近现代 近现代 · 诗 Poem
青春
Youth (Qingchun)
所有的结局都已写好,所有的泪水也都已启程,却忽然忘了是怎么样的一个开始,在那个古老的不再回来的夏日。
All the endings have already been written, all the tears have already set out on the journey, yet I suddenly forget what kind of a beginning it was, in that ancient summer that does not come back.Meaning
A famous poem of Xi Murong, written in 1979, collected in the collection 'The Youth without Regret' (1983). The whole poem of two stanzas and four lines, this excerpt being the first stanza, writes the 'looking back': the opening, 'all the endings have already been written, all the tears have already set out on the journey'—the two parallel sentences of the 'all... already...' writing the youth as a completed thing—the endings written, like the book closed; the tears setting out, like the train departed—the two 'already' writing the irrevocability of the youth; 'yet I suddenly forget what kind of a beginning it was'—the turn, the forgetting of the beginning, the vagueness of the memory; 'in that ancient summer that does not come back'—the close, the ancient summer that does not come back, the remoteness of the youth. The poem, with the plain and the shallow language, writes the common wistfulness of the youth, and can move all the people.
所有的结局都早已写好,所有的泪水也都已经启程出发,却忽然忘记了那是一个怎样的开始,在那个古老的、再也回不去的夏日。
Appreciation
The art of this poem lies in the 'the writing of the most common wistfulness with the extremely clear and shallow language, and the moving of all the people.' The whole poem of two stanzas and four lines, the first stanza (the excerpt) writing the 'looking back': the opening with the two parallel sentences of the 'all the endings have already been written, all the tears have already set out on the journey' writing the youth as a completed thing—the endings written, like the book closed; the tears setting out, like the train departed—the two 'already' the irrevocability of the youth, the past already past; 'yet I suddenly forget what kind of a beginning it was'—the turn, the forgetting of the beginning, the memory of the youth vague, the wistfulness of the forgetting; 'in that ancient summer that does not come back'—the 'ancient' and the 'does not come back' the remoteness and the irrevocability of the youth, the wistfulness of the close. The whole poem, with the plain and the shallow language and the clear and the colloquial tone, the common wistfulness of the youth written with the simple, the eternal resonance of the youth of all the people.
【白话串讲】 席慕蓉写《青春》:“所有的结局都已写好,所有的泪水也都已启程,却忽然忘了是怎么样的一个开始,在那个古老的不再回来的夏日”——“含着泪,我一读再读,却不得不承认,青春是一本太仓促的书”——她写青春仓促。 【意象与手法】 诗以「所有的……都已……」的排比起势,两个「都已」写尽青春的「完成态」;「却忽然忘了」以转折宕开,由结局折回开始;「古老的」「不再回来的」两个修饰语层层限定,把夏日推向不可企及的远方。全诗意象单纯(结局、泪水、开始、夏日)而意蕴丰富,语言清丽如口语,节奏舒缓如回忆,是席慕蓉「清浅见深」诗风的典型。 【情感与主旨】 此诗写对青春逝去的追忆与怅惘:青春之所以珍贵,正因为它「不再回来」;而人之所以怅惘,是因为回望时只记得结局与泪水,却忘了最初的美好。「忘了开始」不是真的遗忘,而是岁月把开始推得太远——远到如同古老的夏日,只能在记忆的尽头依稀辨认。这是人人共通的青春体验,也是此诗能引起广泛共鸣的原因。 【名句点睛】 「在那个古老的不再回来的夏日」是全诗情感最浓的一句:「古老」写时间之远,「不再回来」写永逝之痛,「夏日」是青春最典型的意象——热烈、明亮、漫长,而终究要过去。一句之中,把青春的珍贵与不可复返写得淋漓尽致,令人低回不已。
Background
Xi Murong (1943–), born in Chongqing, Sichuan, ancestral home in the Ming'an Banner of the Chahar League of Inner Mongolia, of the Mongolian nationality, original name Mulun Xilianbo (the 'the great river' of the Mongolian), the famous Taiwanese woman poet, essayist, and painter. She moved to Hong Kong with her family in 1949 and to Taiwan in 1954, and after graduating from the art department of the Taiwan Normal University went to Belgium for the advanced study at the Royal Academy of Fine Arts of Brussels, specializing in the oil painting, and returned to Taiwan to teach in 1966. Xi Murong began the creation in the 1960s, and in 1981 published her first collection of poems, the 'Seven Miles of Fragrance,' sweeping Taiwan, the sales record of the collections of poems of Taiwan, and thereafter the 'The Youth without Regret' (1983) and other collections. This poem was written in 1979, collected in the 'The Youth without Regret,' when Xi Murong was over thirty, looking back on the youth of the past, the wistfulness of the passage of the years, the poem the eternal resonance of the youth of all the people.
