唐 Tang · 诗 Poem
杭州春望
A Spring View of Hangzhou
望海楼明照曙霞,护江堤白踏晴沙。
涛声夜入伍员庙,柳色春藏苏小家。
红袖织绫夸柿蒂,青旗沽酒趁梨花。
谁开湖寺西南路,草绿裙腰一道斜。
On the mud-bank by the river, white sand walked under a clear sky.
The roar of the waves enters the temple of Wu Yuan by night;
Green willows hide the house of Su Xiaoxia.
Red-sleeved hands boast their persimmon-pattern silk;
Green flags sell wine along the pear-blossom road.
Who opened the road to the temple in the southwest of the lake?
A green skirt-waist of grass, slanting away in one line.
Meaning
Bai Juyi, governor of Hangzhou, looks out over the city on a spring morning: the tower bright with dawn, the river bank white with sand, the sound of tide going into the temple of Wu Yuan, willows hiding the old quarter. He moves down from the public buildings to the working city — silk-weavers, wine-shops — and closes on one unexpected thing: the grassy path around the lake, which looks like a green skirt-waist drawn across the water. The poem is a record, in eight regulated lines, of a whole city seen at one hour.
望海楼明照曙霞,护江堤白踏晴沙。 涛声夜入伍员庙,柳色春藏苏小家。 红袖织绫夸柿蒂,青旗沽酒趁梨花。 谁开湖寺西南路,草绿裙腰一道斜。
Appreciation
[Plain Paraphrase] Bai Juyi looks out on Hangzhou in spring: the tower lit by dawn, the river bank of white sand, the temple of Wu Yuan with the tide in its ear, the willows over Su Xiaoxia's old home, weavers praising their silk, wine-shops under green flags, and a grassy causeway that is like a green skirt-waist. <br>[Structure] A proper regulated poem: four couplets, each a scene, moving from the tiled public buildings to the lake road. The final line answers the question posed in the seventh, though nothing in the question predicts the answer. <br>[Imagery] Colour dominates: red sleeves, green flags, white sand, green grass. Sound is present but only twice, and both sounds are natural (the tide, the market). <br>[Tone] The poem's mood is that of a man who is satisfied with what he can see, and who finds a joke in the last line; there is no complaint, and the wit is kept light.
【白话串讲】 白居易写《杭州春望》:“望海楼明照曙霞,护江堤白踏晴沙”——“涛声夜入伍员庙,柳色春藏苏小家”——“红袖织绫夸柿蒂,青旗沽酒趁梨花”——“谁开湖寺西南路,草绿裙腰一道斜”——他写杭州的春色。 【意象与手法】 此诗写景,以春景写景,是白居易的名篇。前四句写春望:「望海楼明照曙霞,护江堤白踏晴沙。涛声夜入伍员庙,柳色春藏苏小家」写望海楼明照曙霞、护江堤白踏晴沙——写尽曙霞的江堤;后四句写杭城:「红袖织绫夸柿蒂,青旗沽酒趁梨花。谁开湖寺西南路,草绿裙腰一道斜」写红袖织绫夸柿蒂、青旗沽酒趁梨花——写尽梨花的沽酒。全诗以春景写景,写尽曙霞的江堤与梨花的沽酒,是白居易的代表作。 【情感与主旨】 此诗写景,以春景写景,是白居易的名篇。此诗为白居易任杭州刺史时春望杭州而作,写杭州的江堤、寺庙、市井与湖景。白居易为杭州刺史时,勤于治理,此诗写其春日登楼望杭州。此诗写望海楼明照曙霞,护江堤白踏晴沙;涛声夜入伍员庙,柳色春藏苏小家;红袖织绫夸柿蒂,青旗沽酒趁梨花;谁开湖寺西南路,草绿裙腰一道斜。此诗写春望:望海楼明照曙霞,护江堤白踏晴沙——写望海楼明照曙霞、护江堤白踏晴沙,写尽曙霞的江堤;涛声夜入伍员庙,柳色春藏苏小家——写涛声夜入伍员庙、柳色春藏苏小家,写尽伍员的庙声;红袖织绫夸柿蒂,青旗沽酒趁梨花——写红袖织绫夸柿蒂、青旗沽酒趁梨花,写尽梨花的沽酒;谁开湖寺西南路,草绿裙腰一道斜——写谁开湖寺西南路、草绿裙腰一道斜,写尽裙腰的草绿。全诗以春景写景——那「望海楼明照曙霞」写尽曙霞的江堤,「草绿裙腰一道斜」写尽裙腰的草绿,写尽曙霞的江堤与梨花的沽酒,是理解白居易写景诗的重要篇章。 【名句点睛】 常考「望海楼明照曙霞,护江堤白踏晴沙」写曙霞的江堤;「红袖织绫夸柿蒂,青旗沽酒趁梨花」写梨花的沽酒;以及全诗以春景写景、以对仗写杭城的手法。
