宋 Song · 词 Ci lyric
鹧鸪天·代人赋
Partridge in the Sky: Written in Place of Another
晚日寒鸦一片愁。
柳塘新绿却温柔。
若教眼底无离恨,不信人间有白头。
肠已断,泪难收。
相思重上小红楼。
情知已被山遮断,频倚阑干不自由。
The willow pond, the new green, yet, tender and soft.
If, teaching, the eyes, below, no, the parting grief,
Not believing, the human world, having, the white heads.
The bowels, already, broken, the tears, hard, to hold.
The mutual longing, again, ascending, the small red tower.
Knowing, clearly, already, by the mountains, cut off, hidden,
Frequently, leaning, the railings, not, free, the self.
Meaning
A lyric of the parting and the longing, written by Xin Qiji. The cold crows of the evening sun with the sorrow, the willow pond with the new green yet tender — the scene of the opening. If teaching the eyes below no parting grief, not believing the human world having the white heads — the parting grief of the belief. The bowels already broken with the tears hard to hold, the mutual longing again ascending the small red tower — the longing of the tower. And the close's knowing clearly already by the mountains cut off hidden, frequently leaning the railings not free the self — the close's leaning. The lyric is the parting and the longing: the cold crows, the white heads, and the close's leaning the railings.
夕阳晚照,寒鸦归飞,眼前一片愁绪;柳塘边的新柳却一片嫩绿,温柔多情。倘若眼前没有离愁别恨,我就不相信人间会有白头。柔肠已断,眼泪难收;怀着相思,又一次登上小红楼。明明知道视线已被远山遮断,却还是身不由己地一次次倚着阑干眺望。
Appreciation
[Plain Paraphrase] The cold crows of the evening sun, one piece, the sorrow. The willow pond, the new green, yet, tender and soft. If, teaching, the eyes, below, no, the parting grief, not believing, the human world, having, the white heads. The bowels, already, broken, the tears, hard, to hold. The mutual longing, again, ascending, the small red tower. Knowing, clearly, already, by the mountains, cut off, hidden, frequently, leaning, the railings, not, free, the self. [Structure and Thought] The lyric moves from the cold crows and the tender willows, through the white heads and the tears, and the mutual longing ascending the tower, to the close's mountains cutting off the hidden, the frequent leaning of the railings. [Key Technique] The lyric's art is the close of the leaning: the mountains cut off hidden of the close, and the frequent leaning of the railings — the longing gathered in the hidden and the close's leaning. [Emotional Tone] Sorrowful, deep, and longing: the lyric is the parting grief, the tower and the close's railings.
【白话串讲】 辛弃疾写鹧鸪天代人赋:“晚日寒鸦一片愁。柳塘新绿却温柔”。“若教眼底无离恨,不信人间有白头”——“肠已断,泪难收。相思重上小红楼”——“情知已被山遮断,频倚阑干不自由”——他写离别。 【意象与手法】 以景起兴(晚日寒鸦),以乐景衬哀(柳塘新绿却温柔);「若教……不信……」的假设句法翻出新意,无理而妙。过片三字短句「肠已断,泪难收」顿挫直抒;结以「频倚阑干不自由」,以态写情,将痴情写到极处。 【情感与主旨】 代闺中思妇抒写离愁别恨:相思之深足以催人白头,明知无望仍倚阑眺望。稼轩于豪放之外,此词以婉约之笔写尽痴情,亦或寄寓自身志不得伸的孤愤。 【名句点睛】 「若教眼底无离恨,不信人间有白头」为千古名句:以假设立论,将离恨与白头结为因果,无理而妙,把一己离愁升华为人间普遍经验。
Background
Xin Qiji (1140–1207), the great patriotic poet of the Song, wrote this 'Partridge in the Sky: Written in Place of Another' of the parting and the longing — the sorrow of the separation. The cold crows with the tender willows, the white heads with the broken bowels, and the close's mountains cutting off the hidden, the frequent leaning of the railings — the lyric gathers the sorrow of the parting, the deep longing. The lyric is one of the famous works of the poet's lyrics of the parting.
