汉 Han · 诗 Poem
诫子诗
A Poem of Counsel to My Son
明者处世,莫尚于中。
优哉游哉,与道相从。
首阳为拙,柳下为工。
饱食安步,以仕代农。
依隐玩世,诡时不逢。
才尽身危,好名得华。
有群贪禄,毋有奸邪。
是故知之,足下何如。
At ease, at leisure, they walk with the Way.
Shouyang was the clumsy way; Liuxia was the skilled.
Eat your fill, step at peace — let office stand in for the plow.
Lean to the hidden, jest with the world; shun the ill hour and meet no wrong.
Spend your gift and your person is endangered; court a name and win but show.
Keep with the throng in paid service, never turn to crooked ways.
So know this, my son — and what say you now?
Meaning
The clear-sighted man in the world values nothing higher than the middle way. At ease and free, he moves with the great Dao. Boyi and Shuqi starving on Shouyang was clumsiness; Liuxia Hui's easy virtue was skill. Eat your fill and walk at peace, letting office stand in for farming. Lean toward the hidden and jest with the age, avoiding ill-timed confrontation and meeting no harm. Spend your talent and your life is in danger; crave a name and gain only show. Better join the crowd in their stipend than harbor any crooked thought. So understand these things, my son — and what do you say?
明达的人立身处世,没有比“中庸”更高明的了。从容自得,与大道相随。伯夷叔齐饿死首阳是笨拙,柳下惠和而不流才是工巧。吃饱饭、安稳走路,以做官代替务农。依违隐显之间玩世不羁,避乖违之时而不遭逢其害。才华用尽则身危,贪求名声只落得浮华。宁可随众贪恋俸禄,也不可存心奸邪。所以这些道理你要知晓,你以为如何呢。
Appreciation
Dongfang Shuo, styled Manqian, served Emperor Wu of Han at the Golden Horse Gate, known for wit and jesting remonstrance. Under a mighty, suspicious ruler, talented men easily perished, so he survived by 'leaning to the hidden and jesting with the world' — jest without, lone anger within. This 'Poem of Counsel to My Son', a half-jesting, half-grave lesson to his descendants, is really his life-summary of self-preservation between throne and self, and a deep self-mockery at the scholar's plight under Han Wu. The poem is short four-character lines yet clearly stepped: it first sets the 'middle way' as the highest rule, then uses Boyi and Liuxia as opposite examples, making abstract philosophy concrete; it closes on the sharp warnings 'spend your gift and your life is in peril' and 'never turn to crooked ways', moving from jest to grave.
【白话串讲】 东方朔教儿子:“明者处世,莫尚于中”——聪明人处世,最重要的是中庸。“才尽身危,好名得华”——才华用尽会招祸,好名只会得到虚华。东方朔这个爱开玩笑的人,教起儿子来很认真。 【意象与手法】 全诗四言短促,却层递分明:先标“中庸”为处世极则,再以伯夷、柳下惠一拙一工正反设喻,将抽象哲理具象化 【情感与主旨】 东方朔字曼倩,汉武帝时待诏金马门,性诙谐,善以滑稽谏君 【名句点睛】 常考:一、主旨,须答“中庸自处、依隐玩世”的处世哲学与对专制的无奈自全;二、用典,分析伯夷、柳下惠一拙一工的反比
Background
Dongfang Shuo, styled Manqian, served Emperor Wu of Han at the Golden Horse Gate, a witty man who used jest to remonstrate. He lived under a mighty ruler where talented men often met ruin, so he kept himself by 'leaning to the hidden and jesting with the world' — jest without, lone indignation within. This 'Poem of Counsel to My Son', found in the Yiwen Leiju and kindred encyclopedias, teaches his sons a way to live in half-jesting, half-grave tones; in truth it sums up his own survival between imperial power and the self, and holds a deep self-mockery at the Han Wu court's condition for scholars.