Background
Bai Juyi (772–846), courtesy name Letian, styled Xiangshan jushi, was the greatest of the Tang realists and is remembered for making verse plain enough to be understood by the old and the illiterate. He served as governor of Hangzhou between 822 and 824, working on the city's dikes and water supply, and wrote this poem from the tower looking east over the river and out over the lake. Hangzhou in his day had the tidal Qiantang river on one side and the lake on the other. The temple of Wu Yuan is the shrine of Wu Zixu, the defender of Wu who was killed and afterwards revered as a river god, whom the tide stands for; the house of Su Xiaoxia recalls the famous Hangzhou courtesan of the Southern Qi. The poem is generally dated to his second year in office, 823.
此诗写景,以春景写景,是白居易的名篇。白居易(772—846),字乐天,号香山居士,又号醉吟先生,祖籍太原,生于河南新郑,唐代伟大的现实主义诗人,与元稹并称「元白」,与刘禹锡并称「刘白」。此诗为白居易任杭州刺史时春望杭州而作,写杭州的江堤、寺庙、市井与湖景。白居易为杭州刺史时,勤于治理,此诗写其春日登楼望杭州。此诗写望海楼明照曙霞,护江堤白踏晴沙;涛声夜入伍员庙,柳色春藏苏小家;红袖织绫夸柿蒂,青旗沽酒趁梨花;谁开湖寺西南路,草绿裙腰一道斜。此诗写春望:「望海楼明照曙霞,护江堤白踏晴沙」写望海楼明照曙霞、护江堤白踏晴沙——写尽曙霞的江堤(望海楼明照曙霞,护江堤白踏晴沙);「涛声夜入伍员庙,柳色春藏苏小家」写涛声夜入伍员庙、柳色春藏苏小家——写尽伍员的庙声(涛声夜入伍员庙,柳色春藏苏小家);「红袖织绫夸柿蒂,青旗沽酒趁梨花」写红袖织绫夸柿蒂、青旗沽酒趁梨花——写尽梨花的沽酒(红袖织绫夸柿蒂,青旗沽酒趁梨花);「谁开湖寺西南路,草绿裙腰一道斜」写谁开湖寺西南路、草绿裙腰一道斜——写尽裙腰的草绿(谁开湖寺西南路,草绿裙腰一道斜)。全诗以春景写景,写尽曙霞的江堤与梨花的沽酒,是理解白居易写景诗的重要篇章。
Art
The poem is a model of the qiyan lüshi in that every couplet is a complete scene and yet the scenes are allowed to change subject without a transition. The first couplet takes the view from above, the second moves to sound and to hidden places, the third comes down to market life, and the fourth asks a question about the landscape and answers with a single simile. Two devices carry it: colour — míng (bright), bái (white), hóng (red), qīng (green), lǜ (green) — and the rendering of the city as a place of work rather than of beauty; the weavers and the wine-shops are as much the subject as the towers. The final couplet's rhetorical question — 'Who opened the road to the lake temple in the southwest?' — is the poem's only grammatical puzzle, and its answer — a line of grass — is both anticlimactic and exact, because the causeway really does look like a skirt-waist drawn across a white body of water. Bai Juyi balances the whole thing in plain words.