辛弃疾(1140—1207),字幼安,号稼轩,历城(今山东济南)人,南宋豪放词宗。此词题为「代人赋」,是代闺中思妇抒写离愁别恨之作。辛弃疾生长于金人统治下的北方,青年时率众南归,本欲北伐中原、恢复故土,然南归后却长期被朝廷投闲置散,屡遭排挤,壮志难酬。此词虽代他人立言,然稼轩一生「一饭不忘君」、忧时念乱之心,往往于代人言情中隐然可见——写思妇之离恨,亦未尝不是写志士之孤愤。具体作年已不可确考,一般认为作于辛弃疾南归后长期闲居带湖(今江西上饶)一带的时期,或即其闲居词中之婉约一脉。全词以「愁」字起、以「不自由」结,上片写景抒情,下片写登楼倚阑之态,将离愁写得缠绵深至,与稼轩豪放词风迥异,可见其「能刚能柔」的大家风范。李清照之后,辛弃疾此作是宋代「代人赋」闺情词中极见功力的一篇。全词篇幅虽短,而写景、说理、叙事、言情兼备,愁情一线贯穿,是稼轩婉约词中不可多得的名篇,亦为词史「代人赋」一体之翘楚。
Art
The lyric's art is the art of the parting longing. The scene opens: the cold crows of the evening sun, one piece, the sorrow — the cold crows of the sorrow; the willow pond, the new green, yet, tender and soft — the tender willows of the pond. The belief follows: if, teaching, the eyes, below, no, the parting grief — the no parting grief of the eyes; not believing, the human world, having, the white heads — the white heads of the world; the bowels, already, broken, the tears, hard, to hold — the broken bowels; the mutual longing, again, ascending, the small red tower — the ascending of the small red tower. And the close gathers the leaning: knowing, clearly, already, by the mountains, cut off, hidden — the hidden of the mountains; frequently, leaning, the railings, not, free, the self — the leaning of the railings — the scene, the longing and the close's leaning, gathered in the lyric.
此词之妙,在以景起情、以理翻情、以态写情,层层深入。起拍「晚日寒鸦一片愁」以景起兴:夕阳西下、寒鸦归飞,正是日暮思归之时,而「一片愁」三字直点词眼,情由景生。次句「柳塘新绿却温柔」陡转:柳塘新绿,春意温柔,以乐景衬哀情——春色愈温柔,愈见离人之孤独,且「却」字一转,写出愁人对春景的敏感与拒斥。过片前「若教眼底无离恨,不信人间有白头」以假设句翻出新意:若不亲历离恨,便不会相信人间真有白头——将离恨与白头结为因果,无理而妙,是千古名句。下片转入动作与情态:「肠已断,泪难收」以三字短句顿挫直抒,语急情促;「相思重上小红楼」之「重」字,写相思之反复无已;「情知已被山遮断,频倚阑干不自由」以明知不可而仍倚阑干收束,将痴情写到极处。全词由外景到内心、由理念到姿态,一气流走而层次分明,是婉约词中「以健笔写柔情」的典范。写景则清丽,说理则精警,言情则深挚,兼得婉约词之长,而自有稼轩清刚之气,后之论者谓其「于豪放之外,别树一帜」,此词即其婉约一帜的典型。
Allusions
'The cold crows' (han ya) are the cold crows — the crows of the evening, the sorrow; 'the white heads' (bai tou) are the white heads — the heads of the white, the parting grief; 'the small red tower' (xiao hong lou) is the small red tower — the tower of the red, the ascending of the longing; 'the railings' (lan gan) are the railings — the leaning of the close, the not free of the self.