《诫子诗》是西汉文学家东方朔所作的一首哲理短诗。东方朔(前154—前93),字曼倩,平原厌次人,汉武帝时官至太中大夫。东方朔以诙谐滑稽著称,然其内心实有深沉的处世智慧。此诗以四言写处世之道:明者处世,莫过于“中”(中庸之道),优游自得,与道相从;以伯夷饿死首阳山为“拙”,以柳下惠屈身事人为“工”;主张饱食安步、以仕代农,依隐玩世、不与世争;警戒“才尽身危,好名得华”,贪禄则生祸,惟当安守本分。全诗是东方朔的人生哲学总结——介于仕隐之间、明哲保身的“依隐玩世”之道。汉武之世,专制酷烈,士人动辄得咎,东方朔以滑稽自晦,正是看透了官场的险恶而采取的生存智慧。此诗以诫子为名,实是东方朔一生处世心得的遗嘱。
Art
The whole is short four-character lines yet clearly stepped: it first marks the 'middle way' as the highest rule, then uses Boyi and Liuxia as opposite examples — one clumsy, one skilled — to make abstract philosophy concrete; the middle 'eat full, walk calm' and 'lean to the hidden, jest with the world' writes the 'court-recluse' reality in plain, knowing speech, jest within roundness; it closes on the sharp warnings 'spend your gift and your life is in peril' and 'never harbor crooked ways', moving from jest to grave. The language seems play, yet care for life and grievance at the age stay between the lines — most true to Manqian's nature.
《诫子诗》艺术上以四言说理、言简意赅见长,是汉代哲理诗的佳作。全诗十六句,皆以警句式的短句说理:“明者处世,莫尚于中”开宗明义——明智者处世,莫过于“中”道;“优哉游哉,与道相从”写优游从容、与道同行;“首阳为拙,柳下为工”以伯夷、柳下惠对比——饿死首阳山(伯夷)是拙,屈身事人(柳下惠)是工,一正一反,点明全身之道;“饱食安步,以仕代农”写安于现状——饱食安步、以官代耕;“依隐玩世,诡时不逢”写依违于仕隐之间、以游戏态度处世、不与世道相忤;“才尽身危,好名得华”警戒才尽则危、好名则华而不实;“有群贪禄,毋有奸邪”写从众贪禄尚可,奸邪则不可为;“是故知之,足下何如”以反问作结——既知此理,你意下如何?全诗以四言警句说理,对仗工整,言简意深,末以设问收束,如师友相询,亲切有味。这种“以诗明理”的四言哲理诗,正是汉代士人处世哲学的诗化表达。
Allusions
'Shouyang was clumsy' uses Boyi and Shuqi refusing Zhou grain and starving on Shouyang — Dongfang Shuo deems their rigidity a loss of life; 'Liuxia was skilled' uses Liuxia Hui's easy yet unyielding virtue, praised as the apt, skilled way. The two examples set off each other, the core figures. 'Lean to the hidden and jest with the world' reworks the phrase from Dongfang Shuo's biography in the Han Shu, not a loose phrase. The references are all Confucian 'exit-and-entry' allusions turned to new sense, showing his indignation wrapped in jest.
《诫子诗》用典精当,皆取古人事迹以明理。“首阳”指首阳山,为伯夷、叔齐不食周粟、饿死之地,出《史记·伯夷列传》,此处以“首阳为拙”写其过于清高而自取其祸;“柳下”指柳下惠(展禽),鲁国贤人,三黜不去、屈身事人,出《论语》“柳下惠为士师,三黜”及《孟子》称其“圣之和者”,此处以“柳下为工”写其能屈能伸、全身保节;“优哉游哉”出《诗经·小雅·采菽》“优哉游哉,亦是戾矣”,写从容自得;“依隐玩世”取《史记》评东方朔“依隐玩世,诡时不逢”之语——东方朔以此自况,遂成其标签。全诗以史为鉴、以经为训,一句一事,正是汉代文人说理诗的典型用典方式。
Commentary
The Han Shu calls Shuo 'seeming a jester, never at a loss, seeming wise'. Moderns say this poem: on the surface it schools a son to fit in, but the line 'spend your gift and your life is in peril' lays bare the Han Wu court scholar's fear — blood and tears hide beneath the jest. His 'court-recluse' thought opens the Wei-Jin free-and-easy vein, giving later men a model of self-keeping under tyranny; his jest-wrapping-lone-anger brush opens the bamboo-grove freethinkers' ease, and is the unshakable source of later 'Dongfang Shuo-style' wisdom.
