汉 Han · 诗 Poem
精列
The Fine Ordering (Jinglie)
厥初生,造划之陶物,莫不有终期。
莫不有终期。
圣贤不能免,何为怀此忧?
愿螭龙之驾,思想昆仑居。
思想昆仑居。
见期于迂怪,志意在蓬莱。
志意在蓬莱。
周礼圣徂落,会稽以坟丘。
会稽以坟丘。
陶陶谁能度?
君子以弗忧。
年之暮奈何,时过时来微。
The creating and the molding of the things, none is without the term of the end.
None is without the term of the end.
The sages and the worthies cannot be exempt, why then should one cherish this grief?
I wish for the chariot of the horned dragon, and think of the dwelling of the Kunlun.
I think of the dwelling of the Kunlun.
I see my term in the strange and the fantastic, and my mind's aim is in the Penglai.
My mind's aim is in the Penglai.
The Zhou rites and the sages passed away, and Kuaiji became the mound of the tomb.
Kuaiji became the mound of the tomb.
The joyous and the easy, who can pass through it? The gentleman does not grieve for it.
The evening of the years, what is to be done? The time passes and the time to come is faint.
Meaning
A yuefu of Cao Cao's later years, written in the dozen years after the Battle of the Red Cliff (208) to his death (220). The poem faces directly the necessity of the 'none is without the term of the end' of the ten thousand things and the 'the sages and the worthies cannot be exempt' of the death: 'at the very beginning of the birth, the creating and the molding of the things, none is without the term of the end,' and 'the sages and the worthies cannot be exempt, why then should one cherish this grief?'—the necessity of the death and the questioning of the grief; then the wish of the immortals: 'I wish for the chariot of the horned dragon, and think of the dwelling of the Kunlun... my mind's aim is in the Penglai,' the wish of the transcendence; and the fall: 'the Zhou rites and the sages passed away, and Kuaiji became the mound of the tomb,' the sages and the sage-kings all returning to the tombs, the negation of the immortality; and the close, 'the joyous and the easy, who can pass through it? The gentleman does not grieve for it. The evening of the years, what is to be done? The time passes and the time to come is faint'—the free-and-easy of the 'the gentleman does not grieve' and the faint of the 'the time passes and the time to come is faint,' the real mood of Cao Cao's later years: clearly recognizing the death, yet not willing to sink in the grief.
天地最初的生机(万物始生)啊——天地造划、陶铸的万物,没有一样不有终结的期限。没有一样不有终结的期限。圣贤也逃不过这终结,既然如此,又何必为此忧怀呢?但愿能乘上螭龙拉的车驾,心中向往着昆仑山上的仙境居所。心中向往着昆仑居。期望于神仙怪异之事,志意在于蓬莱仙山。志意在于蓬莱。制礼作乐的圣哲也终归殂落,如大禹葬于会稽,只剩下一座坟丘。只剩下一座坟丘。谁能像陶陶然和乐的人那样超然度过呢?君子因此不再忧愁。年岁已暮,无可奈何,时光已过,来日无多了。
Appreciation
The poem is short in form yet strict in composition, the feeling advancing layer on layer. It rises with the three-character 'at the very beginning of the birth,' drawing the vision to the very beginning of the heaven and the earth; then the 'the creating and the molding of the things, none is without the term of the end' proposes the proposition of the whole poem: the ten thousand things have the end; 'the sages and the worthies cannot be exempt' pushes the proposition to the utmost, then 'why then should one cherish this grief?' turns at once, from the grief to the free-and-easy. The middle turns to the wandering of the immortals: 'I wish for the chariot of the horned dragon, and think of the dwelling of the Kunlun... my mind's aim is in the Penglai,' the wish of the transcendence; and 'the Zhou rites and the sages passed away, and Kuaiji became the mound of the tomb' falls suddenly, with the fact of the sages and the sage-kings all returning to the mounds of the tombs, calmly negating the wish of the wandering of the immortals; and the close, 'the joyous and the easy, who can pass through it? The gentleman does not grieve for it,' the free-and-easy of the gentleman, and the 'the time passes and the time to come is faint' the faint and the desolate of the evening of the years, the whole poem from the grief to the wish to the free-and-easy, the real mood of the later years of Cao Cao.