此词不事典故,而以意象与日常语写情,然细味之,皆有传统可寻。其一,「晚日寒鸦」:日暮寒鸦,自古为羁旅思归之景,王昌龄《长信秋词》「寒鸦飞数点,流水绕孤村」写寒鸦与孤村,温庭筠「鸦背夕阳多」写暮色,辛弃疾以「寒鸦」配「晚日」,「一片愁」随之而出。其二,「柳塘」:柳为赠别之木,古人折柳送别,「柳」与「留」谐音;柳塘新绿,本属春景,而于离人眼中,柳色愈新愈惹离思。其三,「小红楼」:闺阁之代称,唐宋词中「楼上愁」「独倚楼」为思妇典型场景,李白《菩萨蛮》「暝色入高楼,有人楼上愁」、温庭筠《望江南》「独倚望江楼」皆其先声。其四,「山遮断」:山遮望眼,是思妇望归的经典意象,欧阳修《踏莎行》「平芜尽处是春山,行人更在春山外」写行人已在春山之外,辛弃疾反用其意,写明知山遮断而仍倚阑干。其五,词牌「鹧鸪天」本身:鹧鸪鸟鸣声凄切,俗谐「行不得也哥哥」,词牌名与离愁别绪天然相合。凡此种种,皆化用无痕,正是稼轩「以故为新」的手段。
Commentary
This lyric is one of the famous works of Xin Qiji's lyrics of the parting, quoted for the depth of its longing and the leaning of its close. The white heads of the parting grief, and the railings not free the self, are among the admired passages of the poet's lyrics. Critics praise the lyric's depth: the parting gathered in the belief, to the close's leaning.
辛弃疾以豪放词雄视两宋,而此词以婉约之笔代写闺情,足见其风格之多面。前人论稼轩词「肝肠似火,色貌如花」,正谓其豪放之中自有深情、柔情之内亦含风骨——此词写思妇离愁,缠绵深至而不失清刚,即是明证。词史上「代人赋」一体源远流长:花间词人多代女子言情,柳永、晏几道皆工于此道;辛弃疾此作却能于传统题材中翻出新意——「若教眼底无离恨,不信人间有白头」以理语写情,将离愁提升到人生经验的普遍层面,遂成千古名句,为历代选本所必录。全词由「晚日寒鸦」之景到「倚阑干不自由」之态,愁之深、情之痴、思之无已,层层写来,而始终不离一个「愁」字,章法严谨,情致深婉。后人或以稼轩闺情词为「英雄气短」,然细读此词,正见其「能刚能柔」的大家气象——能写金戈铁马者,亦能写相思入骨。后世闺情词写倚楼望归者,多不出温、韦、柳、晏之范围,而稼轩此词以「理语翻新」出之,遂成别调。今人读此词,犹能于「不自由」三字中,体会那份情到深处的身不由己与无可奈何。
Prosody
Line by line
晚日寒鸦一片愁。
The setting sun, chill crows — one whole expanse of grief.
夕阳晚照,寒鸦归飞,眼前一片凄凉愁绪。
The evening sun and returning chill crows make a scene of utter desolation and grief.