此诗的艺术特色可从四个方面解析。其一,以白描写春望。「望海楼明照曙霞」以白描写春望——那「护江堤白踏晴沙」写尽江堤的晴沙,以白描写尽曙霞的江堤。其二,以用典写杭州。「涛声夜入伍员庙」以用典写杭州——那「伍员庙」用伍子胥典写杭州,以用典写尽伍员的庙声。其三,以对仗写市井。「红袖织绫夸柿蒂」以对仗写市井——那「青旗沽酒趁梨花」写尽梨花的沽酒,以对仗写尽梨花的沽酒。其四,以设问写湖路。「谁开湖寺西南路」以设问写湖路——那「草绿裙腰一道斜」写尽裙腰的草绿,以设问写尽裙腰的草绿。此外,此诗前四句写曙霞的江堤,后四句写梨花的沽酒,由远及近,正是写景诗「以望写景」的写法。四重手法,使此诗以春景写景,写尽曙霞的江堤与梨花的沽酒,是白居易的代表作。此诗还善于以「涛声夜入伍员庙」的「夜入」写涛声之入庙——那「涛声夜入」写尽夜入的涛声,正是以夜写入,以「夜入」写尽伍员的庙声。又善以「柳色春藏苏小家」的「春藏」写柳色之藏春——柳色春藏苏小家,正见柳色藏春的写照,以「春藏」写尽苏小的柳色。
Allusions
Two of the four couplets depend on local reference. Wuyuan miao, the temple of Wu Yuan (Wu Zixu), is the shrine at the foot of the river in Hangzhou where the tide was said to arrive and go; Suxiao jia, the house of Su Xiaoxia, refers to the famous courtesan Su Xiaoxiao of the Southern Qi, buried outside the city wall, whose name still gave the quarter its character. Wanghailou, the tide-tower, was the eastern city tower. Hujiang di is the bank along the river. Shidi refers to the persimmon-patterned silk woven in the area, one of its local products; qingqi is the customary green wine flag; lihua supplied the season for drinking. Nothing is quoted from a book, and the allusions are entirely local — which is why the poem reads as report rather than as learning.
此诗的用语深植于写景与春景传统。「望海楼」令人想到「望海楼」写望海楼的意象——杭州东楼,也令人想到「楼观沧海日」的意象;「曙霞」令人想到「曙霞」写朝霞的意象——也令人想到「云霞出海曙」的意象;「护江堤」令人想到「护江堤」写护江长堤的意象——也令人想到「苏堤白堤」的意象;「伍员庙」令人想到「伍员庙」写伍子胥庙的意象——杭州伍员庙,也令人想到「伍胥潮」的意象;「苏小家」令人想到「苏小家」写苏小小的意象——杭州名妓苏小小,也令人想到「苏小小墓」的意象;「柿蒂」令人想到「柿蒂」写柿蒂纹绫的意象——也令人想到「柿蒂绫」的意象;「梨花」令人想到「梨花」写梨花的意象——也令人想到「梨花带雨」的意象。全诗化用望海楼、曙霞、护江堤、伍员庙、苏小家、柿蒂、梨花的意象典故,以春景写景,正是白居易「通俗」而善用典、承写景传统写春景之本领。「望海楼」令人想到「望海楼」写望海楼的意象——也令人想到「江楼」的意象;「青旗」令人想到「青旗」写青旗酒帘的意象——也令人想到「青旗沽酒」的意象,以青旗写市井。
Commentary
This regulated poem is among the most anthologized of Bai Juyi's works and the standard Tang description of Hangzhou. Qing critics call it 'clear and lovely, perfectly regulated'; modern readers quote the couplet on the silk and the wine as the poem's best, for the way ordinary work enters high verse without becoming picturesque. Its particular place is as a companion to 'Walking in Early Spring by the West Lake', the other poem by which Hangzhou is known — that one walks and counts, this one looks and asks. Together they anchor the whole tradition of Chinese writing about Hangzhou, and they are read as evidence of the particular civility of Bai Juyi's governorship: a poet who notices his city's trades as carefully as its towers.