【白话串讲】 曹操写《精列》:“厥初生,造划之陶物,莫不有终期”——万物都有终结。“圣贤不能免,何为怀此忧”——“愿螭龙之驾,思想昆仑居”——“志意在蓬莱”——他叹人生有终,想求仙。 【意象与手法】 全诗以万物有终的清醒立骨,以复沓章法咏叹(莫不有终期、思想昆仑居等句反复重唱);中段游仙之想(螭龙、昆仑、蓬莱)与圣贤必死(会稽坟丘)的冷静相碰撞,终以陶陶谁能度、君子以弗忧的设问自答收束,一波三折,由悲而幻、由幻而醒、由醒而达。 【情感与主旨】 此诗写曹操晚年对生死的思考:万物有终、圣贤不免的清醒认识,游仙长生的浪漫企慕,与君子弗忧的达观自解,三者交织,正是曹操暮年既知天命、又不甘沉溺忧惧的真实心态,也见其借乐府旧题写新意的创作主张。 【名句点睛】 圣贤不能免,何为怀此忧以设问由悲转达;陶陶谁能度?君子以弗忧以自答收束全篇,达观中见苍凉,是建安风骨慷慨任气的深层体现。
Background
The poem is a yuefu of Cao Cao's later years, of the 'Harmonious Songs,' written in the dozen years after the Battle of the Red Cliff (208) to his death (220). In his early years Cao Cao took the pacification of the world as his aim, and in the thirteenth year of Jian'an was defeated at the Red Cliff, the enterprise of the unification obstructed; thereafter he went through the death of Xun Yu, the great plague of Jian'an, and other changes, and in his later years, with the many illnesses, his thought on the problem of the life and the death grew ever deeper. The poem is the product of this background: facing directly the necessity of the 'none is without the term of the end' of the ten thousand things and the 'the sages and the worthies cannot be exempt' of the death, and the wish of the immortals of the 'the chariot of the horned dragon' and the 'the mind's aim is in the Penglai,' and finally closing with the free-and-easy of the 'the gentleman does not grieve,' the real mood of Cao Cao's later years: clearly recognizing the death, yet not willing to sink in the grief. With the 'Tortoise Lives Long,' the 'Gazing at the Vast Ocean,' and the 'Though the Cold Pine' the poems of the later years of the same vein.
《精列》是曹操晚年的乐府诗,属《相和歌辞》,约作于建安十三年(208)赤壁之战以后至其逝世前(220)的十余年间。曹操早年以平定天下为志,建安十三年败于赤壁,统一之业受阻;此后又历经荀彧之死、建安大疫等变故,暮年多病,对生死问题的思考日益深挚。《精列》即此背景下的产物:诗中直面万物有终、圣贤不能免的必然,又生出愿螭龙之驾、志意在蓬莱的游仙之想,终以君子以弗忧的达观收束,正是曹操晚年既清醒认识死亡、又不甘于沉溺忧惧的真实心态。此诗与《龟虽寿》《短歌行》《观沧海》等同为曹操乐府的代表作,体现了其借乐府旧题写新意的创作主张与清峻通脱的建安诗风,也是研究曹操晚年生命观的第一手材料。诗中造划、陶物等古语,亦见曹操以古为体、以质为文的一贯作风,与建安文坛尚通脱、重气韵的风气相合。由此诗亦可见,曹操虽为一代枭雄,而其于生死之际的思索,与常人之忧乐并无二致,尤显其人性的深度。
Art
The art is the strict composition and the feeling advancing layer on layer: the rise with the very beginning of the heaven and the earth, the proposition of the 'none is without the term of the end,' the push of the 'the sages and the worthies cannot be exempt,' the turn of the 'why then should one cherish this grief,' the wish of the wandering of the immortals, the fall of the negation, and the close of the free-and-easy—from the grief to the wish to the free-and-easy, the deep and the desolate of the later years of Cao Cao.