起拍七字,以景起兴,奠定全词基调。「晚日」写时间:夕阳西下,正是鸟归人归、最易牵动离思的黄昏时分;「寒鸦」写物象:暮色中归飞的乌鸦,本是无情之物,而「寒」字赋予其凄清之感——鸦且知归,而离人未归,物我对照,愁从中来。「一片愁」三字直点词眼,不说「我愁」,而说眼前晚日寒鸦「一片愁」,将主观之情外化为客观之景,愁绪遂弥漫天地之间。稼轩善以景语开篇:「更能消几番风雨」之怅惘、「郁孤台下清江水」之悲慨,皆以一景而定全篇声情;此句以「晚日寒鸦」起「一片愁」,起笔即见离愁之浓重,为后文「白头」「肠断」预伏根苗。
The opening raises feeling through scenery in seven characters, fixing the ci's keynote. 'The evening sun' writes time: the sun sinking, the dusk when birds and men return and parting thoughts are most stirred. 'Chill crows' writes object: crows flying home in the dusk, originally unfeeling, yet the word 'chill' gives them desolation — crows know to return, yet the parting traveler does not, thing and self set off, grief arising. 'One whole expanse of grief' directly names the eye of the ci: it does not say 'I grieve' but that the evening sun and chill crows before the eyes are 'one whole expanse of grief,' projecting subjective feeling onto objective scenery, until sorrow fills all heaven and earth. Jiaxuan excels at opening with scenic words: the melancholy of 'how many more storms can it bear,' the grief of 'below the Yugu Terrace, the clear river' — each fixes the whole piece's voice through one scene. This line raises 'one whole expanse of grief' through 'evening sun, chill crows,' showing at the first stroke the weight of parting sorrow, planting the seed for the later 'white head' and 'broken bowels.'
柳塘新绿却温柔。
By the willow pond the new green is yet so tender.
柳塘边新生的嫩柳一片新绿,却显得那样温柔多情。
Beside the willow pond, the fresh green of new buds seems so tender and warm.
此句承接上句,而笔锋一转,以乐景反衬哀情。「柳塘新绿」写春景:春水池塘,新柳初绿,正是生机盎然之时;「温柔」二字,将新绿柳色写得情致缠绵——柳条依依,如人脉脉含情。然着一「却」字,顿生转折之妙:如此温柔的春色,在离人眼中非但不能解愁,反更衬出自身之孤独——柳尚知春、知温柔,而人独对离恨,春色愈好,离愁愈深。此即古典诗学「以乐景写哀,一倍增其哀」之法。且「柳」本关别情:古人折柳赠别,柳塘新绿,正是当年送别之地,触景愈增离思。两句一愁一温、一哀一乐,对照映发,情致深婉,为全词定下「哀而不伤、怨而不怒」的基调。
This line follows the last yet turns the brush, using joyful scenery to set off sorrow. 'By the willow pond the new green' writes spring scenery: the pond in spring water, new willows just green, the time of teeming life. 'Tender' writes the new green willow color as feelingful — willow branches trailing, as if people's quiet affection. Yet one word 'yet' gives the turn: such tender spring scenery, in the eyes of the parting traveler, cannot dissolve grief but rather sets off his solitude — willows know spring and tenderness, while the man alone faces parting; the fairer the spring, the deeper the sorrow. This is precisely the classic poetics of 'writing sorrow through joyful scenery, doubling the sorrow.' Moreover, the 'willow' naturally links parting: ancients broke a willow sprig at farewell; the willow pond fresh green is precisely the place of that year's sending off, touching the scene and redoubling longing. Two phrases, one grief one tenderness, one sorrow one joy, setting each other off, the feeling delicate — fixing the ci's keynote of 'sorrowful without wounding, resentful without anger.'
若教眼底无离恨,不信人间有白头。
If, teaching, the eyes, below, no, the parting grief, not believing, the human world, having, the white heads.
倘若眼前没有离愁别恨,我就不相信人间会有白发。
If parting sorrow were not before my eyes, I would not believe that people ever grow white-haired.