席慕蓉(1943—),生于四川重庆,祖籍内蒙古察哈尔盟明安旗,蒙古族,原名穆伦·席连勃(蒙古语「大江河」之意),台湾著名女诗人、散文家、画家。她1949年随家迁居香港,1954年迁居台湾,台湾师范大学艺术系毕业后赴比利时布鲁塞尔皇家艺术学院深造,专攻油画,1966年返台任教。席慕蓉1960年代开始创作,1981年出版第一部诗集《七里香》,风靡台湾,一纸风行,创下台湾诗集销售纪录,其后《无怨的青春》(1983)、《时光九篇》(1987)等接连问世,成为1980年代台湾「新女性诗歌」的代表人物。《青春》一诗收入《无怨的青春》,作于1979年,时年诗人三十六岁,正当人生由青年向中年过渡之际。席慕蓉的诗以清丽婉约见长,多写爱情、青春、乡愁与时光的咏叹,《青春》正是其「时光咏叹」主题的代表作——全诗以「青春是本太仓促的书」收束,把青春写成一本仓促翻完的书,怅惘之情溢于言表。此诗作于台湾经济起飞、都市化加速的背景下,现代人在快节奏的生活中日益感到青春的易逝,席慕蓉以清浅的诗句写出这普遍的时代情绪,遂能引发跨越地域与年代的广泛共鸣。
Art
The art is the 'the writing of the common wistfulness with the extremely clear and shallow language': the two parallel sentences of the 'all... already...' writing the youth as a completed thing, the two 'already' the irrevocability, the turn of the forgetting of the beginning, and the close of the 'ancient summer that does not come back'—the plain and the shallow, the clear and the colloquial, the eternal resonance of the youth.
此诗的艺术,在「以极清浅的语言写极普通的怅惘,而能打动所有人」。全诗两节四行,第一节(即本节所选)写「回首」:起笔以「所有的结局都已写好,所有的泪水也都已启程」两个「所有的……都已……」的排比句,把青春写成一件已完成的事物——结局写好,如书已合卷;泪水启程,如列车已发——两个「都已」都是「完成时态」,青春的「完成感」扑面而来。第三句「却忽然忘了是怎么样的一个开始」以「却忽然」转折,由结局折回开始,笔势一宕:「忘了」二字是全诗的关键——不是「记得」而是「忘了」,追忆中最先浮起的竟是遗忘本身,怅惘由此而生。末句「在那个古老的不再回来的夏日」以两个修饰语层层收束:「古老」写时间之远,「不再回来」写永逝之不可追,最后落在「夏日」这一青春最典型的意象上——热烈、明亮、漫长,而终究要过去。全诗结构为「排比—转折—收束」:两个排比句铺陈青春的完成态,一个转折句引出追忆的怅惘,一个限定句把怅惘定格于不可复返的夏日。语言上不用一个生僻字,句句如口语,而「写好」「启程」「忘了」「不再回来」四个动词短语,把青春的完成、泪水的远行、记忆的模糊、时间的永逝写得层层递进,正是席慕蓉「浅语深情」的本领。
Allusions
Though this poem is a modern new poem, its emotional core is deeply rooted in the long tradition of the 'the cherishing of the time and the lamenting of the spring' of the Chinese literature. The theme of the 'youth' in the classical Chinese poetry has a long history: the 'Long Song' of the Han yuefu, 'the young and the strong do not work hard, and the old and the gray are left with the vain sorrow,' first opens the sigh of the cherishing of the time; Du Qiuniang's 'The Golden Dress,' 'the advise you not to cherish the golden dress, the advise you to cherish the time of the youth,' the admonition of the cherishing of the youth; and the 'the flowers may be again and again picked' of the 'The Moon of the Fifteenth' of the yuefu, the 'the flowers can be reborn, and the man never again young' of the 'the evening of the years' of the modern. The poem, with the 'all the endings have already been written' and the 'ancient summer that does not come back,' the modern expression of the ancient motif of the cherishing of the time, the deep feeling of the youth of the Chinese literature.
