气格确有分别。
天仙子·水调数声持酒听 Song of the Immortal in Heaven · Listening to Water Melody with Wine 张先 · 同一作者伤春怀人的姊妹篇 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
「云破月来花弄影」为张先平生得意之句,与《千秋岁》同写夜中伤春怀远。两词皆以夜为背景,以月、花、影等朦胧意象传情,结句一作「明日落红应满径」,一作「东窗未白凝残月」,均以景语收束,含不尽之意。所不同者,《天仙子》愁在酒醒伤春,《千秋岁》愁在情丝难断,前者空灵,后者缜密,可见子野词风之一体两面。两词合观,可知子野于同一伤春母题下不断自我超越,炼字愈工而寄意愈深,其「张三影」之名与「双丝网」之喻,正同为其词艺精进的标志。
离骚 Encountering Sorrow (Excerpt) 屈原 · 取意于香草美人比兴传统 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
张先起笔「数声𫛸鴂」直接脱胎于《离骚》「恐鹈鴂之先鸣兮,使夫百草为之不芳」,以禽鸟鸣声预告春之将尽,正是楚辞香草比兴传统在词体中的流衍。但屈原以「众芳芜秽」托君臣之慨,张先则借「芳菲歇」「残红折」写儿女之私情,把政治寓言转写为情感体验,比兴由「通于政事」渐变为「专于性情」,可见词体兴起后比兴内涵的位移。由屈赋而宋词,这一比兴的转化,正是中国抒情文学由庙堂雅颂而下及闺檐私情的缩影,张先此词既守其比兴之体,又拓其言情之境,在词史与诗史的交接处自有其不可替代的位置。