此为全词名句,以假设句翻出新意,无理而妙。「若教眼底无离恨,不信人间有白头」:若使眼中没有离恨,我便不信人间真有白头——言下之意,白头正由离恨催生,离恨之深,足以使人一夜白头。此语本属夸张之词,然以「若教……不信……」的假设对举出之,便觉理直气壮、无可辩驳:离恨若除,则白头可免;白头既见,则离恨可知。李白《秋浦歌》「白发三千丈,缘愁似个长」以白发写愁之长,辛弃疾此句以白头证离恨之深,同一机杼而更富理趣。两句对仗工稳(若教对不信、眼底对人间、离恨对白头),语虽浅近而意极深挚,将一己之离愁升华为人间之普遍经验,遂成千古传诵的至情至理之语。
This is a famous line of the ci, turning a new thought through a hypothetical sentence, unreasonable yet exquisite. 'If parting sorrow were not before my eyes, I would not believe that people ever grow white-haired': if there were no parting grief before the eyes, I would not believe the human world truly has white heads — the implication being that white heads are bred of parting grief, whose depth can turn one white overnight. The words are hyperbole, yet put through the hypothetical parallel 'if... I would not believe...' they feel unanswerable: remove parting grief, and white heads need not come; seeing white heads, parting grief is known. Li Bai's 'A thousand fathoms of white hair, for grief as long' writes the length of sorrow through white hair; Xin's line proves the depth of parting grief through white heads, the same method yet richer in reason. The two are tightly parallel (if against believe-not, before the eyes against the human world, parting grief against white head), the words plain yet the meaning deep, sublimating one man's parting sorrow into the universal experience of humanity — hence a cherished line of utmost feeling and reason.
肠已断,泪难收。
Bowels already broken, tears hard to hold.
柔肠已经断裂,眼泪难以收止(悲伤到了极点)。
My bowels are already broken, and the tears I cannot stop (sorrow at its extreme).
过片六字,以三字短句顿挫直抒,是全词情感之爆发点。「肠已断」写情之痛极:古人以「断肠」状悲伤之极,江淹《别赋》「黯然销魂者,唯别而已矣」,白居易「一夜乡心五处同」之肠断皆同此意;「泪难收」写悲之难制:泪既流出,欲收不得。两句两用「已」「难」,将无可奈何之状写得入木三分。从句式看,三字对三字,节奏短促紧迫,如泣如诉,与上片七言句的舒徐形成顿挫,正是词中「换头」处声情之变;从情脉看,上句「若教」的假设之谈,至此跌入「肠断泪难收」的实境,理想与现实的落差,尽在这六个字中。稼轩豪放词中偶现婉约之笔,此六字最见其柔情似水的一面。
The head-turning opening of six characters, three-beat short phrases speaking directly, is the ci's explosion of feeling. 'Bowels already broken' writes grief at its extreme: ancients used 'broken bowels' for utmost sorrow, as Jiang Yan's 'the dark and soul-shaking is parting alone,' and Bai Juyi's 'one night, homesick heart in five places'; 'tears hard to hold' writes grief hard to control: tears once flowing cannot be gathered back. The two use 'already' and 'hard' to write the helplessness to the quick. In syntax, three characters against three, the rhythm short and urgent, like weeping, forming a cadenced contrast with the upper stanza's flowing seven-character lines — the voice change at the ci's 'head turn.' In feeling, the hypothetical talk of 'if' above falls into the actual state of 'broken bowels, tears hard to hold'; the gap between ideal and reality is all in these six characters. Jiaxuan's bold ci occasionally shows a restrained stroke, and these six best show his tender, water-like side.
情知已被山遮断,频倚阑干不自由。
Knowing, clearly, already, by the mountains, cut off, hidden, frequently, leaning, the railings, not, free, the self.
明明知道视线已被远山遮断,却还是身不由己地一次次倚着阑干眺望。
Well I know the sight is already blocked by the distant hills, yet again and again I lean on the railing, powerless to stop.