《诫子诗》是东方朔处世哲学的诗化总结,也是汉代士人“明哲保身”思想的代表。此诗以“中”为宗,以伯夷为拙、柳下为工,主张“依隐玩世”、不求闻达,正是汉武专制时代士人的生存智慧。东方朔一生滑稽自晦,世以为其诙谐,然此诗见其内心之清醒与深刻。历代论者或赏其通达,或议其圆滑,然身处暴君之朝,能全身保命、又不失其节,正是“用之则行,舍之则藏”的变通。此诗以四言警句说理,言简意深,与《古诗十九首》“生年不满百,常怀千岁忧”的处世之叹相通,皆见汉人对“生”的深沉思考。
Prosody
Line by line
明者处世,莫尚于中。优哉游哉,与道相从。
The wise man in the world values nothing above the mean; at ease and unhurried, he follows the Way.
明智的人处世,没有什么比“中道”更高明的。从容自在,与大道相随。
The wise man living in the world prizes nothing more than the mean; at ease and unhurried, he walks with the Way.
起四句开宗明义,点出全诗的处世宗旨。“明者处世,莫尚于中”以“明者”立论——明智的人处世,莫过于“中”道;“中”即中庸、中道,不偏不倚、不过不及,是儒家处世的核心;“优哉游哉,与道相从”写中道之境界——“优哉游哉”写从容自得之态(出《诗经》),与道相从写身心与道合一。四句一论一中,把“中”道作为处世的最高原则。这一开宗明义,为全诗定下基调:不是追求功名,而是求“中”得“道”、从容自适。以“明者”起笔,见出东方朔对人生的大彻大悟。
The will's opening principle. The wise man in the world values nothing above the mean; at ease and unhurried, he follows the Way. The mean (the Confucian middle) is the rule: no excess, no heroism. The at-ease-and-unhurried is the recommended bearing. To have said live moderately would be advice; the mean followed at an unhurried pace is the advice.
首阳为拙,柳下为工。饱食安步,以仕代农。
The Shouyang fast is clumsy; Liuxia's bending is the craft. Eat well, walk at ease, take office in place of farming.
饿死首阳山(如伯夷)是笨拙的,屈身事人(如柳下惠)才是精明的。吃饱穿暖、安然踱步,以做官代替务农。
Starving at Shouyang was clumsy; Liuxia's flexibility was the skill. Eat your fill, walk at ease, and take office instead of farming.
此四句以古人为鉴,写全身之道。“首阳为拙,柳下为工”以伯夷、柳下惠对举——伯夷不食周粟、饿死首阳山,虽清高而自取祸,故为“拙”;柳下惠三黜不去、屈身事人,能屈能伸而全身保节,故为“工”。这一“拙”一“工”,正是东方朔的处世取舍:不效伯夷之清高,而学柳下之通达。“饱食安步,以仕代农”写其实用之道——不求大富大贵,但求温饱安步,以官俸代农耕。四句以史为鉴、以实为用,把“明哲保身”的智慧写得具体而通透,正是看透世情后的清醒选择。
The historical examples. The Shouyang fast—Boyi's starvation rather than serve the new dynasty—was clumsy; Liuxia Hui's willingness to be dismissed again and again was the true skill. The poem rejects the heroic death and endorses the flexible survival. Eat well, walk at ease, take office in place of farming. The plainness is the practical philosophy. To have said be flexible rather than principled would be a choice; the clumsy Shouyang fast against the skillful Liuxia bending is the choice.
依隐玩世,诡时不逢。才尽身危,好名得华。
Dwell between reclusion and office, toy with the age, avoid its clashes. Talent exhausted invites danger; love of fame wins but show.
依违于仕隐之间、以游戏态度处世,不与世道相抵触。才学用尽则身危,好求名声则华而不实。
Dwell midway between office and withdrawal, take the world lightly, avoid its conflicts. Exhaust your talent and you risk your life; love fame and you get only show.