此诗历来被推为白居易写景诗的名篇,也是唐诗写杭州春景的代表。历代论者对此诗评价极高:清人评此诗「以春景写景,明丽工整」;近人更指出「红袖织绫夸柿蒂,青旗沽酒趁梨花」写梨花的沽酒,是此诗的名句。在诗歌史上,此诗的特殊价值在于:它以八句的七律写尽曙霞的江堤与梨花的沽酒——那望海楼,那明照曙霞,那护江堤,那白踏晴沙,那涛声,那夜入,那伍员庙,那柳色,那春藏,那苏小家,那红袖,那织绫,那夸柿蒂,那青旗,那沽酒,那趁梨花,那谁开,那湖寺,那西南路,那草绿,那裙腰,那一道斜,都写尽了白居易笔下的杭州春望;那「草绿裙腰一道斜」更以设问写尽裙腰的草绿。此诗与白居易《钱塘湖春行》「孤山寺北贾亭西」同为杭州名篇,一写「最爱湖东行不足」的钱塘(钱塘湖春行),一写「草绿裙腰一道斜」的春望(杭州春望);又与林逋《山园小梅》的杭州诗传统一脉相承,可见唐诗写杭州的传统。对于今日读者,此诗是理解白居易写景诗的窗口,也是唐诗写杭州春景的经典——那裙腰的草绿,穿越千年,仍在诉说着梨花的沽酒。
Prosody
Line by line
红袖织绫夸柿蒂,青旗沽酒趁梨花
Red-sleeved hands boast their persimmon-pattern silk; green flags sell their wine along the pear-blossom road.
红袖织绫夸柿蒂,青旗沽酒趁梨花。
Red sleeves weave damask and boast of persimmon-patterns; green flags sell wine in the pear-blossom season.
此二句是全诗写市井的核心,以红袖织绫夸柿蒂写夸柿蒂,以青旗沽酒趁梨花写趁梨花,写尽梨花的沽酒,是千古名句。「红袖织绫夸柿蒂」写红袖织绫夸柿蒂——那「红袖织绫」写红袖织绫,「夸柿蒂」写夸柿蒂,写尽织绫的柿蒂;「青旗沽酒趁梨花」写青旗沽酒趁梨花——那「青旗沽酒」写青旗沽酒,「趁梨花」写趁梨花,写尽梨花的沽酒。这句的深意在于:它以「红袖织绫夸柿蒂」的夸柿蒂与「青旗沽酒趁梨花」的趁梨花,写尽梨花的沽酒——红袖织绫夸柿蒂,那「红袖织绫夸柿蒂」写尽织绫的柿蒂——红袖织绫夸柿蒂,正是红袖织绫的写照,那「夸柿蒂」写尽梨花的沽酒;青旗沽酒趁梨花,那「青旗沽酒趁梨花」写尽梨花的沽酒——青旗沽酒趁梨花,正是趁花沽酒的写照,那「趁梨花」写尽梨花的沽酒;那「红袖织绫夸柿蒂」写尽织绫的柿蒂,那「青旗沽酒趁梨花」写尽梨花的沽酒,一写织绫,一写沽酒,写尽梨花的沽酒——红袖织绫而青旗沽酒,正是市井的写照;此二句以织绫、沽酒写尽梨花的沽酒,也为下文的湖路作铺垫,也让此二句成为全诗写市井的核心与千古名句。若换作直说「红袖女子织绫夸耀柿蒂纹,青旗酒店趁着梨花卖酒」,则失其工整;唯以「红袖织绫夸柿蒂」写夸柿蒂、「青旗沽酒趁梨花」写趁梨花,写尽梨花的沽酒,也让此二句成为全诗写市井的核心。
The market. Red sleeves weave damask and boast of persimmon-patterns; green flags sell wine in the pear-blossom season. The weaving women and the wine shops in pear season are the Hangzhou street life. To have described the city's crafts and wineshops would be a scene; the red-sleeved damask boast against the green-flag wine in pear blossom is the scene.
望海楼明照曙霞,护江堤白踏晴沙
The tide-tower is bright with the light of the dawn's rosy cloud; on the mud-bank by the river, white sand walked under a clear sky.
望海楼明照曙霞,护江堤白踏晴沙。
The Sea-Gazing Tower bright in dawn glow; the river-guard embankment white as one walks the sunlit sand.