此诗虽为现代新诗,其情感内核却深植于中国文学「惜时伤春」的悠久传统。「青春」主题在中国古典诗词中源远流长:汉乐府《长歌行》「少壮不努力,老大徒伤悲」首开惜时之叹;杜秋娘《金缕衣》「劝君莫惜金缕衣,劝君惜取少年时」以劝勉出之;晏殊《浣溪沙》「无可奈何花落去,似曾相识燕归来」以怅惘出之——青春与时光的咏叹,是古典诗词最恒久的母题之一。席慕蓉此诗正是这一传统在现代新诗中的回响:「所有的结局都已写好」是「无可奈何」的现代变奏,「不再回来的夏日」是「花落去」的现代转译,而全诗怅惘而不颓唐、追忆而不沉溺的调子,又近于李清照「物是人非事事休,欲语泪先流」的含蓄与节制。更可注意的是,「夏日」意象的选择:中国古典惜时诗多写春(春去花落、春恨秋悲),席慕蓉却选择「夏日」——夏日热烈、漫长、明亮,是青春最贴切的象征,而「古老的不再回来的夏日」,把一个具体的夏日推入时间的深处,如一张褪色的老照片,比「春天」的意象更具现代生活的质感。此诗以古典的怅惘之情,装进现代口语的瓶子,正是席慕蓉「旧情新酿」的创造。
Commentary
The 'Youth' is one of the most widely circulated poems of Xi Murong and the most famous 'hymn of the youth' of the Chinese-speaking world since the 1980s. In the background of the creation, this poem was written in 1979, collected in the 'The Youth without Regret' (1983), when Xi Murong was over thirty, looking back on the youth of the past, the wistfulness of the passage of the years; and in the reception, the poem, with the plain and the shallow language, writes the common wistfulness of the youth, and can move all the people, has been recited and anthologized by countless readers, the eternal resonance of the youth; and in the artistic achievement, the poem, with the four lines, the 'all the endings have already been written, all the tears have already set out on the journey' and the 'ancient summer that does not come back,' the youth written with the concise and the deep, the very model of the modern lyric.
《青春》是席慕蓉流传最广的诗作之一,也是1980年代以来华语世界最著名的「青春咏叹」诗篇。就创作背景言,此诗作于1979年,收入《无怨的青春》(1983),其时席慕蓉已三十六岁,诗名初起而渐趋成熟,此诗与《七里香》《一棵开花的树》等共同奠定了她「清丽婉约、深情浅语」的诗风,使她成为台湾「新女性诗歌」中影响最大、读者最广的诗人之一。就接受史言,《青春》自发表以来,被无数人抄录、传诵、引用,成为一代代青年回望青春时最先想起的诗句;「青春是本太仓促的书」更成为流行语,被反复引用,可见其情感的普遍性与穿透力。就文学史言,席慕蓉的诗在1980年代的台湾乃至整个华语世界引发「席慕蓉现象」——其诗以清浅的语言写普遍的人情(青春、爱情、乡愁),打破现代诗「艰深晦涩」的壁垒,让诗歌重新走近大众读者,对此后华语现代诗的通俗化、抒情化转向产生了深远影响。《青春》一诗,正是这一「席慕蓉现象」的典型样本:以最清浅的语言,写出最普遍的怅惘,让每一个读者都能在其中照见自己的青春。
Prosody
Line by line
所有的结局都已写好,所有的泪水也都已启程,
All the endings have already been written, all the tears have already set out on the journey, (The opening: the two parallel sentences of the 'all... already...' writing the youth as a completed thing, the endings written and the tears set out, the irrevocability of the youth.)
所有的结局都早已写好,所有的泪水也都已经启程出发。
All the endings have been written, all the tears have already set out,
起笔两个「所有的……都已……」的排比句,把青春写成一件「已完成」的事物,时间的完成感扑面而来。「所有的结局都已写好」——如一本早已合卷的书,结局已定,无可更改,一个「写」字,把人生写成一场早已落笔的书写,宿命感油然而生;「所有的泪水也都已启程」——泪水不是「流下」而是「启程」,如列车、如舟船,早已出发,正在路上,一个「启程」把悲伤写成一场必然到来的远行,其势不可挡。两句合观,「结局」与「泪水」并举:青春之书以结局为终,以泪水为伴——回望青春,最先浮现的竟是既定的结局与咸涩的泪水,这正是「过来人」的视角:只有青春已逝,才能看清它的结局与泪水。两个「都已」连用,句式复沓,如潮水连涌,把「完成」二字反复敲定,为下句「却忽然忘了」的转折蓄足张力。
The endings. All the endings have been written, all the tears have already set out. The written endings and the set-out tears are the opening. To have written the endings would be a writing; the all-the-endings-have-been-written-all-the-tears-have-already-set-out is the writing.
却忽然忘了是怎么样的一个开始,在那个古老的不再回来的夏日。
yet I suddenly forget what kind of a beginning it was, in that ancient summer that does not come back. (The close: the forgetting of the beginning and the ancient summer that does not come back, the remoteness and the irrevocability of the youth, the wistfulness of the close.)
却忽然忘记了那是一个怎样的开始,在那个古老的、再也回不去的夏日。
yet suddenly I forget what the beginning was like, in that old summer that will not return.