此诗体制短小而章法谨严,情感层层推进。起以厥初生三言起兴,把视野拉到天地之初;继以造划之陶物、莫不有终期提出全诗命题:万物有终;圣贤不能免把命题推到极致,随即何为怀此忧一转,由悲入达。中段转入游仙:愿螭龙之驾、思想昆仑居、志意在蓬莱,写超越之愿;而周礼圣徂落、会稽以坟丘猛然一跌,以圣贤圣王皆归丘土的事实,冷静地否定游仙之想的现实性——昆仑蓬莱可望而不可即,圣贤尚且不免,何况凡人?终以陶陶谁能度、君子以弗忧的设问自答收束,归于达观。全诗一波三折:有终之忧、游仙之愿、圣贤之死、君子弗忧,四层转折,由悲而幻、由幻而醒、由醒而达,在极短的篇幅内完成一次完整的生命思考。手法上以复沓强化咏叹(每句重复)、以设问推进思辨(何为怀此忧/陶陶谁能度)、以典实证哲理(会稽坟丘),古朴而不失跌宕,正是曹操诗沉雄悲壮的典型。
Allusions
The allusions of the poem are few, yet all from the classics, the ancient air full. 'The creating and the molding' takes the meaning of the creating and the molding of the ten thousand things by the heaven and the earth, its thought from the generation of the 'the Way gives birth to the one, the one gives birth to the two' of the Laozi and the cosmology of the response of the heaven and the man of the Han, the pottery-maker's making of the vessels for the creating of the heaven and the earth, the common metaphor of the Han. 'I wish for the chariot of the horned dragon' inherits the tradition of the wandering of the immortals of the 'driving the green dragon and the white chi as the team' of the 'Crossing the River' of the Nine Chapters of the Songs of Chu; and the 'Kunlun' and the 'Penglai' are the dwelling places of the immortals of the Chinese mythology, the wish of the transcendence of the poem.
此诗用典不多,而皆取之经典,古意盎然。造划与陶物取天地造化陶铸万物之意,其思想源于《老子》道生一、一生二的生成论与汉代天人感应的宇宙观,以陶工制器喻天地造物,是汉人习见的比喻。愿螭龙之驾承《楚辞·九章·涉江》驾青虬兮骖白螭的游仙传统,螭龙、青虬皆龙属,自屈原始,龙驾已是游仙诗中飞升的固定坐骑。思想昆仑居、志意在蓬莱并举两大仙山:昆仑为西王母所居、众神之都(见《山海经》),蓬莱为海上三神山之一(见《史记·封禅书》),秦汉以来帝王求仙多以此二山为标的,曹操诗中并提,正见其游仙之思承自战国秦汉以来的求仙文化。会稽以坟丘用大禹葬于会稽之典(《史记·夏本纪》载帝禹东巡狩、至于会稽而崩),以大禹之圣、之功而终成坟丘,印证圣贤不能免的命题。陶陶谁能度化用《诗经·王风·君子阳阳》君子陶陶之句,以和乐之态写超脱之境。全诗典故皆化于议论与咏叹之中,古朴质实,正是汉乐府质胜于文的本色。
Commentary
The poem is the most profound of Cao Cao's poems of the wandering of the immortals and the key document of the understanding of the mood of the later years of Cao Cao. The critics of the later ages of the poetry of Cao Cao mostly praise its 'the air and the rhyme deep and grand,' and this poem is precisely the desolation in the depth and the grandeur: facing the necessity of the 'none is without the term of the end' of the ten thousand things, Cao Cao does not make the manner of the young child, but with the 'why then should one cherish this grief' and the 'the gentleman does not grieve' the free-and-easy of the hero, yet the faint of the 'the time passes and the time to come is faint' reveals the desolation of the hero in his later years, the deepest reflection of the life and the death of the Jian'an literature.