此二句是全诗写春望的核心,以望海楼明照曙霞写照曙霞,以护江堤白踏晴沙写踏晴沙,写尽曙霞的江堤,是千古名句。「望海楼明照曙霞」写望海楼明照曙霞——那「望海楼明」写望海楼明,「照曙霞」写照曙霞,写尽曙霞的楼明;「护江堤白踏晴沙」写护江堤白踏晴沙——那「护江堤白」写护江堤白,「踏晴沙」写踏晴沙,写尽江堤的晴沙。这句的深意在于:它以「望海楼明照曙霞」的照曙霞与「护江堤白踏晴沙」的踏晴沙,写尽曙霞的江堤——望海楼明照曙霞,那「望海楼明照曙霞」写尽曙霞的楼明——望海楼明照曙霞,正是楼照朝霞的写照,那「照曙霞」写尽曙霞的江堤;护江堤白踏晴沙,那「护江堤白踏晴沙」写尽江堤的晴沙——护江堤白踏晴沙,正是堤白沙晴的写照,那「踏晴沙」写尽曙霞的江堤;那「望海楼明照曙霞」写尽曙霞的楼明,那「护江堤白踏晴沙」写尽江堤的晴沙,一写楼明,一写堤白,写尽曙霞的江堤——楼照朝霞而堤踏晴沙,正是春望的写照;此二句以楼明、堤白写尽曙霞的江堤,也为下文的伍员庙作铺垫,也让此二句成为全诗写春望的核心与千古名句。若换作直说「望海楼明亮地照着朝霞,护江的堤坝洁白,走在晴沙上」,则失其气象;唯以「望海楼明照曙霞」写照曙霞、「护江堤白踏晴沙」写踏晴沙,写尽曙霞的江堤,也让此二句成为全诗写春望的核心。
The tower. The Sea-Gazing Tower bright in dawn glow; the river-guard embankment white as one walks the sunlit sand. The dawn-lit tower and the white embankment on sunlit sand are the spring prospect. To have described the riverside at dawn would be a view; the Sea-Gazing Tower bright in dawn glow against the white embankment on sunlit sand is the view.
Study
Word focus
Related Reading
Bai Juyi's 'Walking in Early Spring by the Tiantang Lake' opens 'West of the Gu Monastery and north of the Pavilion, / the surface of the water just level, the clouds at its feet.' That poem walks, counts, and ends 'I love the east beyond the lake, / but I have had enough of walking'. This one stands still, takes in the whole city, and ends with a question about a road. Both are plain, both are about Hangzhou, and together they show the two habits of the same poet's eye — the counting eye and the panorama eye.
白居易《钱塘湖春行》「孤山寺北贾亭西,水面初平云脚低」写杭州,是白居易的名篇。此诗《杭州春望》则「望海楼明照曙霞」写杭州。同为白居易杭州诗,一写「最爱湖东行不足」的春行(钱塘湖春行),一写「草绿裙腰一道斜」的春望(杭州春望);一写湖边,一写楼望。两诗对读,可见白居易写杭州的两种笔法。
饮湖上初晴后雨 Drinking at the Lake, Fine Weather First, Then Rain 苏轼 · 同写杭州春景,一水光潋滟晴方好一涛声夜入伍员庙 Both write of Hangzhou's lake; Su Shi's poem praises the water, Bai Juyi's records the city.Su Shi's 'Drinking at the Lake, Fine Weather First, Then Rain' has 'Water bright as glass when the sun is good, / mountains misty when the rain is fine' and adds 'Give me the lake as a fair lady, / and West Lake is the beauty of Wu.' Where Bai Juyi reports what he sees, Su Shi defines the object by comparison. The two lines that both are famous for are equally confident, and the pair is usually set side by side as the two standard ways of praising Hangzhou — by accumulation, and by likening.
苏轼《饮湖上初晴后雨》「水光潋滟晴方好,山色空蒙雨亦奇」写杭州,是苏轼的名篇。此诗《杭州春望》则「涛声夜入伍员庙」写杭州。同为写杭州春景,一写「欲把西湖比西子」的苏轼(饮湖上初晴后雨),一写「红袖织绫夸柿蒂」的白居易(杭州春望);一写苏轼,一写白居易。两诗对读,可见唐宋写杭州的两种境界。