两句是全诗的情感核心,由「结局」折回「开始」,怅惘由此而生。「却忽然忘了」四字是全诗的转折枢纽:前句刚说「结局都已写好、泪水都已启程」,此句却说「忘了开始」——记得结局而忘了开始,记得泪水而忘了初心,这正是追忆的普遍困境:岁月愈久,最初的美好愈被冲淡,反而尘埃落定后的怅惘愈见清晰。「是怎么样的一个开始」——「怎么样」三字写得极妙:不是「忘了开始」,而是忘了「是怎么样的」开始,一个模糊的、说不清道不明的开始,如晨雾中的远景,依稀可辨而不可把捉。「在那个古老的不再回来的夏日」以两个修饰语层层收束:「古老」写时间之远,「不再回来」写永逝之痛,落在「夏日」上——热烈、明亮、漫长而终究要过去的夏日,正是青春最贴切的象征。全句由「忘了」的模糊,落到「不再回来」的确凿,怅惘之情如潮水漫上心头,令人低回不已。
The summer. yet suddenly I forget what the beginning was like, in that old summer that will not return. The forgotten beginning and the old summer that will not return are the close. To have forgotten the beginning would be a forgetting; the yet-suddenly-i-forget-what-the-beginning-was-like-in-that-old-summer-that-will-not-return is the forgetting.
Study
Word focus
Related Reading
The 'A Tree in Flower'—'how to make you meet me, in my most beautiful moment... I have prayed before the Buddha for five hundred years, to beg him to let us have this earthly connection'—writes the waiting of the love, the tree in flower of the waiting; the 'Youth'—'all the endings have already been written... in that ancient summer that does not come back'—writes the passing of the youth, the wistfulness of the passage. One the love and one the youth; one the tree in flower of the waiting and one the summer that does not come back—the companion pieces of the same collection of Xi Murong, the love and the youth, the two eternal themes of the woman poet.
《一棵开花的树》(收入《七里香》)「如何让你遇见我,在我最美丽的时刻,为这,我已在佛前求了五百年,求它让我们结一段尘缘」,以一棵树在佛前求五百年、只为在最美丽的时刻遇见心上人的想象,写爱情的热烈与执著;《青春》以「结局写好、泪水启程、忘了开始」写青春的追忆与怅惘。两诗同为席慕蓉「时光咏叹」的代表作,而方向不同:一写「当下」——在最美的时刻等候遇见,是向前的、热切的;一写「回首」——在结局之后追忆开始,是向后的、怅惘的。一热一冷、一执著一低回,正见席慕蓉诗歌的两副笔墨:她既能写「求了五百年」的热烈,也能写「不再回来」的怅惘,而两诗共通的,是那种清丽婉约、深情浅语的诗风。
错误 Mistake 郑愁予 · 同为台湾现代诗「时光与等待」的经典,一古典一清浅 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
郑愁予《错误》(1954)「我打江南走过,那等在季节里的容颜如莲花的开落」「我不是归人,是个过客」,以古典意象(江南、莲花、青石的街道向晚)写一场错过的等待,语调典雅而苍凉;《青春》以现代口语(结局写好、泪水启程、忘了开始)写青春的一去不返,语调清浅而怅惘。两诗同为台湾现代诗中最广为传诵的抒情名篇,同写「时光与错过」的母题:郑愁予的「过客」是人与人的错过,席慕蓉的「忘了开始」是人与自己的错过——错过的都是回不去的时光。而两诗风格迥异:郑诗是古典的、意象密集的,席诗是现代口语的、意象单纯的。两诗并读,可见台湾现代诗抒情传统的两种路数,亦见「错过」母题在华语诗歌中的恒久魅力。
浣溪沙·游蕲水清泉寺 Silk-Washing Stream: A Cup of Wine, A New Song 苏轼 · 同写时光流逝,一怅惘于永逝,一旷达于再少 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
苏轼《浣溪沙·游蕲水清泉寺》(1082)「谁道人生无再少?门前流水尚能西!休将白发唱黄鸡」,以溪水尚能西流反驳「人生无再少」的成见,发出「休将白发唱黄鸡」的旷达强音;《青春》以「不再回来的夏日」写青春的永逝,怅惘低回。两作相隔九百年,同写时光主题而态度相反:苏轼以「流水尚能西」的旷达化解光阴之叹,席慕蓉以「不再回来」的怅惘接受青春之逝——一为儒道精神的「乐天知命」,一为现代人的「追忆似水年华」。其异其同,正见「时光」母题在中国文学中的两种基本姿态:或超脱(「门前流水尚能西」),或低回(「不再回来的夏日」),而两者都指向人对时间最深的感受——无论旷达还是怅惘,时光之逝都是人心中最柔软的一角。