《精列》是曹操游仙诗中思想最深的一首,也是理解曹操晚年心态的关键文献。历代论曹操诗者,多推其气韵沉雄(敖陶孙《诗评》),此诗正见其沉雄中的苍凉:面对万物有终的必然,曹操不作小儿女之态,而是以何为怀此忧的理性、以君子以弗忧的达观自我开解,这种清醒与旷达的结合,正是建安风骨慷慨任气的深层内涵。就游仙诗史言,汉乐府游仙诗多写求仙之愿,而《精列》的独特处在于:既写游仙之愿,又清醒地以圣贤不能免否定其现实可能,终归于弗忧——这种在浪漫与理性之间的摇摆与平衡,使此诗超越了单纯求仙诗的境界,成为诗人对生死问题的哲学思考。曹操以乐府旧题写如此深挚的个人情怀,开建安文人诗借古题写新意的先河,对曹植《远游篇》及后世游仙诗皆有影响。此诗虽不如《短歌行》《观沧海》之广为传诵,然其思想之深刻,实为曹操诗中别具一格之作。
Prosody
Line by line
厥初生,
At the very beginning of the birth, (The rise with the three characters: the vision drawn to the very beginning of the heaven and the earth, the rise of the poem.)
天地最初的生机(万物始生)啊,万物由此而出,生生不息。
In the very beginning,
厥初生三字,是《精列》的起兴,写天地初生、万物肇始。厥,其、那,为上古汉语的语助词;初生即始生,指宇宙万物最初的诞生。以厥初生开篇,一下子把视野拉到时间的原点——不是从眼前的草木荣枯说起,而是从天地之始说起,为全篇讨论万物有终的命题立下宏阔的框架。此三字与《诗经》厥初生民(《大雅·生民》)同一句法,曹操乐府喜用古语,正见其取径风雅、以古为体的本色。三字一短句,音节古拙,如钟磬初鸣,为全诗的苍茫悲慨定下基调。
The poem opens at the origin. In the very beginning. The three-character line reaches for the world's start before arguing about its end. The archaic particle gives the tone of an ancient hymn. To have said in the beginning would be a start; the archaic in-the-very-beginning is the start.
造划之陶物,莫不有终期。
The creating and the molding of the things, none is without the term of the end. (The proposition: the creating and the molding of the ten thousand things by the heaven and the earth, none without the term of the end, the first proposition of the poem.)
天地造划、陶铸的万物,没有一样不有终结的期限。
All things the Creator shapes and molds have their appointed end.
此两句提出全诗的核心命题:万物皆有终期。造划即造化(划通化),指天地创造化育之力;陶物以陶工制器喻天地造物——陶铸万物,如窑烧陶,器物既成,终有毁时。一个陶字,把天地造物的过程写得具体可感,也暗含万物皆为人所造之器、器有尽时的隐喻。莫不有终期以双重否定写全称判断:无一例外,皆有终期。此句的哲学意味极浓:曹操直面万物有终的事实,不作回避,这种清醒的理性精神,正是其游仙诗与一般求仙诗的根本区别——他不自欺。
The proposition. All things the Creator shapes and molds have their appointed end. The potter metaphor (shapes like clay) makes the world a fired vessel, and every vessel breaks. The double negative (there is nothing without an end) is the full claim. To have said all things end would be a fact; the molded clay with its appointed end is the fact.
圣贤不能免,何为怀此忧?
The sages and the worthies cannot be exempt, why then should one cherish this grief? (The push and the turn: the sages and the worthies cannot be exempt from the death, and the 'why then should one cherish this grief' turns from the grief to the free-and-easy.)
圣贤也逃不过这终结的期限,既然如此,又何必为此忧怀呢?
Even sages cannot escape it; why then nurse this sorrow?
此两句由万物推及人类,再推及圣贤,层层收拢。圣贤不能免五字,把人类中最杰出者(圣、贤)也拉入有终期的必然之中——圣贤尚且不免,何况常人?这是把死亡的普遍性推到极致。然而紧接着何为怀此忧一转,却由悲转达:既然圣贤皆不能免,忧伤又有何用?此问句是全诗由悲入达的枢纽:曹操不因死亡之必然而陷入绝望,反而由此推出弗忧的结论。这种知其不可奈何而安之的达观,与《龟虽寿》神龟虽寿、犹有竟时……养怡之福、可得永年的思想一脉相承:正视有终,而求精神的永年。
The deduction. Even sages cannot escape it; why then nurse this sorrow? The poem first extends death to the sages, then asks what good grief does. The question is the turn from despair to acceptance. To have said even the wise die, so why grieve would be a consolation; the sages not escaping and the question about nursing sorrow are the consolation.