结拍以「明知不可而为之」写痴情,是全文情感之归结。「情知已被山遮断」:明明知道归人的身影早被远山遮断,望也望不见——「情知」二字,写出思妇的清醒;而「频倚阑干不自由」,却仍一次次身不由己地倚阑远望——「频」字写次数之密、相思之切,「不自由」三字写痴情之不由自主:明知无望,偏要倚望,正是情到深处、身不由己的写照。欧阳修《踏莎行》「平芜尽处是春山,行人更在春山外」,写春山之外更有人,望之不及;辛弃疾此句反写明知山遮断而仍倚阑,望之不已——一写距离之远,一写痴情之执,异曲同工。以「不自由」收束全词,离恨之深、相思之痴、无奈之重,尽在此三字,余韵不尽。
The close writes dotage through 'knowing it cannot be yet doing it anyway,' the conclusion of the ci's feeling. 'Well I know the sight is already blocked by the distant hills': the figure of the one returning is long blocked by far hills, and gazing will not bring it — 'well I know' writes the waiting woman's clear-sightedness. Yet 'again and again I lean on the railing, powerless to stop': still, helpless, she leans and gazes — 'again and again' writes the frequency and keenness of longing, 'powerless' writes the involuntariness of dotage: knowing it hopeless, yet still leaning and gazing, the portrait of feeling at its deepest, the body beyond control. Ouyang Xiu's 'at the green plain's edge are spring hills, and the traveler is beyond the spring hills' writes a person beyond the hills, out of gaze; Xin's line reverses it — knowing the hills block the sight, yet still leaning, gazing without end; one writes the distance, the other the fixation of dotage, the two reaching the same by different roads. Closing the ci on 'powerless' gathers the depth of parting grief, the madness of longing, the weight of helplessness into these three characters, the aftertone unending.
Study
Word focus
Related Reading
Compare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
温庭筠《望江南·梳洗罢》「过尽千帆皆不是,斜晖脉脉水悠悠。肠断白蘋洲」与辛弃疾此词同写思妇倚楼望归,而情态有别:温词写思妇梳洗登楼,看尽千帆皆不是归人,是「期待—落空」的循环,肠断于白蘋洲头;辛词写思妇明知山遮断而仍「频倚阑干」,是「清醒—执念」的纠缠,身不由己。温词之愁在「等待的落空」,辛词之愁在「相思的无可摆脱」;一写实景之尽,一写痴情之执。二词对读,可见同一题材由唐入宋的深化:温庭筠以景结情,含蓄蕴藉;辛弃疾以理入情、以态写情,更深一层,而「肠断」一语,正承温词「肠断白蘋洲」而来。
一剪梅·红藕香残玉簟秋 A Twig of Mume Blossoms: Red Lotus Fragrance Fades on the Jade Mat in Autumn 李清照 · 宋人闺情离愁的对照 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
李清照《一剪梅》「花自飘零水自流。一种相思,两处闲愁。此情无计可消除,才下眉头,却上心头」与辛弃疾《鹧鸪天》同写相思离愁,而身份有别:李清照是女性自写其情,笔触细腻婉转,「才下眉头,却上心头」写愁之缠人,如影随形;辛弃疾是男性代拟闺情,笔致清刚深挚,「频倚阑干不自由」写情之不由自主,如茧自缚。一写愁之「去而复来」,一写望之「明知无望」,皆把抽象之愁写得可触可感。二词一为婉约正宗,一为豪放词人之婉约变体,合观可见宋代闺情词的两副笔墨,而「愁」字之深,殊途同归。
雨霖铃·寒蝉凄切 Bells Ringing in the Rain - Cold Cicadas' Sad Cry 柳永 · 别后相思的两种想象 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
柳永《雨霖铃》「今宵酒醒何处?杨柳岸,晓风残月」「便纵有千种风情,更与何人说」与辛弃疾此词同写离别相思,而时间维度有别:柳词写的是「别时」对「别后」的想象——设想酒醒后在杨柳岸边、晓风残月中的孤独,凄清而苍茫;辛词写的是「别后」的反复相思——重上小红楼、频倚阑干,具体而执著。柳永是男性自道别情,辛弃疾是代人设言闺思;柳词之境空阔清冷,辛词之态缠绵痴绝。二词对照,可见宋词写离愁的两种典范:一以境胜,一以情胜,而皆能「状难写之景如在目前,含不尽之意见于言外」。