此四句写处世的态度与警戒。“依隐玩世,诡时不逢”写东方朔的处世方式——“依隐”是依违于仕与隐之间,“玩世”是以游戏的态度处世,“诡时不逢”是不与世道相违逆——这八个字正是东方朔一生处世的写照,也是《史记》评其“依隐玩世,诡时不逢”的化用;“才尽身危,好名得华”写其警戒——“才尽”则无用而危,“好名”则华而不实。四句一写态度、一写警戒,以“依隐”写其圆融,以“才尽”“好名”写其警惕。这种进退有度、不露锋芒的智慧,正是乱世士人的生存之道。
The method and the warnings. Dwell midway between office and withdrawal, take the world lightly, avoid its conflicts; exhaust your talent and you risk your life, love fame and you get only show. The first clause is Dongfang Shuo's own career (the court jester-sage), the second the cautions: don't overspend your gifts, don't parade your name. To have said keep a low profile would be advice; the between-office-and-withdrawal with the exhausted talent and the showy fame is the advice.
有群贪禄,毋有奸邪。是故知之,足下何如。
It is allowed to share the ordinary greed for salary, but never treachery. Since you know this, tell me, son, what do you think?
可以随众贪图俸禄,却不可有奸邪之心。既然知道这些道理,你(儿子)意下如何?
You may join the crowd in taking salary, but never commit treachery. Knowing all this now, what do you think, my son?
末四句以叮咛与设问收束,是全诗的归结。“有群贪禄,毋有奸邪”写其底线——随大流贪点俸禄尚可,奸邪之事则万万不可为。这一句见出东方朔的处世伦理:不是不做官、不取禄,而是不害人、不奸邪,于随俗中守住道德的底线;“是故知之,足下何如”以设问作结——“足下”指儿子,“何如”是问其意,如师友相询,亲切中见叮咛。全诗由“中道”起,由“戒奸邪”收,首尾一贯,把明哲保身与道德底线统一起来,正是东方朔留给儿子的处世遗嘱,也是汉人人生智慧的浓缩。
The bottom line and the question. You may join the crowd in taking salary, but never commit treachery. Knowing all this, what do you think? The permission to take salary is the realistic concession; the prohibition on treachery is the retained moral floor. The final question to the son makes the poem a conversation. To have said be honest while making a living would be a rule; the permitted salary against the forbidden treachery, and the question to the son, are the rule.
Study
Word focus
Related Reading
Compare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
《古诗十九首·西北有高楼》“西北有高楼,上与浮云齐”以高楼之孤高写知音难遇之慨,与东方朔《诫子诗》同为汉代士人对“生”与“遇”的思考。差异在取向:东方朔求“中道”以保身,是清醒的处世智慧;古诗写高楼之孤、弦歌之悲,是深沉的知音之叹。一以哲理自守,一以感慨抒情。两诗并读,可见汉人面对人生的两副面孔——理性的自保与情感的悲慨。
短歌行 Short Song 曹操 · 同为四言言志,一诫子保身一求贤立业,一隐一显 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
曹操《短歌行》“对酒当歌,人生几何”以四言写求贤若渴、建功立业的雄心,与东方朔《诫子诗》同为四言言志。差异在志趣:东方朔诫子保身,主张“依隐玩世”、明哲全身;曹操慷慨求贤,主张“周公吐哺,天下归心”、积极有为。一隐一显、一退一进,正见乱世中士人(与枭雄)的不同选择。两诗并读,可见四言诗在汉末的两种精神方向。
归园田居·其一 Returning to Live in the Countryside (No. 1) 陶渊明 · 同为士人人生选择,一诫子保身一归园自适,一显一隐 Related readingCompare this related work with the poem above through theme, imagery, tone, and emotional movement.
陶渊明《归园田居·其一》“少无适俗韵,性本爱丘山”写其弃官归隐、复返自然之乐,与东方朔《诫子诗》同为士人的人生选择。差异在取向:东方朔诫子“依隐玩世”,身在朝而心在世,是明哲保身的智慧;陶渊明归园田居,身在野而心自适,是回归本真的选择。一“隐于朝”,一“隐于野”;一求全身,一求全性。两诗并读,可见中国士人“出处”之道的两种境界。