愿螭龙之驾,思想昆仑居。
I wish for the chariot of the horned dragon, and think of the dwelling of the Kunlun. (The wish of the immortals: the chariot of the horned dragon and the dwelling of the Kunlun, the wish of the transcendence.)
但愿能乘上螭龙拉的车驾,心中向往着昆仑山上的仙境居所。
I would I had a chariot drawn by hornless dragons; my heart longs for the dwelling on Kunlun.
此两句转入游仙之想,是全诗浪漫想象的高潮。螭龙是传说中无角的龙,《楚辞·九章·涉江》有驾青虬兮骖白螭之句,曹操愿乘螭龙之驾,正是承楚辞游仙传统,以龙驾飞升,超越尘世的桎梏。思想昆仑居写心向往之:昆仑是西王母所居、众神之山,在中国神话中是最高的仙山。愿、思想两词一表愿望、一表心念,写游仙之思的迫切与绵长。此两句与下文志意在蓬莱相承,昆仑、蓬莱两大仙山并提,把求仙之愿写到极致;而愿、思想皆出以向往之辞,正见其求仙是心愿而非现实,清醒与浪漫并存。
The yearning. I would I had a chariot drawn by hornless dragons; my heart longs for the dwelling on Kunlun. The immortals' mount (dragons) and immortals' mountain (Kunlun) are the poem's fantasy, knowingly entertained. The longing is the poem's frankness about its own wish. To have said he dreamed of immortals would be a wish; the dragon-chariot and the heart's longing for Kunlun are the wish.
周礼圣徂落,会稽以坟丘。
The Zhou rites and the sages passed away, and Kuaiji became the mound of the tomb. (The fall: the sages and the sage-kings all returning to the mounds of the tombs, the calm negation of the wish of the immortals.)
制礼作乐的圣哲也终归殂落,如大禹葬于会稽,只剩下一座坟丘。
The sage who made the rites is gone; at Kuaiyi there is only a burial mound.
此两句是全诗最沉痛的句子,也是清醒与浪漫的碰撞点。徂落即殂落,死亡;周礼圣指制礼作乐的圣人(后世通行本多作周孔圣,即周公、孔子)——连制礼作乐、垂范万世的圣人都死了;会稽以坟丘用大禹葬于会稽之典:大禹治水功盖万世,而终葬会稽,只剩坟丘一抔土。圣人之殂、圣王之王(禹),皆归于一丘之土,这是对有终期最沉重的印证,也是对前文游仙之想最冷静的否定:昆仑、蓬莱虽可向往,而圣贤皆死,仙山何在?两句以史实证哲理,字字千钧,全诗的苍凉之感至此达到顶点,而陶陶谁能度的达观正由此逼出。
The rebuttal. The sage who made the rites—Du Zhou, the model lawgiver—is gone; at Kuaiyi, where Yu the Great is buried, there is only a mound. The immortals' mountains are fantasies, but the sages' graves are facts. The two dead worthies are the poem's real answer to the dragon-chariot wish. To have said even the sages died would be a fact; the dead lawgiver and the single mound at Kuaiyi are the fact.
陶陶谁能度?君子以弗忧。
The joyous and the easy, who can pass through it? The gentleman does not grieve for it. (The close: the free-and-easy of the 'the gentleman does not grieve,' the return of the hero, the real mood of the later years.)
谁能像陶陶然和乐的人那样超然度过呢?君子因此不再忧愁。
Who can live that long, that joyous span? The wise man therefore does not grieve.
结句以设问与自答收束全篇,是曹操式达观的完成。陶陶是和乐的样子,《诗经·王风·君子阳阳》君子陶陶即其源;度可解为度过(此生)或超度(生死)。陶陶谁能度以反问提出:谁能真的陶陶然超脱生死之忧?答案即君子以弗忧:唯君子能不以死生为忧。此两句由年之暮奈何、时过时来微的感叹直逼而来:年暮已不可奈何,时过而来日微茫,忧亦无益,不如弗忧。全诗由莫不有终期的清醒,经愿螭龙之驾的浪漫,至君子以弗忧的达观,走完一个由悲到求仙再到超越的完整心路,正是曹操晚年人生哲学的诗化总结。
The ending. Who can live that long, that joyous span? The wise man therefore does not grieve. The joyful, unhurried span is the ideal; since no one reaches it, the wise man chooses not to grieve. The conclusion is acceptance rather than denial. To have said the wise accept death would be a conclusion; the unanswerable who and the wise man not grieving are the conclusion.
Study
Word focus
Related Reading
'Though the Tortoise Lives Long'—'though the tortoise lives long, yet there is the time when it ends... the old steed in the stable, its aim is still in the thousand li; the hero in his later years, his strong heart is not yet ended... the happiness of the heaven, one may obtain the long years'—seeks the long years, the 'the old steed in the stable, its aim is still in the thousand li' the strong heart of the later years. The 'Fine Ordering'—'none is without the term of the end, the sages and the worthies cannot be exempt... the joyous and the easy, who can pass through it? The gentleman does not grieve for it'—values the non-grief, the facing of the death and the free-and-easy. One seeking the long years and one valuing the non-grief; one the 'the strong heart is not yet ended' and one the 'the gentleman does not grieve'—the two declarations of the will of the later years of Cao Cao, the two faces of the hero's reflection on the life and the death.
《龟虽寿》神龟虽寿,犹有竟时。腾蛇乘雾,终为土灰……老骥伏枥,志在千里。烈士暮年,壮心不已,与《精列》同是曹操晚年的人生思考,同以神物(神龟、螭龙)起兴,同写万物有终(犹有竟时/莫不有终期)。差异在归宿:《龟虽寿》由有终推出养怡之福、可得永年的养生之志,更由老骥伏枥推出烈士暮年、壮心不已的进取之心,是向外的建功;《精列》由有终推出愿螭龙之驾的游仙之想,终归于君子以弗忧的达观,是向内的安顿。一进取一安顿,合观可见曹操晚年既壮心不已、又深知天命的两面,正是历史人物最真实的心态。
观沧海 The Vast Sea 曹操 · 同是曹操乐府,一写海岳气象一写游仙之思 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
《观沧海》东临碣石,以观沧海。水何澹澹,山岛竦峙……日月之行,若出其中。星汉灿烂,若出其里,与《精列》同属曹操乐府名篇,一写登临观海的气象,一写游仙长生的企慕。差异在境界:《观沧海》以大海吞吐日月星汉之象写胸襟之壮阔,是向外扩张的宇宙感;《精列》以昆仑蓬莱之思写超越死生之愿,是向上升腾的生命感。前者是建安风骨中志深笔长的典范,后者是其中慷慨多气的别调。两诗并读,可见曹操既观照客观世界的壮美,也执着主观生命的长度,正是其如幽燕老将、气韵沉雄(敖陶孙语)的完整面貌。
短歌行 Short Song 曹操 · 同是《相和歌辞》名篇,一叹人生一求贤才 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
《短歌行》对酒当歌,人生几何?譬如朝露,去日苦多……山不厌高,海不厌深。周公吐哺,天下归心,与《精列》同为曹操《相和歌辞》名篇,同以人生短促起兴(譬如朝露/莫不有终期)。差异在题旨与归宿:《短歌行》由人生苦短转向求贤若渴——唯有延揽人才、成就功业,才能超越生命的有限,是政治家的答案;《精列》由万物有终转向游仙与弗忧——昆仑蓬莱、君子弗忧,是诗人的答案。一建功一游仙,一外向一内敛,恰见曹操作为政治家与诗人的双重身份。两诗对读,可窥见同一颗心灵在功业与生命之间的徘徊,正是建安文学慷慨任气的深层底蕴。